Original Text(~250 words)
CHAPTER XIX If Emma had still, at intervals, an anxious feeling for Harriet, a momentary doubt of its being possible for her to be really cured of her attachment to Mr. Knightley, and really able to accept another man from unbiased inclination, it was not long that she had to suffer from the recurrence of any such uncertainty. A very few days brought the party from London, and she had no sooner an opportunity of being one hour alone with Harriet, than she became perfectly satisfied—unaccountable as it was!—that Robert Martin had thoroughly supplanted Mr. Knightley, and was now forming all her views of happiness. Harriet was a little distressed—did look a little foolish at first: but having once owned that she had been presumptuous and silly, and self-deceived, before, her pain and confusion seemed to die away with the words, and leave her without a care for the past, and with the fullest exultation in the present and future; for, as to her friend’s approbation, Emma had instantly removed every fear of that nature, by meeting her with the most unqualified congratulations.—Harriet was most happy to give every particular of the evening at Astley’s, and the dinner the next day; she could dwell on it all with the utmost delight. But what did such particulars explain?—The fact was, as Emma could now acknowledge, that Harriet had always liked Robert Martin; and that his continuing to love her had been irresistible.—Beyond this, it must ever be unintelligible to Emma. The...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Emma's final chapter ties up all loose ends with satisfying resolution. Harriet quickly gets over her crush on Mr. Knightley and marries Robert Martin, revealing that she was always better suited to him anyway. Her parentage is revealed - she's the daughter of a tradesman, not nobility, which makes Emma realize how wrong her assumptions were. Emma acknowledges that Harriet will be happier with Martin than she ever could have been with someone from a higher social class. The friendship between Emma and Harriet naturally fades as their lives take different directions, which Emma accepts as necessary and right. Meanwhile, Emma and Mr. Knightley want to marry quickly while his brother is still visiting, but her father's anxiety about change threatens to delay everything. The solution comes from an unexpected source: when Mrs. Weston's turkeys are stolen, Mr. Woodhouse becomes so worried about security that he welcomes having Mr. Knightley permanently at Hartfield for protection. The wedding happens within a month, described as simple and unpretentious - exactly opposite of Mrs. Elton's flashy style. The novel ends with the promise that this marriage, built on genuine understanding and mutual respect, will bring lasting happiness. This conclusion reinforces Austen's themes about the importance of self-knowledge, appropriate matches, and how true compatibility matters more than social climbing or romantic fantasy.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Supplanted
To replace someone or something, especially by taking their position or role. In this chapter, Robert Martin has completely replaced Mr. Knightley in Harriet's affections. It suggests a total shift in feelings, not just a gradual change.
Modern Usage:
We see this when someone gets over an ex by falling for someone new, or when a new employee supplants a veteran worker.
Unbiased inclination
Natural feelings or attraction that aren't influenced by outside pressure or manipulation. Emma worries whether Harriet can truly choose someone based on her own genuine feelings rather than Emma's meddling influence.
Modern Usage:
This is like wondering if your friend really likes someone or if they're just going along with what you think is best for them.
Presumptuous
Acting beyond what's appropriate for your position or relationship, often by assuming more intimacy or importance than actually exists. Harriet admits she was presumptuous in thinking Mr. Knightley could be interested in her.
Modern Usage:
Like texting your boss like they're your friend, or assuming you're invited to an event when you weren't specifically asked.
Astley's
A famous London entertainment venue featuring circus acts, equestrian shows, and popular performances. It was where working-class and middle-class people went for fun, not the refined entertainment of the upper classes.
Modern Usage:
Think of it like going to a carnival, amusement park, or big concert venue - accessible entertainment for regular people.
Unintelligible
Impossible to understand or make sense of. Emma can't comprehend how Harriet's feelings changed so quickly and completely, because Emma doesn't understand that genuine attraction works differently than her manipulated scenarios.
Modern Usage:
When someone's behavior or choices make absolutely no sense to you, like when your friend keeps going back to someone who treats them badly.
Irresistible
Too appealing or powerful to resist. Robert Martin's continued love and attention proved too strong for Harriet to ignore, especially since it matched her natural inclinations rather than fighting against them.
Modern Usage:
When someone or something is so appealing you can't say no, even if you thought you wanted something else.
Characters in This Chapter
Emma
Protagonist reflecting on her mistakes
Emma finally accepts that her matchmaking was wrong and that Harriet is better off without her interference. She feels relief rather than disappointment when Harriet chooses Robert Martin, showing real growth in her character.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who finally admits they were wrong about your relationship choices
Harriet
Young woman finding her true path
Harriet quickly recovers from her crush on Mr. Knightley and embraces her engagement to Robert Martin. Her happiness and ease with this choice shows she was always meant for a simpler, more genuine life than Emma imagined for her.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who was trying to be someone she wasn't but finally embraces who she really is
Robert Martin
Harriet's true match
Though not present in this scene, Robert Martin represents the right choice that was there all along. His persistence and genuine affection win out over Emma's schemes and social climbing.
Modern Equivalent:
The good guy who waited patiently while someone figured out what they really wanted
Mr. Knightley
The object of misplaced affection
Mr. Knightley serves as the contrast to Robert Martin - he was never a real possibility for Harriet, just Emma's fantasy. His role shows how important it is to be realistic about romantic prospects.
