Original Text(~250 words)
THE SIRENS, SCYLLA AND CHARYBDIS, THE CATTLE OF THE SUN. “After we were clear of the river Oceanus, and had got out into the open sea, we went on till we reached the Aeaean island where there is dawn and sun-rise as in other places. We then drew our ship on to the sands and got out of her on to the shore, where we went to sleep and waited till day should break. “Then, when the child of morning, rosy-fingered Dawn, appeared, I sent some men to Circe’s house to fetch the body of Elpenor. We cut firewood from a wood where the headland jutted out into the sea, and after we had wept over him and lamented him we performed his funeral rites. When his body and armour had been burned to ashes, we raised a cairn, set a stone over it, and at the top of the cairn we fixed the oar that he had been used to row with. “While we were doing all this, Circe, who knew that we had got back from the house of Hades, dressed herself and came to us as fast as she could; and her maid servants came with her bringing us bread, meat, and wine. Then she stood in the midst of us and said, ‘You have done a bold thing in going down alive to the house of Hades, and you will have died twice, to other people’s once; now, then, stay here for the rest of the...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Odysseus faces three deadly challenges that test his leadership under impossible circumstances. First, the Sirens offer knowledge and wisdom through their deadly song—Odysseus wants to hear them but knows it means death. He finds a creative solution: his crew plugs their ears with wax while they bind him to the mast, letting him gain the knowledge while preventing disaster. Next comes an impossible choice between Scylla and Charybdis—a six-headed monster versus a ship-destroying whirlpool. Circe warns him there's no perfect option: lose six men to Scylla or risk losing everyone to Charybdis. Odysseus chooses to sacrifice six to save the rest, but doesn't tell his crew about Scylla beforehand, knowing they'd panic. Finally, they reach the island of the Sun God's cattle. Despite solemn oaths and clear warnings, Odysseus's starving crew slaughters the sacred animals while he sleeps. This act of desperation dooms them all—Zeus destroys their ship, and only Odysseus survives. The chapter reveals how leadership sometimes means making choices where someone gets hurt, how hunger and desperation can override wisdom, and how even the best leaders can't control everything. Odysseus learns that some prices are too high to pay, even for survival, and that a leader's greatest challenge isn't the external dangers—it's managing the human weaknesses within his own team.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Sirens
Mythical creatures who lured sailors to their deaths with irresistible songs that promised knowledge and wisdom. They represent the dangerous temptation of wanting to know everything, even when that knowledge comes at too high a price.
Modern Usage:
We use 'siren song' to describe any tempting offer that seems too good to be true and will probably hurt us.
Scylla and Charybdis
Two monsters positioned on opposite sides of a narrow strait, forcing travelers to choose between a six-headed beast that would kill some crew members or a whirlpool that would destroy the entire ship. This represents impossible choices where every option involves loss.
Modern Usage:
We say someone is 'between Scylla and Charybdis' when they face two equally bad options and have to pick the lesser evil.
Sacred cattle
The Sun God's immortal cattle that Odysseus's crew kills and eats despite knowing it will bring divine punishment. They represent the temptation to break rules or cross lines when we're desperate, even though we know there will be consequences.
Modern Usage:
This shows up whenever people make desperate choices they know are wrong - like stealing when broke or cheating when failing.
Hubris
Excessive pride or arrogance that leads to downfall. In this chapter, it's shown through the crew's belief they can break divine laws without consequences, and Odysseus's assumption he can control his men's actions.
Modern Usage:
We see hubris when people think rules don't apply to them or that they're too smart to get caught.
Impossible choice
A situation where every available option leads to harm or loss, forcing leaders to choose which damage is acceptable. Odysseus faces this repeatedly - lose some men to Scylla or risk losing everyone to Charybdis.
Modern Usage:
Parents, managers, and leaders face impossible choices daily - like cutting hours to save jobs or disciplining a child who's acting out from pain.
Crew mutiny
When followers rebel against their leader's orders, usually out of desperation or loss of faith. Odysseus's crew breaks their oath and kills the sacred cattle while he sleeps, dooming them all.
Modern Usage:
This happens in workplaces when employees stop following company policies, or in families when kids rebel against house rules.
Characters in This Chapter
Odysseus
Protagonist and ship captain
Faces three tests of leadership that show both his wisdom and his limitations. He cleverly solves the Siren problem, makes a calculated sacrifice at Scylla, but fails to prevent his crew's fatal mistake with the sacred cattle.
Modern Equivalent:
The department supervisor trying to keep everyone alive during layoffs
Circe
Mentor and advisor
Warns Odysseus about the dangers ahead and gives him strategies for survival. She's honest about the impossible choices he'll face, preparing him for leadership decisions where someone will get hurt.
Modern Equivalent:
The experienced coworker who tells you the real deal about office politics
The Sirens
Antagonists and tempters
Offer Odysseus knowledge and wisdom through their deadly song. They represent the seductive power of wanting to know everything, even when that knowledge comes at too high a price.
Modern Equivalent:
The gossip who knows everyone's secrets but spreads them everywhere
Odysseus's crew
Followers and victims
Despite swearing oaths and knowing the consequences, they kill the Sun God's cattle when hunger and desperation override their judgment. Their actions doom them all and show how fear can make people self-destruct.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworkers who break safety rules when the boss isn't watching
Scylla
Monster and unavoidable threat
A six-headed beast that Odysseus must sacrifice six men to in order to save the rest of his crew. She represents the harsh reality that sometimes leaders must choose who gets hurt.
