Original Text(~250 words)
We reach’d the summit of the scale, and stood Upon the second buttress of that mount Which healeth him who climbs. A cornice there, Like to the former, girdles round the hill; Save that its arch with sweep less ample bends. Shadow nor image there is seen; all smooth The rampart and the path, reflecting nought But the rock’s sullen hue. “If here we wait For some to question,” said the bard, “I fear Our choice may haply meet too long delay.” Then fixedly upon the sun his eyes He fastn’d, made his right the central point From whence to move, and turn’d the left aside. “O pleasant light, my confidence and hope, Conduct us thou,” he cried, “on this new way, Where now I venture, leading to the bourn We seek. The universal world to thee Owes warmth and lustre. If no other cause Forbid, thy beams should ever be our guide.” Far, as is measur’d for a mile on earth, In brief space had we journey’d; such prompt will Impell’d; and towards us flying, now were heard Spirits invisible, who courteously Unto love’s table bade the welcome guest. The voice, that first? flew by, call’d forth aloud, “They have no wine; “ so on behind us past, Those sounds reiterating, nor yet lost In the faint distance, when another came Crying, “I am Orestes,” and alike Wing’d its fleet way. “Oh father!” I exclaim’d, “What tongues are these?” and as I question’d, lo! A third exclaiming, “Love ye...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Dante and Virgil reach the second terrace of Purgatory, where souls purge themselves of envy. This level appears stark and colorless, reflecting how envy drains the world of beauty and joy. As they walk, invisible voices call out examples of love and generosity - the opposite of envy's poison. Soon they encounter the envious souls themselves, a heartbreaking sight: people sitting against the cliff wall with their eyes sewn shut with wire, forced to rely on each other for support. They cannot see the world around them, just as envy in life blinded them to their own blessings and others' worth. Dante meets Sapia, a woman from Siena who admits she took more pleasure in her enemies' defeats than in her own victories. She describes watching her fellow citizens lose a battle and feeling gleeful satisfaction, comparing herself to a falcon fooled by false prey. Her honesty about this ugly truth shows the self-awareness needed for real change. Sapia asks Dante to restore her reputation when he returns to earth, showing how our earthly connections and legacy matter even in spiritual transformation. This terrace reveals how envy doesn't just hurt others - it imprisons us in darkness, cutting us off from the light and joy available to everyone. The cure requires learning to celebrate others' successes and find contentment in our own path.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Purgatory
In medieval Christian belief, a place where souls purify themselves after death before entering heaven. Unlike hell, it's temporary - a spiritual boot camp where people work through their character flaws.
Modern Usage:
We use 'purgatory' to describe any difficult waiting period where we're stuck between bad and good situations.
Terrace of Envy
The second level of Purgatory where souls overcome envy by learning to celebrate others' success. It's deliberately colorless and stark, showing how envy drains joy from life.
Modern Usage:
We see this pattern in social media culture, where constant comparison to others' highlight reels breeds dissatisfaction with our own lives.
Eyes Sewn Shut
The punishment for the envious - their eyes are wired closed so they must rely on others and can't see what might trigger jealousy. It forces them to develop inner vision and empathy.
Modern Usage:
This represents how jealousy blinds us to our own blessings and makes us miss opportunities right in front of us.
Invisible Voices
Spirits that call out examples of love and generosity as Dante passes. They provide positive models to counter envy's negative patterns.
Modern Usage:
Like motivational podcasts or inspirational social media accounts that try to shift our mindset toward gratitude and abundance.
Contrapasso
Dante's principle that punishments mirror the sin - the envious who couldn't see others' worth now literally cannot see. The cure matches the crime.
Modern Usage:
We see this in how our bad habits often create their own consequences - liars lose credibility, selfish people end up alone.
Spiritual Rehabilitation
The idea that character flaws can be systematically worked through and overcome, not just punished. Purgatory is therapy, not prison.
Modern Usage:
Modern addiction recovery programs and therapy use similar step-by-step approaches to changing destructive patterns.
Characters in This Chapter
Dante
Protagonist and observer
He's horrified by the sight of souls with sewn eyes but learns from their stories. His compassion shows he's growing spiritually through witnessing others' struggles.
Modern Equivalent:
The person in therapy who starts recognizing their own patterns by hearing others' stories
Virgil
Guide and mentor
He leads Dante through this terrace and helps him understand what they're seeing. He uses the sun as their guide since there are no landmarks on this stark level.
Modern Equivalent:
The experienced sponsor or mentor who helps navigate difficult life transitions
Sapia
Reformed envious soul
A woman from Siena who admits she took more joy in her enemies' defeats than her own victories. Her brutal honesty about her past ugliness shows the self-awareness needed for change.
Modern Equivalent:
The recovering addict who sponsors others by being completely honest about their rock bottom
The Invisible Voices
Spiritual teachers
They provide examples of love and generosity to counter envy. Their first cry is 'They have no wine' - referring to Mary's concern for wedding guests at Cana.
