Original Text(~250 words)
ARGUMENT. THE TRIAL OF THE ARMY, AND CATALOGUE OF THE FORCES. Jupiter, in pursuance of the request of Thetis, sends a deceitful vision to Agamemnon, persuading him to lead the army to battle, in order to make the Greeks sensible of their want of Achilles. The general, who is deluded with the hopes of taking Troy without his assistance, but fears the army was discouraged by his absence, and the late plague, as well as by the length of time, contrives to make trial of their disposition by a stratagem. He first communicates his design to the princes in council, that he would propose a return to the soldiers, and that they should put a stop to them if the proposal was embraced. Then he assembles the whole host, and upon moving for a return to Greece, they unanimously agree to it, and run to prepare the ships. They are detained by the management of Ulysses, who chastises the insolence of Thersites. The assembly is recalled, several speeches made on the occasion, and at length the advice of Nestor followed, which was to make a general muster of the troops, and to divide them into their several nations, before they proceeded to battle. This gives occasion to the poet to enumerate all the forces of the Greeks and Trojans, and in a large catalogue. The time employed in this book consists not entirely of one day. The scene lies in the Grecian camp, and upon the sea-shore; towards the end...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Zeus sends a deceptive dream to Agamemnon, promising easy victory over Troy if he attacks immediately. But this is a trap—Zeus wants to show the Greeks how much they need Achilles. Agamemnon decides to test his army's loyalty through reverse psychology, telling them they should give up and go home, expecting his commanders to rally the troops. The plan backfires spectacularly. The moment Agamemnon suggests retreat, the entire army erupts in joy and rushes to prepare their ships for departure. Nine years of war have taken their toll, and the soldiers are desperate to see their families again. Only the quick thinking of Odysseus saves the situation. He borrows Agamemnon's royal scepter and uses a combination of inspiration and intimidation to stop the exodus. He speaks respectfully to the nobles but physically beats a commoner named Thersites who dares criticize Agamemnon publicly. Thersites voices what many think but cannot say—that this war benefits only the leaders while common soldiers die for someone else's honor. After restoring order, Odysseus reminds everyone of the prophecy that Troy will fall in the tenth year. Nestor suggests organizing the troops by nationality before battle, which leads to a massive military parade. The chapter ends with detailed catalogs of both Greek and Trojan forces, emphasizing the enormous scale of this conflict. This episode reveals how fragile leadership authority can be when people are exhausted and demoralized, and how skilled communicators can redirect mass emotions.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Divine Deception
When gods in Greek literature deliberately mislead mortals to serve their own purposes. Zeus sends Agamemnon a false dream promising easy victory, knowing it will actually lead to disaster.
Modern Usage:
We see this pattern when authority figures give false assurances to manipulate people into risky decisions.
Reverse Psychology
Agamemnon's strategy of suggesting retreat to test his army's commitment, expecting them to refuse and demand to fight. The tactic completely backfires when everyone eagerly agrees to leave.
Modern Usage:
Parents and managers still use this technique, though it can blow up in your face if people call your bluff.
War Weariness
The exhaustion and demoralization that sets in during prolonged conflicts. After nine years of fighting, the Greek soldiers are desperate to go home to their families.
Modern Usage:
We see this in any long-term struggle - from military deployments to difficult work projects where people lose motivation over time.
Class Privilege
The double standard shown when Odysseus speaks respectfully to nobles but physically beats the commoner Thersites for saying the same criticisms.
Modern Usage:
This still happens when wealthy or connected people get gentle treatment while working-class people face harsh consequences for identical behavior.
Catalog of Ships
The detailed military roster listing all Greek and Trojan forces, their leaders, and home regions. This shows the massive scale of the conflict and serves as ancient propaganda.
Modern Usage:
Modern equivalents include military parades or detailed coverage of coalition forces to demonstrate strength and unity.
Royal Scepter
The ceremonial staff that symbolizes legitimate authority. Odysseus borrows Agamemnon's scepter to give his words official weight when stopping the army's exodus.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this with official titles, uniforms, or company logos that give someone's words extra authority.
Characters in This Chapter
Zeus
Divine manipulator
Sends a deceptive dream to Agamemnon, promising easy victory while actually planning Greek defeat. He's fulfilling his promise to Thetis to make the Greeks suffer without Achilles.
Modern Equivalent:
The CEO who sets up middle management to fail
Agamemnon
Failing leader
Falls for Zeus's trap and then compounds the error with his disastrous reverse psychology test. His leadership crisis nearly destroys the entire war effort in one morning.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss who creates problems trying to solve problems
Odysseus
Crisis manager
Saves the situation through quick thinking and skilled communication. He uses different approaches for different audiences - inspiration for nobles, intimidation for commoners.
Modern Equivalent:
The employee who has to clean up management's messes
Thersites
Truth-telling scapegoat
A common soldier who dares to criticize Agamemnon publicly, pointing out that leaders profit while regular troops die. He's beaten for speaking uncomfortable truths.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who says what everyone's thinking and gets fired for it
Nestor
Elder advisor
Provides the practical solution of organizing troops by nationality before battle. His experience and diplomatic skills help restore order and focus.
Modern Equivalent:
The veteran employee who knows how to actually get things done
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone says the opposite of what they want, hoping to manipulate your response.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when people use reverse psychology—'maybe we should just cancel' or 'fine, just quit'—and ask directly: 'Do you mean that, or are you hoping I'll react differently?'
