Original Text(~250 words)
Here is the indictment of the good Lord Hastings, Which in a set hand fairly is engrossed, That it may be to-day read o'er in Paul's. And mark how well the sequel hangs together: Eleven hours I have spent to write it over, For yesternight by Catesby was it sent me; The precedent was full as long a-doing: And yet within these five hours Hastings lived, Untainted, unexamined, free, at liberty. Here's a good world the while! Who is so gross That cannot see this palpable device? Yet who so bold but says he sees it not? Bad is the world; and all will come to nought When such ill dealing must be seen in thought. A scrivener (professional scribe) reveals the smoking gun: the document condemning Hastings was written and copied over eleven hours, but Hastings was only accused and executed within five hours. The document was created before the supposed crime - proving it was a complete setup. The scrivener recognizes the 'palpable device' but knows he cannot speak out. This scene exposes Richard's method: he manufactures evidence to justify predetermined actions. The document isn't a record of a crime - it's a tool created to justify a murder already planned. This shows how manipulators create false evidence, using documents and records not to document truth but to manufacture justification. The scrivener's awareness but silence also shows how systems can be complicit - those who see the manipulation may be powerless to stop it, or may choose silence...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
A scrivener (professional scribe) reveals the smoking gun: the document condemning Hastings was written and copied over eleven hours, but Hastings was only accused and executed within five hours. The document was created before the supposed crime - proving it was a complete setup. The scrivener recognizes the 'palpable device' but knows he cannot speak out. This scene exposes Richard's method: he manufactures evidence to justify predetermined actions. The document isn't a record of a crime - it's a tool created to justify a murder already planned. This shows how manipulators create false evidence, using documents and records not to document truth but to manufacture justification. The scrivener's awareness but silence also shows how systems can be complicit - those who see the manipulation may be powerless to stop it, or may choose silence for self-preservation. This is a crucial scene because it shows an ordinary person recognizing manipulation but being unable or unwilling to expose it.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Scrivener
A professional scribe or copyist who prepares legal and official documents
Modern Usage:
Like a document preparer, legal writer, or administrative assistant who creates official records
Manufactured Evidence
Documents, records, or proof created after a decision to justify that decision, rather than created before to document truth
Modern Usage:
Like performance reviews written after a firing decision, or emails created to justify a predetermined action
Palpable Device
An obvious manipulation or scheme that is clearly visible but goes unacknowledged
Modern Usage:
Like a transparent lie that everyone sees but no one calls out
Characters in This Chapter
The Scrivener
A professional scribe who recognizes the manufactured evidence
The scrivener represents those who see manipulation but are powerless or unwilling to expose it. He recognizes the 'palpable device' but remains silent.
Modern Equivalent:
Someone who sees manipulation but feels powerless to stop it, or chooses silence for self-preservation
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
Some manipulators create false evidence to justify their actions. This skill helps you spot manufactured documents and records.
Practice This Today
When someone produces evidence, examine the timeline. Was it created before or after the decision? Are there inconsistencies? Does the evidence match the timeline of events?
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"And yet within these five hours Hastings lived, Untainted, unexamined, free, at liberty."
Context: The scrivener realizing the document was created before Hastings' supposed crime
The scrivener exposes the timeline: the document took eleven hours to create, but Hastings was only accused five hours ago. The evidence was manufactured.
In Today's Words:
The document was created before the supposed crime - it's manufactured evidence
"Who is so gross That cannot see this palpable device? Yet who so bold but says he sees it not?"
Context: The scrivener recognizing that everyone sees the manipulation but no one speaks
The scrivener recognizes that the manipulation is obvious, but fear and complicity keep people silent. This is how manipulation succeeds.
In Today's Words:
Everyone can see the manipulation, but no one is brave enough to call it out
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Manufactured Evidence
Creating false documents, records, or evidence after a decision to justify that decision, rather than creating evidence before to document truth
Thematic Threads
Corruption
In This Chapter
Evidence is manufactured, not documented
Development
Documents become tools of manipulation
In Your Life:
Watch for evidence created after decisions - it may be manufactured justification
Complicity
In This Chapter
Those who see manipulation often remain silent
Development
Silence enables manipulation
In Your Life:
Recognize when you see manipulation but choose silence - your silence may enable it
Modern Adaptation
The Document Factory
Following Vince's story...
Vince fires Marcus on Monday. On Tuesday, HR produces performance reviews, emails, documentation - all showing why Marcus had to be let go. The evidence is comprehensive, detailed, official. But Sarah, the HR coordinator, knows the truth. She created those documents on Monday afternoon, after Vince told her Marcus was being fired. The performance reviews were backdated. The emails were fabricated. The documentation was manufactured. Sarah sees the 'palpable device' - the manipulation is obvious. But she stays silent. She needs her job. Speaking out would risk her position. So she participates in the evidence factory, creating documents that justify a predetermined decision. The evidence looks legitimate. It's official, detailed, comprehensive. But it's manufactured. The timeline exposes it: the documents were created after the decision, not before. The evidence factory produces justification, not truth.
The Road
Vince's road is paved with manufactured evidence. Documents justify predetermined actions.
The Map
The map shows Vince's evidence factory: create documents after decisions to justify those decisions. The map also shows the trap: evidence that looks legitimate but is manufactured.
Amplification
The scrivener's revelation teaches us that manipulators manufacture evidence. When documents are created after decisions, they may be justification, not truth. Examine the timeline: was evidence created before or after the action?
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does the scrivener's revelation show about Richard's methods? How does the timeline expose the manipulation?
analysis • deep - 2
Why does the scrivener remain silent even though he recognizes the manipulation? What does this show about complicity?
reflection • medium - 3
Have you witnessed manufactured evidence? How was documentation created to justify predetermined actions?
application • surface
Critical Thinking Exercise
The Evidence Timeline Analysis
The scrivener exposes manufactured evidence by examining the timeline. Think of a time when evidence seemed manufactured.
Consider:
- •How do you verify evidence is genuine versus manufactured?
- •What are the signs of manufactured evidence?
- •How can you examine timelines to expose manipulation?
- •What can you do when you recognize manufactured evidence?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you saw manufactured evidence. How did the timeline expose it? Did you speak out or remain silent? Why?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 15: Act III, Scene 7: Richard's Reluctant Acceptance
In the next chapter, you'll discover the manipulation of false modesty, and learn 'reluctant' acceptance is often calculated. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.