Original Text(~250 words)
VII. Mrs. Henry van der Luyden listened in silence to her cousin Mrs. Archer's narrative. It was all very well to tell yourself in advance that Mrs. van der Luyden was always silent, and that, though non-committal by nature and training, she was very kind to the people she really liked. Even personal experience of these facts was not always a protection from the chill that descended on one in the high-ceilinged white-walled Madison Avenue drawing-room, with the pale brocaded armchairs so obviously uncovered for the occasion, and the gauze still veiling the ormolu mantel ornaments and the beautiful old carved frame of Gainsborough's "Lady Angelica du Lac." Mrs. van der Luyden's portrait by Huntington (in black velvet and Venetian point) faced that of her lovely ancestress. It was generally considered "as fine as a Cabanel," and, though twenty years had elapsed since its execution, was still "a perfect likeness." Indeed the Mrs. van der Luyden who sat beneath it listening to Mrs. Archer might have been the twin-sister of the fair and still youngish woman drooping against a gilt armchair before a green rep curtain. Mrs. van der Luyden still wore black velvet and Venetian point when she went into society--or rather (since she never dined out) when she threw open her own doors to receive it. Her fair hair, which had faded without turning grey, was still parted in flat overlapping points on her forehead, and the straight nose that divided her pale blue eyes was only a...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Mrs. Archer and Newland visit the van der Luydens, New York society's ultimate arbiters, seeking help with the Ellen Olenska situation. The van der Luydens are portrayed as preserved relics of old New York - formal, ritualistic, and almost ghostly in their perfect propriety. They live like reluctant royalty, preferring their country estate but dutifully maintaining their role as society's final court of appeal. When Mrs. Archer explains how Lawrence Lefferts has orchestrated the snub against Ellen, the van der Luydens are quietly outraged - not so much at the treatment of Ellen, but at the principle being violated. Their response is swift and devastating: they will invite Ellen to dine with the Duke of St. Austrey, their visiting English relative. This is social warfare at its most elegant - by including Ellen in such an exclusive gathering, they effectively silence all criticism and force society to accept her. The chapter reveals how real power works in this world: not through confrontation, but through calculated gestures that everyone understands but no one can openly challenge. By evening, word has spread through the Opera house, and Lawrence Lefferts can only sit in his box, defeated, making irrelevant comments about opera singers. The van der Luydens have spoken without raising their voices, and their verdict is final.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Drawing-room
The formal living room where wealthy families received guests - designed to impress and intimidate. Everything was arranged to show status, from the expensive furniture to the family portraits.
Modern Usage:
Like the perfectly staged living room that's too fancy to actually use, or the executive office designed to make visitors feel small.
Social arbiters
The people who decide what's acceptable behavior in high society. They don't hold official positions but everyone defers to their judgment about who belongs and who doesn't.
Modern Usage:
Like the popular kids in high school, or the influencers who decide what's trendy - their approval makes or breaks your social standing.
Cut/Snubbing
Deliberately ignoring someone in social situations to show disapproval. In this world, being cut by the right people could destroy your reputation completely.
Modern Usage:
Like being ghosted, blocked on social media, or excluded from group chats - modern ways of socially punishing someone.
Court of appeal
The van der Luydens are like society's Supreme Court - when there's a social dispute, their decision is final and everyone must accept it.
Modern Usage:
Like going to HR when there's workplace drama, or asking the family matriarch to settle a dispute.
Social warfare
Fighting for power and status through subtle moves rather than direct confrontation. Victory comes through calculated gestures that send clear messages.
Modern Usage:
Like passive-aggressive office politics, or the careful way people navigate neighborhood disputes without open conflict.
Ormolu
Expensive gilded bronze decorations that wealthy families displayed to show their taste and wealth. Every detail in these homes was chosen to impress.
Modern Usage:
Like designer handbags or luxury car logos - status symbols that signal you have money and know quality.
Characters in This Chapter
Mrs. Henry van der Luyden
Social authority figure
The ultimate judge of New York society who lives like reluctant royalty. Her silence and formal manner intimidate everyone, but when she acts, her decisions are final and devastating to opponents.
Modern Equivalent:
The company CEO who rarely speaks but whose rare emails change everything
Mrs. Archer
Social advocate
Newland's mother who brings the Ellen Olenska problem to the van der Luydens. She understands the power structure and knows exactly who to approach for help.
Modern Equivalent:
The connected mom who knows exactly which school board member to call
Newland Archer
Concerned family member
Accompanies his mother to seek help for Ellen, showing his growing investment in her situation. He's learning how real power works in his world.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who goes with his mom to handle family business because he's starting to understand the stakes
Lawrence Lefferts
Social antagonist
The man orchestrating the campaign against Ellen Olenska. By evening, he's been completely defeated by the van der Luydens' strategic move, reduced to making irrelevant comments.
Modern Equivalent:
The office gossip who gets shut down when management intervenes
Duke of St. Austrey
Social weapon
The van der Luydens' English relative whose presence at dinner will force society to accept Ellen. He's a tool in their strategic response, representing international prestige.
