Original Text(~250 words)
L←etter 97. On the degeneracy of the ageMoral letters to Luciliusby Seneca, translated by Richard Mott GummereLetter 98. On the fickleness of fortuneLetter 99. On consolation to the bereaved→483740Moral letters to Lucilius — Letter 98. On the fickleness of fortuneRichard Mott GummereSeneca ​ XCVIII. ON THE FICKLENESS OF FORTUNE 1. You need never believe that anyone who depends upon happiness is happy! It is a fragile support—this delight in adventitious things; the joy which entered from without will some day depart. But that joy which springs wholly from oneself is leal and sound; it increases and attends us to the last; while all other things which provoke the admiration of the crowd are but temporary Goods. You may reply: “What do you mean? Cannot such things serve both for utility and for delight?” Of course. But only if they depend on us, and not we on them. 2. All things that Fortune looks upon become productive and pleasant, only if he who possesses them is in possession also of himself, and is not in the power of that which belongs to him.[1] For men make a mistake, my dear Lucilius, if they hold that anything good, or evil either, is bestowed upon us by Fortune; it is simply the raw material of Goods and Ills that she gives to us—the sources of things which, in our keeping, will develop into good or ill. For the soul is more powerful than any sort of Fortune; by its own agency it guides its affairs...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Seneca tackles one of life's hardest truths: everything we love can be taken away at any moment. He's writing about fortune's fickleness—how quickly good times can turn bad, and how the things we depend on for happiness are ultimately beyond our control. But this isn't a doom-and-gloom lecture. Instead, Seneca offers a radical reframe: the problem isn't that we might lose things, it's that we make our happiness dependent on keeping them. He distinguishes between two types of joy—the fragile kind that comes from external things like money, status, or even relationships, and the unshakeable kind that comes from within. The key insight is that we can enjoy good things without being enslaved by them. Seneca uses powerful examples of historical figures who faced extreme hardship with dignity—Socrates drinking poison, Cato choosing death over dishonor. These aren't just ancient heroes; they're proof that ordinary humans can develop extraordinary resilience. The letter also touches on a friend who's dealing with a serious illness, showing how these philosophical principles play out in real suffering. Seneca's advice isn't to become emotionally numb, but to practice a kind of mental preparation—imagining loss before it happens so you're not blindsided. This isn't pessimism; it's emotional insurance. By accepting that everything is temporary, we can actually enjoy what we have more fully, without the constant anxiety of losing it.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Fortune
In Stoic philosophy, Fortune represents all the external circumstances beyond our control - luck, chance events, other people's actions, natural disasters, economic changes. Seneca personifies Fortune as a fickle goddess who gives and takes away randomly.
Modern Usage:
We see this when people say 'that's just how life goes' or when someone loses their job due to company layoffs - it's the unpredictable stuff that happens to us.
Adventitious goods
Things that come to us from outside ourselves - money, possessions, status, even relationships and health. Seneca calls them 'adventitious' because they're accidental additions to our lives, not essential parts of who we are.
Modern Usage:
This includes everything from your car and house to your job title and social media followers - anything that could disappear tomorrow.
Leal and sound joy
Joy that comes from within yourself - from your character, values, and inner strength rather than external circumstances. Seneca argues this is the only reliable source of happiness because no one can take it away from you.
Modern Usage:
It's the satisfaction you get from knowing you did the right thing, or the peace that comes from accepting yourself, regardless of what's happening around you.
Raw material of goods and ills
Seneca's concept that external events are morally neutral - they become good or bad based on how we respond to them. A setback isn't automatically bad; it's just raw material we can shape into wisdom or bitterness.
Modern Usage:
Like when someone gets fired and either becomes bitter or uses it as motivation to find something better - same event, different outcomes based on their response.
Premeditation of evils
A Stoic practice of imagining potential losses or hardships before they happen, not to be pessimistic but to build mental resilience and appreciate what you currently have.
Modern Usage:
It's like having emergency savings or insurance - you hope you won't need it, but preparing for problems makes you less anxious and more grateful for good times.
Possession of oneself
Being in control of your own thoughts, reactions, and values rather than being controlled by external circumstances or other people's opinions. It's about internal sovereignty.
Modern Usage:
It's when you can stay calm during family drama or not let a bad day at work ruin your whole evening - you own your emotional responses.
Characters in This Chapter
Seneca
Mentor and letter writer
Serves as the wise teacher sharing hard-won insights about dealing with life's uncertainties. He's not just theorizing but speaking from experience as someone who lived through political upheaval and personal losses.
Modern Equivalent:
The older coworker who's been through layoffs and divorces but somehow stays positive and gives great advice
Lucilius
Student and letter recipient
Represents the earnest seeker trying to apply philosophical principles to real-life challenges. His questions and struggles make Seneca's advice more practical and relatable.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who actually wants to grow and asks for honest feedback about their life choices
Socrates
Historical example of resilience
Referenced as someone who faced death with dignity and maintained his principles even when condemned by his own city. Shows that ordinary people can achieve extraordinary inner strength.
Modern Equivalent:
The whistleblower who loses their career but sleeps well knowing they did the right thing
Cato the Younger
Historical example of integrity
Mentioned as someone who chose death rather than compromise his values when Caesar took power. Represents the ultimate commitment to personal principles over external circumstances.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who quits a high-paying job rather than participate in something unethical
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to protect your mental wellbeing by not making happiness dependent on things beyond your control.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you catch yourself saying 'I'll be happy when...' and ask instead: 'How can I appreciate what I have right now?'
