Original Text(~250 words)
HE came again, without managing the last parting; and again and again, without finding that Mrs. Penniman had as yet done much to pave the path of retreat with flowers. It was devilish awkward, as he said, and he felt a lively animosity for Catherine’s aunt, who, as he had now quite formed the habit of saying to himself, had dragged him into the mess and was bound in common charity to get him out of it. Mrs. Penniman, to tell the truth, had, in the seclusion of her own apartment—and, I may add, amid the suggestiveness of Catherine’s, which wore in those days the appearance of that of a young lady laying out her _trousseau_—Mrs. Penniman had measured her responsibilities, and taken fright at their magnitude. The task of preparing Catherine and easing off Morris presented difficulties which increased in the execution, and even led the impulsive Lavinia to ask herself whether the modification of the young man’s original project had been conceived in a happy spirit. A brilliant future, a wider career, a conscience exempt from the reproach of interference between a young lady and her natural rights—these excellent things might be too troublesomely purchased. From Catherine herself Mrs. Penniman received no assistance whatever; the poor girl was apparently without suspicion of her danger. She looked at her lover with eyes of undiminished trust, and though she had less confidence in her aunt than in a young man with whom she had exchanged so many tender vows, she...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Morris is desperately trying to escape his engagement to Catherine, but he's too cowardly to break up with her directly. Instead, he creates an elaborate story about needing to travel to New Orleans for business, hoping she'll either get angry enough to end things or give him an excuse to leave. Mrs. Penniman, who helped create this mess by encouraging the romance, is now paralyzed by guilt and can't bring herself to help Morris find a graceful exit. Catherine, meanwhile, sees right through Morris's excuses with devastating clarity. When he claims he needs to make six thousand dollars in cotton trading, she points out they don't need the money and that he's thinking about business when he should be thinking about her. She offers to go with him, shoots down his concerns about yellow fever, and basically calls out every excuse he makes. The more reasonable and loving Catherine becomes, the more trapped Morris feels. He tries to pick a fight with her, calling her indiscreet and telling her not to bully him, but she just apologizes and becomes more gentle. Finally, Morris promises to return but rushes out, leaving Catherine with the terrible realization that he might not come back. This chapter shows how people behave when they want out of a relationship but lack the courage to be honest. Morris's elaborate deceptions reveal his character, while Catherine's responses show both her deep love and her growing awareness that something is very wrong.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Trousseau
The clothes, linens, and household items a bride collected before marriage. In the 1800s, preparing a trousseau was a major part of engagement, showing the family's wealth and the bride's domestic skills.
Modern Usage:
Today we see this in wedding registries and the months of planning that go into weddings - the idea that marriage requires extensive preparation and material goods.
Cotton trading
A risky business venture in the 1800s where men would travel south to buy cotton and sell it for profit. It was often used as an excuse for travel or making quick money, but was genuinely dangerous and unpredictable.
Modern Usage:
Like someone today claiming they need to go to Vegas or invest in cryptocurrency to 'make it big' - often a cover for wanting to escape responsibilities.
Yellow fever
A deadly disease common in southern ports like New Orleans in the 1800s. It was a real threat that killed thousands, making travel there genuinely dangerous, especially for northerners with no immunity.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how people today might use health scares or dangerous situations as reasons to avoid commitments or travel.
Natural rights
The idea that young women had the right to marry for love and make their own romantic choices, rather than having marriages arranged by families. This was a newer concept in the 1800s.
Modern Usage:
Today we take for granted that people should choose their own partners, but this shows how recent that freedom really is.
Tender vows
Romantic promises and declarations of love exchanged between engaged couples. In the 1800s, these were considered sacred commitments that bound people together morally and socially.
Modern Usage:
Like the sweet promises couples make early in relationships - 'I'll never hurt you,' 'We'll always be together' - that feel binding at the time.
Common charity
Basic human decency and kindness that people owe each other. Morris expects Mrs. Penniman to help him escape the situation she helped create, seeing it as her moral obligation.
Modern Usage:
When someone says 'You got me into this mess, you need to help me get out' - expecting others to clean up problems they helped create.
Characters in This Chapter
Morris
Reluctant suitor
He's desperately trying to escape his engagement to Catherine but lacks the courage to break up honestly. Instead, he creates elaborate excuses about needing to travel for business, hoping she'll either end things or give him a reason to leave.
Modern Equivalent:
The guy who ghosts instead of having the breakup conversation
Catherine
Trusting fiancée
She sees through Morris's excuses with devastating clarity but responds with love and reasonableness, which only makes him feel more trapped. Her offer to accompany him and her logical responses to his concerns expose his true intentions.