Modern Equivalent:
The budget cuts that force managers to decide who gets laid off
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to identify when you're facing impossible choices where someone will get hurt no matter what you decide.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone presents you with a choice that seems to have only bad options—ask yourself what they're really asking you to sacrifice.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"You will have died twice, to other people's once"
Context: Circe greets Odysseus after his return from the underworld
This acknowledges that Odysseus has already survived what should have killed him and warns that more deadly challenges await. It shows how trauma and extreme experiences change a person - they've already 'died' in ways that others haven't.
In Today's Words:
You've been through hell and back, but it's not over yet
"It is better to lose six men and keep your ship than to lose your ship and your company entire"
Context: Advising Odysseus about the choice between Scylla and Charybdis
This is brutal leadership math - sometimes you have to sacrifice some to save the majority. It shows the horrible calculations leaders must make and why leadership is often a lonely burden.
In Today's Words:
Sometimes you have to cut losses to save what you can
"The hunger overcame our fear of death"
Context: Explaining why the crew killed the sacred cattle despite knowing it meant doom
This shows how desperation can override wisdom and self-preservation. When people are pushed to their limits, they'll often make choices that destroy them rather than endure the suffering.
In Today's Words:
We were so desperate we stopped caring about the consequences
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Impossible Choices
When survival requires choosing who gets hurt, leaders must make transparent trade-offs while bearing the full weight of those decisions.
Thematic Threads
Leadership
In This Chapter
Odysseus must make life-and-death decisions for his crew, balancing transparency with effectiveness
Development
Evolved from earlier heroic leadership to pragmatic survival management
In Your Life:
You might face this when managing a team through budget cuts or family crisis decisions
Information
In This Chapter
Knowledge becomes both weapon and burden—hearing Sirens, hiding Scylla's threat, knowing the cattle's curse
Development
Information consistently creates more problems than it solves throughout the journey
In Your Life:
You see this when deciding whether to share bad news that might make situations worse
Desperation
In This Chapter
Starving crew breaks sacred oaths to survive, choosing immediate relief over long-term consequences
Development
Physical needs increasingly override wisdom and planning as journey continues
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in financial decisions made under extreme pressure
Sacrifice
In This Chapter
Six men lost to Scylla, entire crew lost to divine punishment—survival requires accepting losses
Development
Introduced here as conscious leadership strategy rather than random misfortune
In Your Life:
You face this when choosing between competing loyalties in work or family situations
Control
In This Chapter
Even bound to the mast, Odysseus can't prevent his crew's final fatal choice while he sleeps
Development
Control continues to slip away despite increasing experience and wisdom
In Your Life:
You see this when your best efforts can't prevent others from making destructive choices
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Omar's story...
Omar just got promoted to shift supervisor at the packaging plant, but the company's cutting costs everywhere. First challenge: the new safety training videos everyone wants to see, but watching them means missing production quotas that could cost jobs. She finds a workaround—plays them during lunch breaks while she takes notes to share. Then corporate drops the real bomb: they're closing one of two production lines. She can fight it and probably lose both lines, or choose which one goes and save half the jobs. She picks the newer line with fewer families depending on it, but doesn't tell anyone until it's final—knowing the panic would make everything worse. Finally, when the plant's struggling to meet quotas, her crew starts cutting safety corners while she's in meetings. She knows they're desperate to keep their jobs, but when someone gets hurt, she's the one who has to answer for it. Every choice protects someone by putting someone else at risk.
The Road
The road Odysseus walked in ancient Greece, Omar walks today. The pattern is identical: leadership under impossible circumstances forces you to choose who gets hurt when you can't save everyone.
The Map
This chapter provides the navigation tool of calculated sacrifice—how to make impossible choices with clear reasoning rather than blind panic. Omar can use it to own her decisions completely rather than letting guilt paralyze her.
Amplification
Before reading this, Omar might have agonized over every hard choice, thinking good leaders never hurt anyone. Now she can NAME impossible situations, PREDICT when they're coming, NAVIGATE them by choosing the least harmful path while taking full responsibility.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Odysseus chose to sacrifice six men to Scylla rather than risk losing everyone to Charybdis. What information did he have that his crew didn't, and why didn't he share it?
analysis • surface - 2
When the crew ate the Sun God's cattle despite their oaths, they were starving and desperate. How does extreme need change people's ability to keep promises or follow rules?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about leaders you know—managers, parents, coaches. When have you seen someone make a decision that hurt some people to protect others? How did they handle it?
application • medium - 4
If you were in Odysseus's position facing Scylla and Charybdis, would you tell your crew about the six-headed monster beforehand? What are the risks of transparency versus secrecy in crisis situations?
application • deep - 5
The crew's hunger ultimately overrode their wisdom and oaths. What does this reveal about how physical desperation affects moral decision-making, and how should leaders account for this?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Impossible Choice
Think of a difficult decision you're facing or have faced where every option has a downside—maybe choosing between jobs, handling family conflict, or managing limited resources. Write out each option and honestly list what each choice costs and who pays that price. Don't try to find the perfect solution; instead, focus on understanding the trade-offs clearly.
Consider:
- •Who has the most to lose with each choice, and who can best absorb the cost?
- •What information do you have that others don't, and what are the risks of sharing versus keeping it private?
- •How might desperation or time pressure be affecting your judgment or others' ability to think clearly?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you had to choose between bad options. How did you make the decision? What would you do differently now, and what did you learn about leadership or responsibility from that experience?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 13: The Homecoming Deception
What lies ahead teaches us to recognize when gratitude and farewell rituals matter for future relationships, and shows us sometimes you need to hide your true identity to assess a situation safely. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.