Original Text(~250 words)
CHAPTER XXXIX. OLD AND NEW ACQUAINTANCE. Fascinated as by a basilisk with three heads, I could not leave this clique; the ground near them seemed to hold my feet. The canopy of entwined trees held out shadow, the night whispered a pledge of protection, and an officious lamp flashed just one beam to show me an obscure, safe seat, and then vanished. Let me now briefly tell the reader all that, during the past dark fortnight, I have been silently gathering from Rumour, respecting the origin and the object of M. Emanuel’s departure. The tale is short, and not new: its alpha is Mammon, and its omega Interest. If Madame Walravens was hideous as a Hindoo idol, she seemed also to possess, in the estimation of these her votaries, an idol’s consequence. The fact was, she had been rich—very rich; and though, for the present, without the command of money, she was likely one day to be rich again. At Basseterre, in Guadaloupe, she possessed a large estate, received in dowry on her marriage sixty years ago, sequestered since her husband’s failure; but now, it was supposed, cleared of claim, and, if duly looked after by a competent agent of integrity, considered capable of being made, in a few years, largely productive. Père Silas took an interest in this prospective improvement for the sake of religion and the church, whereof Magliore Walravens was a devout daughter. Madame Beck, distantly related to the hunchback and knowing her to be without family...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Lucy finally discovers the truth behind multiple mysteries that have tormented her. Hidden in the park during a festival, she overhears a conversation revealing that M. Emanuel's departure was orchestrated by three scheming individuals: Madame Walravens (who needs someone to manage her West Indian estate), Père Silas (who wants to remove Emanuel from Lucy's 'heretical' influence), and Madame Beck (who prefers to destroy what she cannot have). The mysterious 'Justine Marie' turns out to be a living, breathing young woman—Emanuel's wealthy ward—not the ghostly nun Lucy imagined. Most crushing of all, Lucy realizes that Emanuel has delayed his voyage, not for her, but to settle affairs regarding his upcoming marriage to this young heiress. The revelation devastates her, but she forces herself to accept this painful truth rather than cling to false hope. Returning home, Lucy finally confronts the 'nun' that has haunted her—only to discover it's an elaborate hoax: nun's clothing arranged on a bolster, left with a mocking note. The chapter shows Lucy's psychological journey from tortured uncertainty to brutal clarity, as she learns that facing reality, however painful, is preferable to living with illusions that slowly poison the soul.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Basilisk
A mythical serpent whose gaze could kill or paralyze victims. Lucy uses this metaphor to describe how the three conspirators hold her spellbound with fascination and dread. It captures the dangerous allure of forbidden knowledge.
Modern Usage:
We still say someone has a 'paralyzing stare' or describe being 'frozen' by shocking revelations.
Mammon
Biblical term for wealth worshipped as a false god, representing greed and materialism. Lucy reveals that money, not love, drives M. Emanuel's departure. It's the 'alpha' (beginning) of this whole scheme.
Modern Usage:
We talk about 'chasing the almighty dollar' or say someone 'sold their soul' for money.
Sequestered estate
Property legally seized due to debt or bankruptcy, held until claims are settled. Madame Walravens' West Indian plantation was taken when her husband failed financially but may now be returned to her control.
Modern Usage:
Today we see assets frozen during divorce proceedings or homes in foreclosure limbo.
Votaries
Devoted followers or worshippers, usually of a religious figure. Lucy sarcastically calls the three conspirators Madame Walravens' 'votaries' because they treat her wealth like a sacred cause worth serving.
Modern Usage:
We call people 'followers' or say someone has a 'cult of personality' around their success.
Heretical influence
Ideas or beliefs that go against established religious doctrine. Père Silas views Lucy's Protestant faith as dangerous to Emanuel's Catholic soul and wants to separate them before she corrupts him further.
Modern Usage:
People still worry about 'bad influences' corrupting family members with different values or lifestyles.
