Original Text(~250 words)
So now prosperity begins to mellow And drop into the rotten mouth of death. Here in these confines slily have I lurk'd, To watch the waning of mine adversaries. A dire induction am I witness to, And will to France, hoping the consequence Will prove as bitter, black, and tragical. QUEEN ELIZABETH. Decline all this, and see what now thou art: For happy wife, a most distressed widow; For joyful mother, one that wails the name; For one being sued to, one that humbly sues; For queen, a very caitiff crown'd with care; For she that scorn'd at me, now scorn'd of me; For she being feared of all, now fearing one; For she commanding all, obey'd of none. The women of the play - Queen Elizabeth (widow of Edward IV), the Duchess of York (Richard's mother), and Lady Anne (Richard's wife) - come together in a powerful scene to lament their losses. Queen Elizabeth has lost her husband and sons. The Duchess has lost her sons and now curses Richard, her own child. Anne, whom Richard seduced and married, now sees the truth of what she's become. This scene shows the human cost of Richard's manipulations - the real suffering behind the political games. These women have lost everything: husbands, sons, power, dignity. Even Anne, who was complicit in Richard's rise, now recognizes her own complicity and the cost of her choices. The scene is particularly powerful because it shows how manipulation destroys not just enemies, but families, relationships,...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
The women of the play - Queen Elizabeth (widow of Edward IV), the Duchess of York (Richard's mother), and Lady Anne (Richard's wife) - come together in a powerful scene to lament their losses. Queen Elizabeth has lost her husband and sons. The Duchess has lost her sons and now curses Richard, her own child. Anne, whom Richard seduced and married, now sees the truth of what she's become. This scene shows the human cost of Richard's manipulations - the real suffering behind the political games. These women have lost everything: husbands, sons, power, dignity. Even Anne, who was complicit in Richard's rise, now recognizes her own complicity and the cost of her choices. The scene is particularly powerful because it shows how manipulation destroys not just enemies, but families, relationships, and even those who initially benefited. The women's lament reveals the truth that political manipulation has human consequences - real people suffer, real families are destroyed, real lives are lost.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Lament
An expression of grief, sorrow, or mourning
Modern Usage:
Like expressing deep sorrow or regret over loss
Human Cost
The real suffering, loss, and consequences that affect actual people, beyond abstract political or strategic considerations
Modern Usage:
Like recognizing that a corporate restructuring affects real families, not just numbers on a spreadsheet
Characters in This Chapter
Queen Elizabeth
Widow of Edward IV, mother of the murdered princes
Queen Elizabeth represents those who lose everything to manipulation. She's gone from queen to widow, from power to powerlessness, showing the human cost of Richard's rise.
Modern Equivalent:
Someone who loses everything - career, family, security - due to someone else's manipulation
Duchess of York
Richard's mother
Even Richard's own mother curses him, showing the depth of his evil. When your own family recognizes your manipulation, you've crossed a line.
Modern Equivalent:
Someone whose own family recognizes their manipulation and rejects them
Lady Anne
Richard's wife, who was seduced by him
Anne represents those who were complicit in manipulation but now see the truth. She recognizes her own complicity and the cost of her choices.
Modern Equivalent:
Someone who initially benefited from manipulation but now recognizes the cost and their own complicity
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
Manipulation has real human consequences. This skill helps you see beyond the political game to the real suffering.
Practice This Today
When you see manipulation, look for the human cost. Who suffers? What are the real consequences? How are families, relationships, and lives affected? Don't just focus on the game - see the people.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"So now prosperity begins to mellow And drop into the rotten mouth of death."
Context: Queen Elizabeth lamenting the fall from prosperity to destruction
This quote captures the theme of the scene: how prosperity and power can quickly turn to destruction and death. The 'rotten mouth of death' suggests that Richard's manipulation consumes everything.
In Today's Words:
Everything we had is now being destroyed and consumed
"For happy wife, a most distressed widow; For joyful mother, one that wails the name; For one being sued to, one that humbly sues; For queen, a very caitiff crown'd with care;"
Context: Queen Elizabeth describing her fall from power and happiness
This powerful litany shows the complete reversal of fortune. Queen Elizabeth has lost everything: her husband, her children, her power, her dignity. The human cost is devastating.
In Today's Words:
I've lost everything: my husband, my children, my power, my dignity
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Human Cost
Recognizing that manipulation has real human consequences - suffering, loss, destroyed relationships - beyond abstract political or strategic considerations
Thematic Threads
Consequences
In This Chapter
Real people suffer from manipulation
Development
Manipulation has human costs beyond the game
In Your Life:
When you see manipulation, look for the human cost. Who suffers? What are the real consequences?
Complicity
In This Chapter
Anne recognizes her own complicity
Development
Those who benefit from manipulation may also suffer
In Your Life:
Recognize when you're complicit in manipulation - even if you benefit, you may also pay a cost
Modern Adaptation
The Human Cost
Following Vince's story...
Families gather in a coffee shop, sharing stories. Sarah talks about how Vince's manipulation destroyed her career. Marcus's wife describes how the firing devastated their family. Former colleagues share stories of destroyed relationships, lost opportunities, damaged mental health. The human cost becomes clear: this isn't just about corporate politics. Real people have suffered. Real families have been affected. Real lives have been damaged. Even those who initially benefited from Vince's manipulation - those who got promotions, those who stayed silent - now recognize the cost. They see their own complicity. They see the suffering they enabled. The women's lament reminds us that manipulation has victims. Behind every political game, there are real people with real losses. The human cost matters.
The Road
Vince's road is paved with human suffering. Real people pay the price for his manipulation.
The Map
The map shows the human cost: destroyed careers, broken families, damaged relationships. The map also shows the trap: focusing on the game while ignoring the suffering.
Amplification
The women's lament teaches us that manipulation has human costs. When manipulators succeed, real people suffer. Look beyond the game to see the real consequences. The human cost matters.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does the women's lament show about the cost of Richard's manipulations? How does it humanize the consequences?
analysis • deep - 2
Why is it important to recognize the human cost of manipulation? How does focusing on the game obscure the suffering?
reflection • medium - 3
Have you witnessed manipulation with human costs? How did real people suffer?
application • surface
Critical Thinking Exercise
The Cost Analysis
The women's lament shows the human cost of manipulation. Think of manipulation you've witnessed or been part of.
Consider:
- •What are the real human consequences of manipulation?
- •Who suffers when manipulators succeed?
- •How can focusing on the game obscure the suffering?
- •What can you do to recognize and address human costs?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you saw the human cost of manipulation. Who suffered? What were the real consequences? How did it affect families, relationships, and lives?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 17: Act IV, Scene 2: Richard's Coronation
The coming pages reveal power changes people, and teach us paranoia follows manipulation. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.