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"You need never believe that anyone who depends upon happiness is happy!"
Context: Opening the letter with a paradox about the nature of true happiness
This counterintuitive statement challenges our normal thinking about happiness. Seneca argues that if your happiness depends on keeping certain things, you're actually living in constant fear of losing them, which makes you unhappy.
In Today's Words:
If you need everything to go right to be happy, you'll never actually be happy because you'll always be worried about something going wrong.
"The soul is more powerful than any sort of Fortune; by its own agency it guides its affairs"
Context: Explaining how our inner strength can overcome external circumstances
This is Seneca's core message - that our internal responses are stronger than external events. We can't control what happens to us, but we can control how we interpret and respond to it.
In Today's Words:
Your mindset is stronger than your circumstances - you get to decide what your experiences mean and how you'll handle them.
"All things that Fortune looks upon become productive and pleasant, only if he who possesses them is in possession also of himself"
Context: Explaining the right relationship to have with good things in life
Seneca isn't saying to reject good things, but to enjoy them without being enslaved by them. The key is maintaining your inner freedom while appreciating external gifts.
In Today's Words:
You can enjoy the good stuff life gives you, but only if you're not desperate to keep it and you remember it's not what makes you who you are.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Attachment Anxiety
Making happiness dependent on keeping external things creates constant fear of loss, which prevents enjoying what you actually have.
Thematic Threads
Control
In This Chapter
Seneca distinguishes between what we can and cannot control, focusing on the futility of trying to control external circumstances
Development
Builds on earlier letters about focusing energy only on what's within our power
In Your Life:
You might waste energy worrying about your adult child's choices instead of focusing on your own response to them
Identity
In This Chapter
True identity comes from internal qualities that can't be taken away, not external possessions or circumstances
Development
Develops the theme of authentic self vs. social roles and expectations
In Your Life:
You might define yourself by your job title or relationship status rather than your character and values
Class
In This Chapter
Examples of dignity in loss show that inner nobility isn't tied to external wealth or status
Development
Continues exploring how true worth transcends social position
In Your Life:
You might feel shame about financial struggles instead of recognizing your inherent dignity as a person
Resilience
In This Chapter
Mental preparation for loss builds emotional strength rather than creating pessimism
Development
Expands on earlier themes of building inner strength through philosophical practice
In Your Life:
You might avoid thinking about potential problems instead of mentally preparing for challenges
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Shows how to love people fully while accepting that relationships are temporary
Development
Deepens the exploration of how to maintain connections without possessiveness
In Your Life:
You might try to control family members out of love instead of supporting them while accepting their autonomy
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Samuel's story...
Marcus had been counting on the assistant manager position at the hardware store for months. He'd already mentally spent the extra $200 a week—half toward his daughter's college fund, half to finally fix the truck's transmission. When corporate gave the job to an outside hire instead, Marcus felt like the wind had been knocked out of him. His coworker Jake was furious, ranting about unfairness and talking about quitting. But Marcus found himself thinking differently. Sure, he was disappointed. But he realized something: he'd been so focused on getting that promotion that he'd stopped appreciating what he already had—a steady job, respect from customers, the satisfaction of helping people solve problems. He'd made his happiness dependent on something completely outside his control. Now he was asking himself harder questions: What if the store closed tomorrow? What if he got injured and couldn't work? Would he still be okay? The answer surprised him—yes, he would figure it out. He always had before.
The Road
The road Seneca walked in ancient Rome, Marcus walks today in the hardware store. The pattern is identical: making happiness dependent on external outcomes creates suffering even before any actual loss occurs.
The Map
This chapter provides the navigation tool of mental preparation—regularly imagining loss to build emotional resilience. Marcus can practice enjoying what he has without being enslaved by what he wants.
Amplification
Before reading this, Marcus might have stayed bitter about the promotion, letting disappointment poison his current job satisfaction. Now he can NAME the pattern of attachment anxiety, PREDICT how it steals present joy, and NAVIGATE it by building emotional independence from outcomes.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Seneca mean when he says the fear of losing something often causes more pain than actually losing it?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Seneca argue that making our happiness dependent on external things creates a kind of slavery?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see people today living in constant anxiety about losing things they value - jobs, relationships, status, or security?
application • medium - 4
How could someone practice Seneca's mental preparation technique without becoming pessimistic or emotionally numb?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about the difference between enjoying something and being enslaved by it?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Practice the Loss Inventory
Make a list of three things you're most afraid of losing right now - could be a job, relationship, health, financial security, or status. For each one, write down what you think would actually happen if you lost it tomorrow. Then ask yourself: would you still be you? Would you find a way forward? This isn't about being negative - it's about building emotional resilience by facing fears directly.
Consider:
- •Focus on what you could control in each scenario, not what you couldn't
- •Notice the difference between imagining loss and actually experiencing it
- •Consider how much mental energy you spend worrying about these losses daily
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you lost something important but discovered you were stronger than you thought. What did that experience teach you about your own resilience?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 99: How to Grieve Without Losing Yourself
Moving forward, we'll examine to distinguish between healthy grief and self-destructive mourning, and understand memories of lost loved ones are treasures that can't be taken away. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.