Dowry
Money or property a woman's family gives to her husband when she marries. Madame Walravens received the plantation as part of her marriage settlement sixty years ago, making it legally hers.
Modern Usage:
Though formal dowries are rare now, families still help newlyweds with money for houses or weddings.
Characters in This Chapter
Lucy Snowe
Protagonist and narrator
Hidden in the shadows, Lucy finally overhears the truth about M. Emanuel's departure and the conspiracy against their relationship. She forces herself to face painful reality rather than cling to false hope.
Modern Equivalent:
The woman who accidentally discovers her partner's real reasons for leaving
Madame Walravens
Wealthy widow and puppet master
The ancient, wealthy widow who needs M. Emanuel to manage her West Indian estate. Despite her hideous appearance, her money makes her powerful enough to control others' destinies.
Modern Equivalent:
The rich elderly relative everyone caters to because of inheritance expectations
Père Silas
Religious manipulator
The Catholic priest who wants to remove M. Emanuel from Lucy's 'heretical' Protestant influence. He uses religious duty to mask his desire to control Emanuel's personal life.
Modern Equivalent:
The religious leader who interferes in members' relationships for 'spiritual' reasons
Madame Beck
Jealous schemer
Lucy's employer who would rather destroy M. Emanuel's happiness than see him with someone else. She joins the conspiracy because she cannot have him herself.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss who sabotages employees' relationships out of jealousy
M. Emanuel
Unwitting pawn
The man Lucy loves, now revealed to be manipulated by three powerful figures into leaving for the West Indies. His sense of duty makes him vulnerable to their schemes.
Modern Equivalent:
The good guy pressured by family obligations into making choices that hurt his relationships
Justine Marie
The mysterious ward
The living young woman Lucy discovers is M. Emanuel's wealthy ward, not the ghostly nun she imagined. Her existence threatens Lucy's hopes for a future with Emanuel.
Modern Equivalent:
The younger woman whose connection to your partner you completely misunderstood
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to separate what you actually know from the elaborate narratives your anxious mind creates to fill information gaps.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you're creating stories about unclear situations—write down what you actually know versus what you're assuming, then take one concrete step toward getting real information.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The tale is short, and not new: its alpha is Mammon, and its omega Interest."
Context: Lucy reveals the true motivation behind M. Emanuel's departure
This biblical reference shows Lucy's bitter realization that money, not love or duty, drives human behavior. She's learned that even the most romantic situations often have cold, financial motivations underneath.
In Today's Words:
It's the same old story - it's all about money from start to finish.
"Madame Beck, distantly related to the hunchback and knowing her to be without family, had long brooded over contingencies with a mother's calculating forethought for her own children."
Context: Lucy explains why Madame Beck joined the conspiracy
This reveals Madame Beck's true nature - she's not just jealous but coldly calculating, thinking about inheritance money for her children. It shows how people can disguise greed as family concern.
In Today's Words:
Madame Beck was already planning how to get her hands on the old lady's money for her kids.
"I had heard this very same yesterday as a model teacher, the next day received royal treatment as a favoured child, yet the third day burned at the stake as a heretic."
Context: Lucy reflects on how quickly people's treatment of her changes
This powerful metaphor captures the exhausting unpredictability of trying to please others. Lucy realizes that people's opinions change based on their own interests, not her actual worth.
In Today's Words:
One day I'm the perfect employee, the next I'm the favorite, then suddenly I'm the enemy.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Necessary Truth
The tendency to torture ourselves with unknowns rather than seeking painful but liberating truth.
Thematic Threads
Truth vs. Illusion
In This Chapter
Lucy discovers the 'nun' was a hoax and Emanuel's departure has nothing to do with romance
Development
Evolved from Lucy's earlier self-deceptions about her feelings and place in the world
In Your Life:
You might find yourself clinging to comfortable lies rather than facing difficult realities about relationships or career prospects.
