Original Text(~250 words)
PART V - CHAPTER III “Pyotr Petrovitch,” she cried, “protect me... you at least! Make this foolish woman understand that she can’t behave like this to a lady in misfortune... that there is a law for such things.... I’ll go to the governor-general himself.... She shall answer for it.... Remembering my father’s hospitality protect these orphans.” “Allow me, madam.... Allow me.” Pyotr Petrovitch waved her off. “Your papa as you are well aware I had not the honour of knowing” (someone laughed aloud) “and I do not intend to take part in your everlasting squabbles with Amalia Ivanovna.... I have come here to speak of my own affairs... and I want to have a word with your stepdaughter, Sofya... Ivanovna, I think it is? Allow me to pass.” Pyotr Petrovitch, edging by her, went to the opposite corner where Sonia was. Katerina Ivanovna remained standing where she was, as though thunderstruck. She could not understand how Pyotr Petrovitch could deny having enjoyed her father’s hospitality. Though she had invented it herself, she believed in it firmly by this time. She was struck too by the businesslike, dry and even contemptuous menacing tone of Pyotr Petrovitch. All the clamour gradually died away at his entrance. Not only was this “serious business man” strikingly incongruous with the rest of the party, but it was evident, too, that he had come upon some matter of consequence, that some exceptional cause must have brought him and that therefore something was going to happen. Raskolnikov,...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Raskolnikov finds himself in an impossible position as the investigation closes in around him. Porfiry Petrovitch, the clever examining magistrate, continues his psychological cat-and-mouse game, dropping hints that he knows more than he's saying. The conversation becomes increasingly tense as Porfiry seems to be testing Raskolnikov's reactions, watching for any sign of guilt or panic. Meanwhile, Raskolnikov struggles to maintain his composure while his inner torment grows stronger. The chapter reveals how guilt doesn't just disappear after a crime - it festers and grows, making every conversation feel like a trap. Raskolnikov's attempts to appear normal only make him seem more suspicious, showing how the cover-up can be harder than the original act. This psychological pressure cooker demonstrates a universal truth: we can't outrun our conscience forever. The chapter also explores how isolation makes everything worse - Raskolnikov has no one to confide in, so his guilt compounds daily. His relationship with his family becomes strained as he tries to protect them while battling his own demons. The tension builds as readers see how one terrible decision creates a domino effect, touching every aspect of his life. Dostoevsky masterfully shows how crime doesn't just harm victims - it destroys the perpetrator from within. The chapter serves as a powerful reminder that our actions have consequences we can't always predict or control, and that trying to live with a terrible secret can be its own form of prison.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Examining magistrate
A Russian legal official who investigates crimes and questions suspects before trial. In Dostoevsky's time, these magistrates had broad powers to conduct psychological interrogations. Understanding this role helps explain why Porfiry can toy with Raskolnikov so freely.
Psychological interrogation
A questioning technique that focuses on reading the suspect's emotions and reactions rather than just gathering facts. Porfiry uses this method to unnerve Raskolnikov without direct accusations. This approach reveals guilt through behavior rather than evidence.
Cat-and-mouse game
A situation where one person (the cat) toys with another (the mouse) who is trapped or vulnerable. Porfiry deliberately plays with Raskolnikov's nerves, dropping hints and watching his reactions. This creates unbearable psychological pressure.
Nihilism
A 19th-century Russian philosophical movement rejecting traditional moral and religious values. Some young intellectuals like Raskolnikov believed they could create their own moral rules. This thinking contributed to his justification for murder.
Conscience
The inner voice that judges our actions as right or wrong. Dostoevsky shows how conscience can't be silenced through rational arguments or willpower. Even when we think we've justified our actions, guilt finds a way to surface.
Isolation
The state of being cut off from others, either physically or emotionally. Raskolnikov's crime forces him into psychological isolation because he can't share his burden. This loneliness amplifies his guilt and paranoia.
Characters in This Chapter
Raskolnikov
Tormented protagonist
Struggles to maintain his composure under Porfiry's psychological pressure while battling intense inner guilt. His attempts to appear normal only make him more suspicious, showing how the cover-up becomes harder than the original crime.
Porfiry Petrovitch
Cunning antagonist
The examining magistrate who uses psychological tactics to unnerve Raskolnikov without making direct accusations. He drops hints and watches reactions, creating a trap that tightens with each conversation.
Dunya
Concerned sister
Raskolnikov's sister who senses something is deeply wrong with her brother but doesn't know what. Her presence adds to his torment as he tries to protect her while hiding his terrible secret.
Pulcheria Alexandrovna
Worried mother
Raskolnikov's mother whose love and concern become another source of his psychological burden. Her faith in him makes his guilt even more unbearable as he realizes how his crime affects his family.
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how investigators and authority figures use indirect questions and casual observations to create psychological pressure and elicit reactions.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Pain and suffering are always inevitable for a large intelligence and a deep heart."