Modern Equivalent:
The crush who was always out of your league but seemed possible because someone encouraged the fantasy
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to spot the difference between relationships that look good on paper and ones that actually work in practice.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you feel like you're performing versus when you feel natural - whether in relationships, jobs, or social situations.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Robert Martin had thoroughly supplanted Mr. Knightley, and was now forming all her views of happiness."
Context: Emma realizes that Harriet has completely gotten over Mr. Knightley and is focused on Robert Martin
This shows how quickly genuine feelings can reassert themselves when artificial obstacles are removed. Harriet's natural inclinations toward Robert Martin were always stronger than her manufactured crush on Mr. Knightley.
In Today's Words:
Robert had completely replaced Mr. Knightley in her heart, and now all her dreams were about him.
"The fact was, as Emma could now acknowledge, that Harriet had always liked Robert Martin."
Context: Emma finally admits the truth she had been ignoring all along
This is Emma's moment of complete honesty about her interference. She acknowledges that she was working against Harriet's natural feelings rather than helping them. It shows real growth in Emma's self-awareness.
In Today's Words:
Emma finally had to admit that Harriet had been into Robert all along.
"Beyond this, it must ever be unintelligible to Emma."
Context: Emma can't understand how Harriet's feelings changed so completely
This reveals Emma's limitations in understanding genuine emotion versus manipulated feelings. She can't comprehend how natural attraction works because she's been so focused on engineering relationships based on social status.
In Today's Words:
Emma just couldn't wrap her head around how it all worked out.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Right-Sized Matches
Happiness comes from choices that fit your actual self and circumstances, not from pursuing what you think you should want or what looks impressive to others.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Harriet's true parentage as a tradesman's daughter validates her natural compatibility with Robert Martin rather than making her 'lesser'
Development
Final resolution showing class compatibility matters more than class climbing
In Your Life:
You might find yourself happier dating someone who shares your actual lifestyle rather than someone who looks good on paper
Identity
In This Chapter
Emma accepts her father's anxieties and works around them rather than forcing change, while Harriet embraces her true social position
Development
Characters finally align their actions with their authentic selves rather than fighting their nature
In Your Life:
You might stop trying to be the person you think you should be and start working with who you actually are
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Emma demonstrates true maturity by accepting that her friendship with Harriet will naturally fade as their lives diverge
Development
Growth shown through letting go rather than controlling or clinging
In Your Life:
You might recognize when relationships have served their purpose and let them evolve naturally rather than forcing them to continue
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
The simple wedding reflects Emma and Knightley's genuine partnership, contrasting with Mrs. Elton's performative approach to marriage
Development
Culmination showing authentic connection versus social performance
In Your Life:
You might choose to celebrate milestones in ways that reflect your actual values rather than what's expected or impressive
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
The novel ends by validating choices based on genuine compatibility rather than social advancement or romantic fantasy
Development
Final rejection of society's pressure to pursue status over substance
In Your Life:
You might find yourself making decisions based on what actually works for your life rather than what others expect or admire
Modern Adaptation
When Everything Falls Into Place
Following Emma's story...
Emma watches her friend Harriet finally get back together with Robert, the warehouse supervisor she'd convinced her to dump for someone 'better.' Turns out Harriet's happier stocking shelves and planning their simple wedding than she ever was trying to impress the bank manager Emma had pushed her toward. Emma realizes she'd been projecting her own social climbing onto someone who never wanted to climb at all. Meanwhile, Emma's been putting off moving in with her boyfriend because her anxious father keeps finding excuses to delay it. But when someone breaks into their neighbor's house, her dad suddenly wants the boyfriend there for security. Within weeks, they're living together, and Emma sees how forcing the timing would have created stress, but letting it happen naturally made everyone comfortable. Sometimes the best outcomes come from stopping the interference.
The Road
The road Emma Woodhouse walked in 1815, Emma walks today. The pattern is identical: happiness comes from matches that fit your actual self, not your imagined self.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for distinguishing between what looks impressive and what actually works. Emma can now recognize when she's pushing herself or others toward performance rather than authentic fit.
Amplification
Before reading this, Emma might have kept pushing people toward what 'should' make them happy. Now she can NAME the difference between performing success and living it, PREDICT when forcing a fit will backfire, and NAVIGATE toward what actually feels sustainable.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why does Harriet end up happier with Robert Martin than she would have been with someone from a higher social class?
analysis • surface - 2
What does Emma's realization about Harriet's 'true place' reveal about how we judge what's best for other people?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today pushing themselves or others toward what looks impressive rather than what actually fits their personality and strengths?
application • medium - 4
How can you tell the difference between a life choice that genuinely fits you versus one you think you 'should' want?
application • deep - 5
What does this ending suggest about the relationship between social climbing and genuine happiness?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Match Audit: What Fits vs. What Looks Good
Make two columns: 'What I Think I Should Want' and 'What Actually Energizes Me.' Fill each with 3-5 items from your current life - job aspects, relationship goals, social activities, future plans. Look for mismatches where you're pursuing something that drains rather than sustains you.
Consider:
- •Notice which column feels easier to fill - often we know what we 'should' want better than what we actually enjoy
- •Pay attention to items that appear in both columns - these are your sweet spots
- •Consider whether any 'should wants' come from other people's expectations rather than your own values
Journaling Prompt
Write about one area where you've been forcing a fit that doesn't feel natural. What would it look like to pursue what actually works for you instead?