Class Power
In This Chapter
Three powerful figures—Madame Walravens, Père Silas, and Madame Beck—manipulate Emanuel's life for their own purposes
Development
Continuation of how social hierarchy shapes individual choices throughout the novel
In Your Life:
You might recognize how people with more resources or authority make decisions that affect your life without considering your feelings.
Psychological Liberation
In This Chapter
Lucy chooses to face devastating truth rather than live with tormenting uncertainty
Development
Represents growth from her earlier passive suffering and self-denial
In Your Life:
You might need to choose between the pain of knowing something difficult and the ongoing torture of not knowing.
Manipulation
In This Chapter
The elaborate conspiracy to remove Emanuel and the cruel nun hoax reveal how others toy with Lucy's emotions
Development
Builds on earlier themes of how authority figures control information to maintain power
In Your Life:
You might recognize when people withhold information or create false narratives to control your behavior or emotions.
Economic Dependency
In This Chapter
Emanuel must marry Justine Marie for financial reasons, showing how money shapes personal relationships
Development
Continues the novel's exploration of how financial necessity overrides personal desire
In Your Life:
You might see how financial pressures force people to make relationship choices that have nothing to do with love.
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Lucy's story...
Lucy has been torturing herself for weeks about mysterious changes at her international school. The principal's cryptic meetings, whispered conversations stopping when she enters rooms, and rumors about 'restructuring' have her imagining everything from mass layoffs to being singled out for deportation. Tonight, staying late to grade papers, she overhears the truth through thin office walls: three administrators conspiring to push out James, the department head she's grown close to. The elderly board chair needs someone to run her foundation's overseas programs. The conservative vice-principal wants James away from Lucy's 'bad influence' on school traditions. And the principal, who's always resented their friendship, would rather destroy what she can't control. Worse, Lucy discovers James isn't fighting the transfer because he's planning to marry Elena, the wealthy donor's daughter, for practical reasons—visa status, financial security, a future his teaching salary can't provide. The revelation devastates her, but she forces herself to accept this brutal truth rather than cling to false hope about their connection.
The Road
The road Charlotte Brontë's Lucy walked in 1853, Lucy walks today. The pattern is identical: uncertainty becomes torture when we lack information about situations that matter to us, creating elaborate fantasies worse than reality.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for handling workplace uncertainty and personal disappointment. Lucy can use it to recognize when not-knowing is causing more suffering than knowing would, even when the truth hurts.
Amplification
Before reading this, Lucy might have continued torturing herself with endless speculation and false hope. Now she can NAME the pattern of uncertainty-torture, PREDICT how her imagination makes things worse than reality, and NAVIGATE toward painful truth rather than comfortable delusion.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What three truths does Lucy finally discover in this chapter, and how do they differ from what she had imagined?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do you think Lucy's imagination created scenarios that were more dramatic and painful than the actual truth?
analysis • medium - 3
Think about a time when you worried endlessly about something unknown. How did the reality compare to your worst fears?
application • medium - 4
Lucy chooses to accept painful truth rather than cling to false hope. When is it worth pursuing clarity even when you suspect the answer will hurt?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter suggest about the relationship between uncertainty and suffering? Why might not knowing be worse than knowing something painful?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Truth vs. Uncertainty Audit
List three situations in your life where you're currently living with uncertainty that's causing you stress or mental loops. For each situation, write down what you actually know versus what you're assuming or imagining. Then identify one concrete step you could take to move toward clarity in each case.
Consider:
- •Notice how much mental energy uncertainty consumes compared to dealing with facts
- •Consider whether your imagination is creating scenarios worse than reality likely holds
- •Think about what specific information would actually help you move forward
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you finally got clarity on something you'd been worrying about. How did the truth compare to your fears, and what did you learn about the cost of living in uncertainty?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 40: The Mystery Revealed
In the next chapter, you'll discover secrets eventually surface and reshape our understanding of events, and learn some people thrive by avoiding responsibility while others carry burdens. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.