Original Text(~250 words)
Chapter II. The Alarm Our police captain, Mihail Makarovitch Makarov, a retired lieutenant‐ colonel, was a widower and an excellent man. He had only come to us three years previously, but had won general esteem, chiefly because he “knew how to keep society together.” He was never without visitors, and could not have got on without them. Some one or other was always dining with him; he never sat down to table without guests. He gave regular dinners, too, on all sorts of occasions, sometimes most surprising ones. Though the fare was not _recherché_, it was abundant. The fish‐pies were excellent, and the wine made up in quantity for what it lacked in quality. The first room his guests entered was a well‐fitted billiard‐room, with pictures of English race‐horses, in black frames on the walls, an essential decoration, as we all know, for a bachelor’s billiard‐room. There was card‐playing every evening at his house, if only at one table. But at frequent intervals, all the society of our town, with the mammas and young ladies, assembled at his house to dance. Though Mihail Makarovitch was a widower, he did not live alone. His widowed daughter lived with him, with her two unmarried daughters, grown‐up girls, who had finished their education. They were of agreeable appearance and lively character, and though every one knew they would have no dowry, they attracted all the young men of fashion to their grandfather’s house. Mihail Makarovitch was by no means very efficient in his...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
The murder of Fyodor Karamazov sends shockwaves through the local power structure, revealing how authority figures respond when crisis strikes their community. Police Captain Makarov, a well-meaning but limited man who runs his household like a social club, suddenly finds himself at the center of a major investigation. The prosecutor and investigating lawyer, each carrying their own ambitions and insecurities, leap into action with theories already forming. Meanwhile, the actual discovery unfolds through the eyes of servants and neighbors - Marfa finding her injured husband Grigory, then discovering her master's bloody corpse through a lit window. The evidence seems damning: a brass pestle weapon, an empty envelope that once held three thousand rubles marked for Grushenka, and Dmitri's earlier threats. The authorities quickly piece together a narrative that confirms their suspicions about the eldest Karamazov brother. As they prepare to arrest Dmitri at the inn in Mokroe, we see how institutions mobilize around emerging stories, often before all facts are known. The chapter exposes the machinery of justice in action - sometimes efficient, sometimes bumbling, but always shaped by the personalities and limitations of those who operate it. Dostoevsky shows us how crisis reveals character, both in those who respond to it and those who must navigate its consequences.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Police Captain
In 19th century Russia, a local law enforcement official who combined police duties with social leadership in small towns. They were often retired military officers who maintained order through personal relationships rather than formal procedures.
Modern Usage:
Like a small-town sheriff who knows everyone and runs things through personal connections rather than strict protocol.
Investigating Lawyer
A judicial official in the Russian legal system who conducted preliminary investigations of crimes, gathering evidence and questioning witnesses before trial. They had significant power to shape how cases developed.
Modern Usage:
Similar to a district attorney or lead detective who builds the case and decides what charges to file.
Dowry
Money or property that a woman's family provided when she married, essentially her contribution to the new household. Without a dowry, women from good families often couldn't marry within their social class.
Modern Usage:
Like when parents today help their kids buy their first house or pay for a wedding - financial support that affects marriage prospects.
Society
The local social elite - families with money, education, or government positions who formed the town's upper class. They set social standards and controlled access to respectability.
Modern Usage:
The influential crowd in any community - country club members, business leaders, the families everyone knows and talks about.
Circumstantial Evidence
Facts that suggest someone committed a crime without directly proving it, like being seen near the scene or having a motive. It requires connecting dots rather than having clear proof.
Modern Usage:
When everything points to someone being guilty even without a smoking gun - like finding someone's fingerprints and having video of them nearby.
Mob Justice
When a community decides someone is guilty and wants immediate punishment without waiting for proper legal procedures. Emotions and assumptions drive the response rather than careful investigation.
Modern Usage:
Cancel culture, social media pile-ons, or when a neighborhood decides someone is guilty before the trial even starts.
Characters in This Chapter
Mihail Makarovitch Makarov
Local authority figure
The police captain who must handle the murder investigation despite being better suited for hosting dinner parties than solving crimes. His social approach to leadership gets tested when real crisis hits.
Modern Equivalent:
The small-town sheriff who's great at community relations but gets overwhelmed by serious crime
The Prosecutor
Legal authority
Ambitious legal official who sees the murder case as an opportunity to advance his career. He quickly forms theories about Dmitri's guilt and pushes for rapid action.
Modern Equivalent:
The district attorney who plays politics with high-profile cases
The Investigating Lawyer
Evidence gatherer
Young, eager legal official who takes charge of building the case against Dmitri. He's methodical but also influenced by the prosecutor's assumptions about guilt.
Modern Equivalent:
The lead detective who gets caught up in making the evidence fit the theory
Marfa
Key witness
The servant who discovers both her injured husband Grigory and Fyodor's murder. Her testimony becomes crucial evidence, though she's traumatized and may not be entirely reliable.
Modern Equivalent:
The neighbor who calls 911 and becomes the star witness everyone depends on
Grigory
Injured witness
The loyal servant who tried to stop the killer and got knocked unconscious. His injuries and confused memories add to the mystery while seeming to confirm Dmitri's presence.