Context: Reflecting on Raskolnikov's psychological torment as the investigation intensifies.
This quote reveals Dostoevsky's belief that sensitive, intelligent people suffer more deeply because they understand the full weight of their actions. It explains why Raskolnikov can't simply dismiss his guilt through rational arguments.
"We've got plenty of time. Time is nothing to us."
Context: Speaking to Raskolnikov during their tense psychological duel.
Porfiry's casual tone masks a threat - he's telling Raskolnikov that he can wait as long as necessary for him to break. This creates unbearable psychological pressure by suggesting the game will continue indefinitely.
"I wanted to become a Napoleon, that is why I killed her."
Context: Internal reflection on his motivations for the murder.
This reveals Raskolnikov's grandiose self-image and his belief that extraordinary people can transgress moral boundaries. It shows how intellectual pride can lead to moral blindness and justify terrible actions.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
Thematic Threads
Guilt
In This Chapter
Raskolnikov's inner torment manifests as paranoia during his conversation with Porfiry, making him overinterpret every word
Development
Evolved from initial shock after the murders to this consuming psychological prison
Isolation
In This Chapter
Unable to confide in anyone, Raskolnikov's burden grows heavier and his judgment becomes more distorted
Development
Deepened from earlier chapters where he began withdrawing from family and friends
Deception
In This Chapter
The effort to appear innocent makes Raskolnikov seem more suspicious, creating a self-defeating cycle
Development
Advanced from simple lies to complex psychological warfare with himself
Class
In This Chapter
Porfiry's educated, methodical approach contrasts with Raskolnikov's desperate attempts to maintain his intellectual facade
Development
Continued exploration of how social position affects power dynamics in crisis
Identity
In This Chapter
Raskolnikov struggles to reconcile his self-image as a rational person with his irrational crime and behavior
Development
His fractured sense of self becomes more pronounced under interrogation pressure
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Rodion's story...
Rodion sits across from his former supervisor Marcus at the coffee shop where they agreed to meet. Marcus keeps circling back to the incident at the warehouse - the 'accident' that got the night shift supervisor fired and opened up the position Rodion desperately needed. 'Funny how things work out,' Marcus says, stirring his coffee slowly. 'Camera was broken that exact night. Real convenient timing.' Rodion forces a laugh, but his hands shake as he reaches for his cup. Every casual comment feels loaded with meaning. When Marcus mentions seeing Rodion's car near the warehouse that evening, Rodion's stomach drops. He tries to explain he was just driving around, couldn't sleep, but the words sound hollow even to him. Marcus nods thoughtfully, then changes the subject to Rodion's family, asking how his sister's doing with her nursing school loans. The kindness feels like a trap. Rodion realizes Marcus knows - maybe not everything, but enough. The promotion he sabotaged someone else to get now feels like a noose around his neck. Every shift, every interaction with coworkers who trust him, becomes another layer of the lie he has to maintain.
The Road
The road Raskolnikov walked in 1866, Rodion walks today. The pattern is identical: guilt transforms every conversation into an interrogation, making the guilty party their own worst enemy through hypervigilance and overreaction.
The Map
This chapter provides the navigation tool of recognizing when guilt is distorting perception. Rodion can learn to separate actual threats from guilt-induced paranoia by asking: 'Is this person actually suspicious, or am I projecting my own fear?'
Amplification
Before reading this, Rodion might have believed he could simply tough it out and the guilt would fade with time. Now they can NAME the guilt-paranoia feedback loop, PREDICT how it will make neutral interactions feel threatening, and NAVIGATE it by seeking one safe outlet for the emotional pressure.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific behaviors does Raskolnikov display that make Porfiry suspicious, even though Porfiry has no concrete evidence?
- 2
Why does trying to act 'normal' when carrying guilt often backfire and make someone appear more suspicious?
- 3
Think of a time when someone around you was clearly hiding something - what gave them away? How did their behavior change?
- 4
If you were advising someone who made a serious mistake and is now spiraling in guilt and paranoia, what would you tell them to do differently than Raskolnikov?
- 5
What does this chapter reveal about how secrets affect not just the secret-keeper, but their relationships with everyone around them?
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Guilt Radar
Think about a time when you suspected someone was hiding something from you - a coworker, family member, or friend. Write down what specific behaviors tipped you off. Then flip it: recall a time when you were hiding something. What did you do that probably gave you away? Compare your two lists and identify the common patterns that reveal when someone is carrying a secret.
Consider:
- •Notice how guilt changes normal conversation patterns - do people become more defensive, change subjects quickly, or over-explain simple things?
- •Consider whether the fear of being caught is often worse than the actual consequences of honesty
- •Think about how carrying secrets affects your energy and relationships, even with people who have nothing to do with the original issue
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 30: Svidrigailov's Confession
In the next chapter, you'll discover hearing another's confession to understand your own, and learn shared guilt creates unlikely bonds. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.