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Now when the rosy-fingered Dawn appeared, Agamemnon rose from beside his beloved wife, and put on his soft tunic"
Context: Agamemnon prepares for the day after receiving Zeus's deceptive dream
The peaceful domestic scene contrasts sharply with the chaos about to unfold. Homer shows us a leader who has no idea he's walking into a trap set by the gods.
In Today's Words:
Agamemnon got up that morning thinking it was going to be a good day
"My friends, heroes, servants of Ares, Zeus has entangled me in grievous folly"
Context: Speaking to his commanders before testing the army
Agamemnon admits he's been deceived but doesn't realize he's about to make things worse. This shows how leaders often compound divine manipulation with human error.
In Today's Words:
Guys, I think I've been set up, but I have an idea that's probably going to backfire
"Thersites alone still chattered on, the uncontrolled of speech, whose mind was full of words"
Context: Introducing Thersites before his confrontation with Odysseus
Homer presents Thersites as a troublemaker, but his criticisms of the war are actually valid. This shows how power structures silence dissent by attacking the messenger.
In Today's Words:
There was this one guy who wouldn't shut up and always said what he thought
"It is no shame for a man to flee from evil"
Context: Trying to convince soldiers not to abandon the war
Odysseus acknowledges that wanting to go home is natural and reasonable, which makes his argument more persuasive than simply demanding obedience.
In Today's Words:
Look, nobody wants to be here, and that's totally understandable
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Reverse Psychology Backfire
When leaders use reverse psychology or indirect communication to control others, they often lose control as people take their words at face value rather than playing the intended psychological game.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Odysseus treats nobles with respect but physically beats the commoner Thersites for the same criticism, showing how class determines whose voice matters
Development
Building on earlier class tensions, now showing how power maintains itself through selective punishment
In Your Life:
You might notice how the same complaint gets different responses depending on who voices it at work or in community meetings
Authority
In This Chapter
Agamemnon's authority nearly collapses when his reverse psychology backfires, saved only by Odysseus borrowing his symbols of power
Development
Shows how fragile leadership becomes when it relies on manipulation rather than genuine respect
In Your Life:
You see this when managers or family leaders lose credibility through failed attempts at psychological manipulation
Communication
In This Chapter
The gap between what Agamemnon says and what he means creates chaos, while Odysseus succeeds through direct, targeted communication
Development
Introduced here as a central theme about the power and danger of words
In Your Life:
This appears whenever you use sarcasm or indirect hints instead of saying what you actually need from others
Exhaustion
In This Chapter
Nine years of war have left soldiers desperate to go home, making them vulnerable to any suggestion of escape
Development
Introduced here, showing how prolonged stress affects decision-making and loyalty
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in yourself or others after long periods of caregiving, difficult jobs, or family stress
Truth vs Power
In This Chapter
Thersites speaks uncomfortable truths about leaders benefiting while common people suffer, but gets beaten for it
Development
Introduced here as the tension between honest criticism and social order
In Your Life:
This shows up when you have to choose between speaking truth and maintaining your position in a workplace or family hierarchy
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Achilles's story...
Battalion Commander Martinez gets word from higher-ups that the next deployment will be easy—intelligence says the insurgents are weak, demoralized. But it's a setup to prove how much the unit needs their withdrawn star operator, Achilles, who's been refusing missions since being passed over for promotion. Martinez decides to test his soldiers' commitment by telling them maybe they should request to come home early, expecting his sergeants to rally the troops. Instead, the entire unit erupts in celebration. After eighteen months of brutal combat, they're desperate to see their families. Soldiers start calling their wives, making plans. Only Sergeant Rodriguez saves the situation, grabbing Martinez's authority and using a mix of inspiration and intimidation to restore order. He reminds everyone of their mission and the local allies counting on them. But the damage is done—Martinez's leadership credibility is shattered, and everyone now knows how badly the troops want out.
The Road
The road Agamemnon walked in ancient Troy, Martinez walks today on a forward operating base. The pattern is identical: leaders who use manipulation instead of honest communication often lose control of the very people they're trying to motivate.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for recognizing when authority figures are testing you through reverse psychology. Martinez's failed test teaches that exhausted people will grab any escape route offered, even if it wasn't meant seriously.
Amplification
Before reading this, Achilles might have fallen for manipulation tactics or used them himself without understanding the risks. Now they can NAME reverse psychology, PREDICT when it will backfire on stressed people, and NAVIGATE these situations with direct communication instead.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why did Agamemnon's test backfire so dramatically when he told his army they could go home?
analysis • surface - 2
What does the soldiers' instant joy at the prospect of leaving tell us about their true feelings after nine years of war?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen reverse psychology or sarcastic motivation fail in your own workplace, family, or relationships?
application • medium - 4
When someone uses manipulation tactics like Agamemnon's test, how can you respond without getting caught up in their game?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between authority that comes from position versus authority that comes from genuine respect?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Communication Gap
Think of a recent situation where someone said one thing but clearly meant another (sarcasm, reverse psychology, passive-aggressive hints). Write down what they actually said, what they probably meant, and what actually happened. Then rewrite how that conversation could have gone if they had communicated directly and honestly.
Consider:
- •Consider why the person chose indirect communication instead of being straightforward
- •Think about the emotional state of everyone involved - were people too stressed or tired for games?
- •Notice how manipulation often backfires when people take words at face value
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you used reverse psychology or sarcasm to try to motivate someone. What were you really hoping would happen? What actually happened? How might direct communication have worked better?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 3: The Duel That Changed Everything
What lies ahead teaches us to recognize when someone's ego writes checks their courage can't cash, and shows us divine intervention often comes when we least deserve it. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.