Original Text(~250 words)
TELEMACHUS AND HIS MOTHER MEET—ULYSSES AND EUMAEUS COME DOWN TO THE TOWN, AND ULYSSES IS INSULTED BY MELANTHIUS—HE IS RECOGNISED BY THE DOG ARGOS—HE IS INSULTED AND PRESENTLY STRUCK BY ANTINOUS WITH A STOOL—PENELOPE DESIRES THAT HE SHALL BE SENT TO HER. When the child of morning, rosy-fingered Dawn, appeared, Telemachus bound on his sandals and took a strong spear that suited his hands, for he wanted to go into the city. “Old friend,” said he to the swineherd, “I will now go to the town and show myself to my mother, for she will never leave off grieving till she has seen me. As for this unfortunate stranger, take him to the town and let him beg there of any one who will give him a drink and a piece of bread. I have trouble enough of my own, and cannot be burdened with other people. If this makes him angry so much the worse for him, but I like to say what I mean.” Then Ulysses said, “Sir, I do not want to stay here; a beggar can always do better in town than country, for any one who likes can give him something. I am too old to care about remaining here at the beck and call of a master. Therefore let this man do as you have just told him, and take me to the town as soon as I have had a warm by the fire, and the day has got a little heat in...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Telemachus returns home to an emotional reunion with Penelope, bringing news from his journey but still no concrete word about Odysseus. Meanwhile, the disguised Odysseus and Eumaeus make their way to town, where they encounter Melanthius, a disloyal goatherd who kicks and insults the supposed beggar. Odysseus restrains himself from retaliation, showing remarkable self-control. At the palace, Odysseus observes his own home from the outside, noting its fine construction while appearing as a broken-down vagrant. The most heartbreaking moment comes when Argos, Odysseus's faithful hunting dog, recognizes his master after twenty years. Too weak to approach, the old dog wags his tail and dies moments after seeing Odysseus again - a powerful symbol of unwavering loyalty rewarded at last. Inside the hall, Odysseus begins begging from the suitors as part of his reconnaissance mission. Most give him scraps, but Antinous, the most arrogant suitor, not only refuses but hurls a footstool at him, striking his shoulder. Odysseus absorbs this humiliation while secretly plotting revenge. Even the other suitors are disturbed by Antinous's cruelty, warning him that gods sometimes disguise themselves as beggars. Penelope, hearing about the assault on the stranger, expresses her hatred for the suitors and requests to meet this traveler who might have news of her husband. The chapter masterfully builds tension while exploring themes of loyalty, patience, and the cost of maintaining one's cover when justice demands waiting for the right moment.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Xenia
The ancient Greek code of hospitality that required hosts to welcome strangers and guests to be respectful. Breaking this sacred law brought divine punishment. It's central to understanding why the suitors' behavior is so outrageous.
Modern Usage:
We still expect basic courtesy when someone's a guest in our home, and we judge people harshly when they abuse hospitality.
Recognition scene
A dramatic moment when someone's true identity is revealed, often through a token, scar, or behavior only they would know. These scenes build emotional tension and move the plot forward.
Modern Usage:
Movies and TV shows still use this device - think of any scene where someone realizes who someone really is after years apart.
Divine retribution
The belief that the gods will eventually punish wrongdoing, even if justice seems delayed. Characters often warn that mistreating strangers could anger disguised gods.
Modern Usage:
We express this as 'what goes around comes around' or 'karma will get you' - the idea that bad behavior eventually catches up to people.
Loyal retainer
A servant who remains faithful to their master despite danger, hardship, or pressure to betray. These characters represent unwavering loyalty and moral strength.
Modern Usage:
We see this in employees who stick with struggling companies, friends who defend you when you're not around, or anyone who stays loyal when it would be easier to switch sides.
Dramatic irony
When readers know something that characters in the story don't know. We know the beggar is really Odysseus, but most characters don't, which makes their actions more meaningful.
Modern Usage:
Reality TV uses this constantly - we see what's happening in different rooms while the contestants don't know what others are saying about them.
Hubris
Excessive pride or arrogance that leads to downfall. Characters who think they're above consequences often face the harshest punishments from gods or fate.
Modern Usage:
We see this in politicians, celebrities, or bosses who think rules don't apply to them and eventually face major consequences.
Characters in This Chapter
Odysseus
Disguised protagonist
Appears as a beggar to scout his own home and test people's character. Shows incredible self-control when insulted and attacked, gathering information for his revenge.
Modern Equivalent:
The undercover boss checking out their own company
Telemachus
Returning son
Returns home from his journey with new confidence and maturity. Reunites emotionally with his mother but maintains his cover about not knowing his father's fate.
Modern Equivalent:
The college kid coming home changed after their first semester away
Antinous
Primary antagonist
The most arrogant and cruel of the suitors. Throws a stool at the disguised Odysseus, showing his complete lack of respect for hospitality laws and basic human decency.
Modern Equivalent:
The workplace bully who picks on anyone they see as beneath them
Penelope
Grieving wife
Emotionally reunites with Telemachus and expresses her hatred for the suitors. Wants to meet the stranger who might have news of her husband, showing she never stops hoping.
Modern Equivalent:
The military spouse waiting for news about their missing partner
Argos
Faithful companion
Odysseus's old hunting dog who recognizes his master after twenty years but is too weak to approach. Dies content after seeing Odysseus return, representing perfect loyalty.