Modern Equivalent:
The security guard who got hurt trying to stop a crime but can't remember exactly what happened
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to distinguish between real knowledge and the performance of expertise that people use to protect their authority.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone becomes an instant expert on a situation they just learned about, and ask yourself what they actually know versus what they're assuming.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"He knew how to keep society together."
Context: Describing why Police Captain Makarov was respected in the community
This reveals how leadership in small communities often depends more on social skills than professional competence. Makarov's strength is hosting dinner parties, not solving murders.
In Today's Words:
He was good at bringing people together and keeping everyone happy.
"Though every one knew they would have no dowry, they attracted all the young men of fashion."
Context: Describing Makarov's granddaughters and their marriage prospects
Shows how social dynamics work even when money is lacking - personality and access to the right social circles can overcome financial disadvantages.
In Today's Words:
Everyone knew these girls didn't have money, but they were still popular with the eligible guys.
"The evidence seemed to point in one direction."
Context: As authorities examine the crime scene and piece together what happened
Captures how investigations can develop tunnel vision early on, focusing on the most obvious suspect rather than considering all possibilities.
In Today's Words:
Everything seemed to point to the same person being guilty.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Instant Expertise - How Crisis Makes Everyone an Expert
When crisis strikes, people rush to become experts on situations they barely understand to avoid appearing incompetent or uncertain.
Thematic Threads
Authority
In This Chapter
Police and prosecutors immediately take charge despite limited understanding, more concerned with appearing competent than being thorough
Development
Builds on earlier themes of institutional power, showing how authority figures respond under pressure
In Your Life:
You might see this when supervisors make quick decisions during workplace crises to maintain their image of control.
Narrative
In This Chapter
The investigators quickly construct a story that fits their preconceptions about Dmitri rather than following evidence
Development
Continues the book's exploration of how people create stories to make sense of chaos
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself doing this when family drama erupts and you immediately assume you know who's at fault.
Class
In This Chapter
The servants who actually discover the crime are quickly pushed aside as the educated authorities take control of the narrative
Development
Reinforces ongoing themes about whose voices matter in crisis situations
In Your Life:
You might notice this when frontline workers who know the real situation are ignored while managers make decisions.
Evidence
In This Chapter
Physical clues like the pestle and empty envelope become confirmation of predetermined theories rather than neutral facts to investigate
Development
Introduced here as exploration of how bias shapes interpretation of facts
In Your Life:
You might see this when you're already upset with someone and interpret their neutral actions as proof of bad intentions.
Crisis
In This Chapter
The murder creates urgency that pushes everyone toward quick conclusions rather than careful investigation
Development
Builds on earlier explorations of how pressure reveals character
In Your Life:
You might experience this when a family emergency makes everyone rush to solutions before understanding the full situation.
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Ivan's story...
When the shift supervisor at the warehouse is found stealing inventory, Ivan watches management spring into action with instant expertise. The district manager, who visits maybe twice a year, suddenly has theories about 'warning signs we should have caught.' The HR representative, fresh from corporate training, confidently explains the 'typical profile' of employee theft. Security footage shows Ivan's coworker Marcus near the loading dock around the time items went missing—Marcus, who's been struggling with his sick kid's medical bills and made some bitter comments about management bonuses. The evidence seems clear: access, motive, opportunity. But Ivan remembers seeing the night janitor acting strange, notices how quickly everyone accepted the Marcus narrative, and feels uncomfortable with how eager management seems to close this case. The union rep is already preparing Marcus's defense, but even he seems half-convinced of guilt. As the investigation moves toward inevitable conclusion, Ivan realizes they're watching people protect their own certainty rather than seek truth.
The Road
The road Dostoevsky's investigators walked in 1880, Ivan walks today. The pattern is identical: when crisis strikes, people become instant experts to protect themselves from appearing incompetent or uncertain.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for recognizing when expertise is performance rather than knowledge. Ivan can use it to slow down rushed conclusions and ask what people actually know versus what they're assuming.
Amplification
Before reading this, Ivan might have been intimidated by confident authorities and assumed they knew best. Now they can NAME instant expertise, PREDICT how it leads to wrong conclusions, and NAVIGATE by asking for actual evidence rather than theories.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
How do the different authority figures (police captain, prosecutor, investigating lawyer) each respond to the crisis of the murder, and what does this reveal about their priorities?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do the investigators quickly settle on Dmitri as the prime suspect rather than thoroughly examining all possibilities?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about a recent crisis in your workplace, family, or community. Who immediately became 'experts' on the situation, and how did their instant theories shape what happened next?
application • medium - 4
When you're faced with uncertainty in a crisis, what strategies could you use to resist the pressure to have immediate answers or explanations?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how people in positions of authority handle situations that threaten their image of competence?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Track the Expertise Timeline
Choose a recent crisis or dramatic event from your own life, workplace, or community. Create a timeline showing when different people became 'experts' on what happened and what their theories were. Note how quickly these theories formed and whether they were based on actual facts or assumptions.
Consider:
- •Who had theories before they had facts?
- •What did each person's theory reveal about their own fears or biases?
- •How did the rush to expertise affect the actual handling of the situation?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you felt pressure to have immediate answers to a complex problem. How did that pressure affect your decision-making, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 56: Breaking Point Under Pressure
As the story unfolds, you'll explore extreme stress can cause emotional swings between despair and hope, while uncovering taking responsibility for your actions (while maintaining innocence of false charges) builds credibility. These lessons connect the classic to contemporary challenges we all face.