Original Text(~250 words)
L←etter 34. On a promising pupilMoral letters to Luciliusby Seneca, translated by Richard Mott GummereLetter 35. On the friendship of kindred mindsLetter 36. On the value of retirement→482921Moral letters to Lucilius — Letter 35. On the friendship of kindred mindsRichard Mott GummereSeneca ​ XXXV. ON THE FRIENDSHIP OF KINDRED MINDS 1. When I urge you so strongly to your studies, it is my own interest which I am consulting; I want your friendship, and it cannot fall to my lot unless you proceed, as you have begun, with the task of developing yourself. For now, although you love me, you are not yet my friend. “But,” you reply, “are these words of different meaning?” Nay, more, they are totally unlike in meaning.[1] A friend loves you, of course; but one who loves you is not in every case your friend. Friendship, accordingly, is always helpful, but love sometimes even does harm. Try to perfect yourself, if for no other reason, in order that you may learn how to love. 2. Hasten, therefore, in order that, while thus perfecting yourself for my benefit, you may not have ​learned perfection for the benefit of another. To be sure, I am already deriving some profit by imagining that we two shall be of one mind, and that whatever portion of my strength has yielded to age will return to me from your strength, although there is not so very much difference in our ages. 3. But yet I wish to rejoice in the accomplished fact. We...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Seneca makes a distinction that might surprise modern readers: loving someone and being their friend are completely different things. He tells Lucilius that while Lucilius loves him, they're not yet true friends—and that's because real friendship requires both people to be developed, consistent human beings. Love can be selfish, even harmful, but friendship is always beneficial because it's based on mutual respect between people who know themselves. Seneca admits he's being a bit selfish in pushing Lucilius to grow—he wants a real friend, not just an admirer. He warns Lucilius to hurry up with his self-development, because life is short and Seneca is getting old. The key test of whether you're actually growing as a person? Check if you want the same things today that you wanted yesterday. If your desires keep shifting like a ship without an anchor, you're still lost at sea. But if you're becoming more consistent in your values and goals, you're making real progress. Seneca distinguishes between two types of people on the path to wisdom: those who are still moving around but staying in basically the same place (like a ship rocking at anchor), and those who have found their center and aren't being tossed around anymore. This letter reveals Seneca's deep longing for genuine human connection—not the surface-level relationships that dominate social life, but the rare bond between two people who have done the hard work of becoming themselves.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Stoic friendship
A relationship based on mutual respect between two people who have developed their character and wisdom, rather than just emotional attachment. Unlike casual friendships, this requires both people to be consistent in their values and self-aware.
Modern Usage:
We see this in relationships where both people challenge each other to grow, rather than just enabling each other's bad habits.
Moral development
The ongoing process of becoming a better, more consistent person through self-reflection and practice. Seneca believes this is necessary before you can have meaningful relationships with others.
Modern Usage:
This shows up in therapy culture and self-help movements that emphasize 'doing the work' on yourself before dating or forming close bonds.
Consistency test
Seneca's method for measuring personal growth: checking whether your desires and values remain stable over time, rather than shifting constantly based on mood or circumstances.
Modern Usage:
We use this when we ask ourselves if we still want the same things we wanted last year, or if we're just chasing whatever feels good in the moment.
Philosophical correspondence
The practice of writing letters to discuss life's big questions and moral challenges. These weren't just personal letters but a way of working through problems and sharing wisdom.
Modern Usage:
We see this in modern mentorship relationships, life coaching, or even deep text conversations where friends help each other think through major decisions.
Beneficial vs. harmful love
Seneca distinguishes between love that helps someone grow (based on respect for who they really are) and love that can damage them (possessive, enabling, or based on fantasy).
Modern Usage:
This appears in discussions about toxic relationships versus healthy ones, and the difference between loving someone and loving the idea of them.
Anchored vs. drifting
Seneca's metaphor for people who have found their core values and stick to them (anchored) versus those who are still being tossed around by every new influence or emotion (drifting).
Modern Usage:
We use this to describe people who seem to have their life together versus those who are still 'finding themselves' or constantly changing direction.
Characters in This Chapter
Seneca
Mentor and letter writer
He's being honest about his own motivations for pushing Lucilius to grow, admitting he wants a real friend, not just an admirer. He's also aware that time is running out as he ages.
Modern Equivalent:
The older coworker who takes you under their wing but is upfront about wanting intellectual companionship, not just to be looked up to
Lucilius
Student and correspondent
He loves Seneca but isn't yet developed enough to be a true friend. He's in the process of working on himself but still inconsistent in his growth and values.
Modern Equivalent:
The younger person who admires their mentor but is still figuring out who they are and what they really want
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to separate feelings from foundation—recognizing when someone's emotional investment doesn't translate to dependable partnership.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's words don't match their consistency—do they say they care but show up differently each time you need them?
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"A friend loves you, of course; but one who loves you is not in every case your friend."
Context: He's explaining to Lucilius why their relationship isn't true friendship yet, despite the love between them.
This reveals Seneca's high standards for friendship and his belief that real connection requires more than just affection. It shows friendship as something earned through mutual development.