Modern Equivalent:
The old family dog who's been waiting by the door for their favorite person to come home
Melanthius
Disloyal servant
A goatherd who has betrayed his master's household. Kicks and insults the disguised Odysseus, showing how some people abandon loyalty for personal gain.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who throws their team under the bus to get ahead with new management
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how people reveal their true nature when they think they're dealing with someone powerless.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone treats service workers, new employees, or anyone they perceive as 'beneath them'—their behavior in these moments shows you exactly who they are.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I am too old to care about remaining here at the beck and call of a master."
Context: Speaking to Telemachus while disguised as a beggar, asking to go to town
The irony is powerful - Odysseus, the actual master of the house, is pretending to be too old and broken to serve anyone. This shows his complete commitment to his disguise and his strategic thinking.
In Today's Words:
I'm too old to be anyone's errand boy anymore.
"The gods sometimes visit us in disguise."
Context: Warning Antinous after he throws the stool at the beggar
This creates dramatic irony since we know the beggar really is someone powerful in disguise. It also shows that even some suitors recognize Antinous has crossed a line with his cruelty.
In Today's Words:
You never know who you're really dealing with, so don't be a jerk to people.
"His heart was full of thoughts of vengeance."
Context: Describing Odysseus's reaction to being struck by Antinous
This reveals that beneath his patient disguise, Odysseus is cataloging every insult and injury. His self-control makes his eventual revenge more justified and satisfying.
In Today's Words:
He was keeping track of everyone who wronged him, planning payback.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Strategic Invisibility
Appearing powerless while gathering intelligence reveals others' true character and creates strategic advantage.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
The disguised king experiences how society treats the powerless, while his true identity remains hidden beneath surface appearances
Development
Evolved from earlier exploration of hospitality customs to direct experience of class-based cruelty and kindness
In Your Life:
You might notice how differently people treat you based on your job title, clothes, or perceived status
Identity
In This Chapter
Odysseus maintains his true self while wearing a false identity, showing that core identity transcends external circumstances
Development
Developed from Telemachus's identity journey to Odysseus actively choosing to hide his true nature
In Your Life:
You might find yourself being someone different at work than at home, or hiding parts of yourself in certain situations
Loyalty
In This Chapter
Argos recognizes his master after twenty years, while Melanthius betrays his household for personal gain
Development
Builds on earlier contrasts between loyal servants like Eumaeus and disloyal ones throughout the journey
In Your Life:
You might see who really has your back when you're going through tough times versus who disappears when you can't help them
Self-Control
In This Chapter
Odysseus restrains himself from retaliation despite being kicked and struck, maintaining his cover for the larger plan
Development
Evolved from his earlier impulsiveness to hard-won wisdom about timing and strategic patience
In Your Life:
You might need to bite your tongue at work or in family situations while you figure out the best way to handle a problem
Recognition
In This Chapter
Only the loyal dog sees through the disguise, while humans judge based on appearances and social position
Development
Introduced here as a counterpoint to the theme of disguise and hidden identity
In Your Life:
You might find that animals, children, or very perceptive people see your true nature even when you're trying to hide it
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Omar's story...
Marcus finally returns to his old warehouse job after six months of rehab, but now he's starting at the bottom again. His supervisor Tony, who used to be his equal, enjoys making him do the worst tasks while the other workers watch. Some slip him extra break time or share their lunch; others kick him when he's down, spreading rumors about why he really left. The hardest moment comes when he sees Rex, the old loading dock dog who always greeted him. Rex is sick now, barely lifts his head, but his tail still wags when Marcus walks by. That afternoon, Rex dies. Inside the break room, Marcus keeps his head down while Tony throws wadded paper at him, calling him a 'charity case.' The other workers shift uncomfortably—some laugh nervously, others look away. Marcus says nothing, but he's learning who he can trust and who he can't. His caseworker wants to meet him after his shift to hear how the first day went.
The Road
The road Odysseus walked in ancient Greece, Marcus walks today. The pattern is identical: strategic invisibility while gathering intelligence about who shows their true character when they think there are no consequences.
The Map
This chapter provides a map for reading people under pressure. When you appear powerless, people reveal who they really are—their casual cruelties or unexpected kindnesses become visible.
Amplification
Before reading this, Marcus might have either exploded at Tony's humiliation or internalized it as deserved punishment. Now he can NAME it as intelligence gathering, PREDICT who will be allies or enemies, and NAVIGATE by documenting everything while building strategic relationships.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Odysseus allow Melanthius to kick him and Antinous to throw a stool at him without fighting back?
analysis • surface - 2
What does each person's treatment of the 'beggar' reveal about their true character, and why is this information valuable to Odysseus?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen people reveal their true nature when they think they're dealing with someone powerless or unimportant?
application • medium - 4
When might strategic invisibility—appearing less powerful than you are—give you an advantage in your own life?
application • deep - 5
What does Argos's recognition of Odysseus despite his disguise teach us about authentic relationships versus surface appearances?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Own Power Dynamic
Think of a situation where you need to gather information or assess people's true intentions—a new workplace, school, neighborhood, or relationship. Write down what you could learn by observing quietly before asserting yourself. List the different ways people might treat you if they see you as 'new' or 'powerless' versus established.
Consider:
- •What would people reveal if they thought their actions had no consequences?
- •Who shows genuine kindness when they think no one important is watching?
- •How could temporary strategic patience give you long-term advantage?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you learned something important by staying quiet and observing rather than immediately speaking up or taking action. What did you discover that you might have missed if you'd asserted yourself right away?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 18: The Beggar's Fight and Royal Gifts
What lies ahead teaches us to handle bullies without revealing your true strength, and shows us giving strategic warnings to decent people matters. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.