Modern Equivalent:
The celebrity guest who makes everyone want an invitation to your event
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how real authority operates through elevation rather than enforcement, and how to identify who holds strategic power versus who just makes noise.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when conflicts get resolved through promotion or recognition rather than punishment—and identify who in your workplace has the power to elevate rather than just discipline.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Mrs. van der Luyden's portrait by Huntington (in black velvet and Venetian point) faced that of her lovely ancestress."
Context: Describing the intimidating formal drawing room where the meeting takes place
Shows how these people live surrounded by images of their own importance, like a shrine to their family's status. The room itself is designed to remind visitors of their place in the hierarchy.
In Today's Words:
Her expensive portrait stared down at visitors like a reminder of who was really in charge here.
"It was generally considered 'as fine as a Cabanel,' and, though twenty years had elapsed since its execution, was still 'a perfect likeness.'"
Context: Describing how Mrs. van der Luyden has remained unchanged, like a preserved artifact
Reveals how these social leaders exist outside normal time, maintaining the same appearance and rituals for decades. They're like living museum pieces preserving old New York traditions.
In Today's Words:
She looked exactly the same as her twenty-year-old portrait - like she'd been frozen in time.
"Their response is swift and devastating: they will invite Ellen to dine with the Duke of St. Austrey."
Context: The van der Luydens' calculated response to the social attack on Ellen
Shows how real power works through strategic moves rather than arguments. By including Ellen in their most exclusive event, they force everyone to accept her without saying a word about it.
In Today's Words:
They didn't argue or explain - they just made one move that shut down all the gossip.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Strategic Elevation
Solving conflicts by raising someone's status so high that opposition becomes impossible or petty.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Real power operates through calculated gestures rather than direct confrontation
Development
Building from earlier displays of social authority to show ultimate power dynamics
In Your Life:
You might see this when your boss resolves workplace conflicts through strategic promotions rather than disciplinary action
Class
In This Chapter
Social hierarchies are enforced through inclusion and exclusion from elite circles
Development
Deepening from surface social rules to reveal the machinery of class control
In Your Life:
You might experience this when certain invitations or associations instantly change how others treat you
Social Warfare
In This Chapter
Elegant destruction of opponents through unassailable social positioning
Development
Introduced here as sophisticated alternative to open conflict
In Your Life:
You might use this when you need to protect someone from criticism by publicly associating them with respected authority
Unspoken Rules
In This Chapter
Everyone understands the van der Luydens' message without it being explicitly stated
Development
Continuing exploration of how society communicates through gestures and implications
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in family gatherings where seating arrangements and introductions send clear messages about favor and status
Authority
In This Chapter
The van der Luydens' reluctant but absolute role as society's final arbiters
Development
Revealing the burden and responsibility that comes with ultimate social authority
In Your Life:
You might see this when you become the person others turn to for final decisions, whether you want that role or not
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Archer's story...
Marcus watches his coworker Diane get frozen out after filing a harassment complaint against a popular supervisor. The other CNAs avoid her, she's excluded from group texts, and even the charge nurses treat her differently. Marcus knows it's wrong but stays silent—he can't afford to lose this job. Then the nursing director, Ms. Chen, announces that Diane will be representing the unit at the upcoming state healthcare conference, a prestigious assignment that comes with travel pay and recognition. She'll be presenting their innovative patient care protocols to administrators from across the region. Suddenly, everyone's attitude shifts. The same people who were icing her out are now asking about the conference, offering help with her presentation. The supervisor who caused the original problem can only watch as Diane gains visibility with upper management. Ms. Chen never mentioned the harassment complaint, never lectured anyone about workplace behavior. She simply elevated Diane to a position where continuing the freeze-out would look petty and unprofessional.
The Road
The road Mrs. Archer walked in 1920, Marcus walks today. The pattern is identical: strategic elevation neutralizes social warfare without direct confrontation.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for workplace politics: when facing organized exclusion, appeal to higher authority not for justice but for elevation. Show them how the situation undermines their own goals.
Amplification
Before reading this, Marcus might have thought power meant confrontation or that staying silent was his only option. Now he can NAME strategic elevation, PREDICT how it works, NAVIGATE by identifying who has the authority to elevate rather than just mediate.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why do the van der Luydens invite Ellen to dine with the Duke instead of simply telling people to stop gossiping about her?
analysis • surface - 2
How does elevating Ellen's social status solve the problem more effectively than defending her directly would have?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen someone use 'strategic elevation' in your workplace, family, or community to shut down criticism or conflict?
application • medium - 4
If you were being undermined at work or in your community, how could you identify who has the authority to elevate your position rather than just defend you?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about why indirect power moves are often more effective than direct confrontation?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Power Network
Think of a current situation where someone is being criticized, undermined, or excluded in your workplace, family, or community. Draw a simple map showing who has the real authority to change this situation through elevation rather than confrontation. Identify the 'van der Luydens' in your world - the people whose endorsement would make criticism impossible.
Consider:
- •Look for people whose opinion carries weight beyond their official title
- •Consider who others automatically defer to or seek approval from
- •Think about who could make someone 'untouchable' through association or endorsement
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone with authority elevated your status or defended you indirectly. How did it feel different from direct confrontation? How might you use this pattern to help others?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 8: Ellen's Return to New York Society
What lies ahead teaches us social expectations can trap us in rigid roles and behaviors, and shows us the courage required to be authentic in judgmental environments. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.