Modern Equivalent:
The positive influences trying to shift your mindset when you're stuck in negativity
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when we're unconsciously undermining our own progress by focusing on others' failures instead of our own growth.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel pleased about someone else's mistake or setback, then immediately ask yourself what you could be doing to advance your own goals instead.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"They have no wine"
Context: The first example of love called out as they enter the terrace of envy
This refers to Mary noticing the wedding hosts' embarrassment at running out of wine and asking Jesus to help. It's the opposite of envy - seeing others' needs and wanting to help rather than taking pleasure in their problems.
In Today's Words:
Someone's in trouble - let's help them out
"I took more joy in others' hurt than in my own good fortune"
Context: Sapia confesses her envious nature to Dante
This brutal self-assessment shows how envy corrupts our ability to find happiness. Instead of celebrating our wins, we get more satisfaction from others losing. It's a toxic pattern that steals our own joy.
In Today's Words:
I was happier when bad things happened to people I didn't like than when good things happened to me
"Now I see that I was like a blackbird who rejoices in winter, thinking spring will never come"
Context: Sapia describes her foolish satisfaction at her city's military defeat
She realizes her short-sighted thinking - celebrating temporary setbacks for others while missing the bigger picture. Envy makes us stupid, focusing on petty victories while missing real opportunities for happiness.
In Today's Words:
I was celebrating too early, not realizing I was setting myself up for disappointment
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Comparison Prison
Finding satisfaction in others' failures rather than focusing on your own success, which ultimately blinds you to your own opportunities and potential.
Thematic Threads
Envy
In This Chapter
Souls have their eyes sewn shut, representing how envy blinds us to our own blessings and possibilities
Development
Introduced here as a specific sin being purged, showing its destructive power
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you feel secretly pleased about a coworker's mistake instead of focusing on your own performance.
Self-awareness
In This Chapter
Sapia honestly admits her ugly truth about taking pleasure in enemies' defeats rather than her own victories
Development
Building on earlier themes of confession and honest self-examination
In Your Life:
This appears when you have to admit uncomfortable truths about your motivations and reactions to others' success or failure.
Community dependence
In This Chapter
The blind souls must lean on each other for support, learning interdependence
Development
Continues the theme of how individual growth requires community connection
In Your Life:
You see this when you realize you need others' help and support to overcome your own destructive patterns.
Reputation and legacy
In This Chapter
Sapia asks Dante to restore her reputation on earth, showing concern for how she's remembered
Development
Builds on ongoing theme of earthly connections mattering even in spiritual transformation
In Your Life:
This shows up when you worry about how your mistakes will be remembered and want opportunities to make things right.
Spiritual blindness
In This Chapter
Physical blindness represents how envy cuts us off from seeing beauty and joy in the world
Development
Extends the metaphor of sight and blindness from earlier circles
In Your Life:
You experience this when negative emotions prevent you from seeing good opportunities or positive aspects of your situation.
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following George's story...
George sits in the break room at the warehouse, scrolling through social media instead of studying for his forklift certification. He's been stuck in the same position for three years while watching newer hires get promoted around him. But instead of focusing on his own advancement, George has developed a toxic habit: he feels genuinely happy when his coworkers mess up or get written up. When Jake got suspended for a safety violation, George felt a rush of satisfaction. When Sarah's transfer request got denied, he secretly celebrated. Now George realizes he spends more energy tracking others' failures than building his own skills. His supervisor pulls him aside, explaining that his attitude is holding him back more than his qualifications. George sees the pattern clearly for the first time: while he was busy watching others stumble, he stopped walking his own path forward. The promotion he wanted went to someone who spent their break time studying, not gossiping about who got in trouble.
The Road
The road Sapia walked in 1320, George walks today. The pattern is identical: finding more joy in others' defeats than in your own victories blinds you to your own potential and traps you in place.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for escaping comparison prison. When you catch yourself celebrating someone else's failure, redirect that energy immediately toward your own growth and goals.
Amplification
Before reading this, George might have continued the toxic cycle of measuring his worth by others' failures, staying stuck indefinitely. Now he can NAME the comparison trap, PREDICT where it leads (nowhere), and NAVIGATE by redirecting competitive energy toward personal development.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why are the envious souls sitting with their eyes sewn shut, and what does this punishment teach us about how envy actually works?
analysis • surface - 2
Sapia admits she felt more joy watching her enemies lose than celebrating her own victories. What does this reveal about the psychology of envy?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today getting more satisfaction from others' failures than from their own successes? What situations make this tempting?
application • medium - 4
If you caught yourself feeling secretly pleased about someone else's setback, what specific steps would you take to redirect that energy toward your own growth?
application • deep - 5
How does focusing on comparing ourselves to others actually blind us to our own opportunities and path forward?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Create Your Personal Scoreboard
Think of an area where you often compare yourself to others - work, parenting, finances, relationships. Create a personal scoreboard that tracks only your own progress, not your position relative to others. List 3-5 specific metrics that measure your growth in this area over the past month. Then identify one action you can take this week to improve your own score.
Consider:
- •Focus on metrics you can actually control and influence
- •Choose measurements that reflect genuine progress, not just activity
- •Notice how it feels to evaluate yourself without comparing to others
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt genuinely happy about someone else's success, even in an area where you were struggling. What made that possible, and how did it feel different from comparison or envy?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 48: The Poison of Envy Revealed
What lies ahead teaches us envy destroys communities from within, and shows us nostalgia for 'better times' can reveal present corruption. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.