In Today's Words:
Just because someone cares about you doesn't mean they're really your friend in the deepest sense.
"Try to perfect yourself, if for no other reason, in order that you may learn how to love."
Context: He's urging Lucilius to continue his self-development work.
This suggests that without self-knowledge and consistency, we can't even love properly. It connects personal growth directly to our ability to form meaningful relationships.
In Today's Words:
Work on yourself so you can actually be good at caring about people.
"Friendship, accordingly, is always helpful, but love sometimes even does harm."
Context: He's contrasting the reliability of true friendship with the potential dangers of mere emotional attachment.
This challenges our modern assumption that love is always good. Seneca sees undeveloped love as potentially destructive, while friendship between mature people is always beneficial.
In Today's Words:
Real friendship always makes your life better, but love can actually mess you up if it's not based on respect.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Real Connection - Why Love Isn't Enough for True Partnership
Loving someone and being able to build something stable with them are entirely different things that require different levels of personal development.
Thematic Threads
Personal Growth
In This Chapter
Seneca demands that Lucilius develop consistency and self-knowledge before they can have true friendship
Development
Evolved from earlier focus on individual virtue to relationship requirements
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize you can't rely on someone you care about because they haven't done their own inner work.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Distinction between love (which can be selfish) and friendship (which requires mutual development)
Development
Deepened from general social observations to specific relationship dynamics
In Your Life:
You might see this in the difference between people who say they love you versus those you can actually count on when things get hard.
Identity
In This Chapter
Consistency in desires and values as the marker of a developed person versus shifting like 'a ship without anchor'
Development
Expanded from individual character to relational implications
In Your Life:
You might notice this in yourself when you check whether you want the same things today that you wanted last month.
Social Expectations
In This Chapter
Challenging the assumption that love alone is sufficient for meaningful relationships
Development
Introduced here as counter to conventional relationship wisdom
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize that caring about someone doesn't automatically make them a good partner, friend, or teammate.
Class
In This Chapter
Seneca's admission of selfishness in wanting Lucilius to develop—honesty about what he gets from the relationship
Development
Evolved from status observations to power dynamics in personal relationships
In Your Life:
You might see this when you realize that even mentoring relationships involve some self-interest—and that's okay if it's honest.
Modern Adaptation
When Love Isn't Enough
Following Samuel's story...
Marcus has been training new CNAs for three years, and he's learned something painful: caring about someone and being able to count on them are completely different things. He watches trainees who genuinely love the work—they cry when patients suffer, they stay late when someone needs help—but they can't show up consistently. One week they're passionate about patient advocacy, the next they're burned out and calling in sick. Meanwhile, other trainees seem less emotional but become the reliable ones—same standards every shift, same quality care regardless of their mood. Marcus realizes he's been confusing intensity with stability. The trainees he can actually build a strong unit with aren't necessarily the ones who feel the most; they're the ones who've figured out how to be the same person every day. Now when he evaluates new hires, he looks for consistency over passion. Can they handle a difficult patient the same way on Monday as Friday? Do their values shift with their energy level? He's learned that loving the job isn't enough—you need to become someone the job can depend on.
The Road
The road Seneca walked in 65 AD, Marcus walks today. The pattern is identical: distinguishing between emotional attachment and reliable partnership, between feelings and the foundation needed for something real.
The Map
This chapter provides a tool for evaluating relationships—any relationships. Ask not how much someone cares, but how consistently they show up. True partnership requires two stable people, not just strong feelings.
Amplification
Before reading this, Marcus might have been frustrated when passionate trainees burned out, taking it personally. Now he can NAME the difference between love and partnership, PREDICT which relationships will last, NAVIGATE his own expectations accordingly.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What distinction does Seneca make between loving someone and being their friend? Why does he say he and Lucilius aren't true friends yet?
analysis • surface - 2
According to Seneca, what makes someone ready for real friendship? Why does consistency in values and desires matter more than feelings?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about your own relationships—where have you seen the difference between someone who loves you and someone you can actually build something with?
application • medium - 4
Seneca uses the metaphor of a ship without an anchor for people whose desires keep changing. How would you recognize if you're the 'unstable' person in your relationships?
application • deep - 5
What does this letter reveal about the loneliness of growth? Why might becoming more consistent actually make relationships harder before they get better?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
The Anchor Test
Write down three things you wanted badly six months ago and three things you want badly now. Compare the lists. Then think about one important relationship in your life and honestly assess: are you the consistent person they can count on, or are you still shifting with every wind? Finally, identify one area where you could become more reliable.
Consider:
- •Don't judge yourself for past inconsistency—everyone starts somewhere
- •Look for patterns, not perfection—small improvements in consistency matter
- •Consider whether the relationship problems you face stem from your instability or theirs
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone you loved couldn't be the partner you needed because they didn't know themselves well enough yet. What did you learn about the difference between caring about someone and being able to build with them?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 36: Choosing Peace Over Status
As the story unfolds, you'll explore to defend your choice to prioritize peace over career advancement, while uncovering prosperity can be more dangerous than poverty. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.