Modern Equivalent:
The girlfriend who calls out her partner's lies with uncomfortable accuracy
Mrs. Penniman
Guilty matchmaker
Having encouraged the romance, she's now paralyzed by guilt and the complexity of helping Morris escape. She realizes she's created a mess but can't bring herself to hurt Catherine by helping Morris leave.
Modern Equivalent:
The friend who set up the couple and now regrets it but doesn't know how to fix things
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone is creating problems to avoid taking responsibility for ending a relationship or commitment.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone keeps adding complications to simple situations - they might be hoping you'll give up so they don't have to say no directly.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"She looked at her lover with eyes of undiminished trust"
Context: Describing Catherine's continued faith in Morris despite his obvious attempts to escape
This shows the tragic gap between Catherine's innocent trust and Morris's deception. Her unwavering faith makes his betrayal more cruel and his escape more difficult.
In Today's Words:
She still believed in him completely, even when he was clearly pulling away
"It was devilish awkward, as he said"
Context: Morris's internal frustration about being trapped in the engagement
This reveals Morris's selfishness - he sees the situation only in terms of his own discomfort, not the pain he's causing Catherine. The casual profanity shows his lack of respect for the sacred nature of engagement.
In Today's Words:
This whole thing was really messing with his head
"The poor girl was apparently without suspicion of her danger"
Context: Describing Catherine's unawareness that Morris wants to leave her
The word 'danger' is crucial - it shows that losing Morris would genuinely harm Catherine, while also suggesting her innocence makes her vulnerable to betrayal.
In Today's Words:
She had no idea he was about to break her heart
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Cowardly Exit Strategies
Creating elaborate circumstances to avoid directly ending a commitment, hoping the other party will do the breaking up instead.
Thematic Threads
Emotional Cowardice
In This Chapter
Morris creates an elaborate business trip story rather than honestly ending the engagement
Development
His cowardice has escalated from passive avoidance to active deception
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when someone in your life starts creating unnecessary drama instead of having a direct conversation.
Clear-Sighted Love
In This Chapter
Catherine sees through every excuse Morris makes but responds with patience and reason
Development
Her clarity about others has grown while her self-protection instincts remain underdeveloped
In Your Life:
You might find yourself making excuses for someone's bad behavior because you love them and want to believe their explanations.
Trapped by Kindness
In This Chapter
The more reasonable and accommodating Catherine becomes, the more trapped Morris feels
Development
This dynamic has been building as Catherine's goodness makes Morris's selfishness more obvious
In Your Life:
You might have experienced how being understanding and flexible can sometimes make difficult people feel worse, not better.
Guilt and Paralysis
In This Chapter
Mrs. Penniman knows she helped create this mess but is too paralyzed by guilt to help fix it
Development
Her meddling has consequences she didn't anticipate and can't handle
In Your Life:
You might recognize times when your good intentions created problems you felt too ashamed to address directly.
The Weight of Pretense
In This Chapter
Morris's elaborate lies require constant maintenance and make him increasingly desperate
Development
His deceptions have grown more complex as his situation becomes more impossible
In Your Life:
You might have experienced how small lies require bigger lies, creating stress that's often worse than just telling the truth would have been.
Modern Adaptation
When He Can't Say He's Done
Following Catherine's story...
Catherine's boyfriend Jake has been acting weird about their wedding plans. First he said they needed to postpone because his cousin might get deployed and he wants him as best man. Then it was saving more money. Now he's talking about taking a job in Phoenix - great opportunity, he says, but he'd have to leave next month and isn't sure when he'd be back. Catherine watches him pile excuse on top of excuse, each one more elaborate than the last. When she offers to come with him, he lists all the reasons why that won't work - the cost of living, her job at the nursing home, her grandmother who needs her. She suggests they do long distance, and he talks about how hard that would be on both of them. Every solution she offers, he shoots down. Every reasonable response she gives makes him more agitated. She can see him building a wall of complications, hoping she'll be the one to say 'forget it' so he doesn't have to admit he wants out.
The Road
The road Morris walked in 1880, Catherine walks today. The pattern is identical: when someone wants out but lacks courage to be honest, they create elaborate scenarios hoping you'll do the breaking up for them.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for recognizing emotional cowardice disguised as circumstances. Catherine can cut through the elaborate stories by asking direct questions and refusing to take the bait.
Amplification
Before reading this, Catherine might have exhausted herself trying to solve every problem Jake invented, believing his stories were real obstacles. Now she can NAME it as avoidance, PREDICT he'll keep escalating until she breaks, and NAVIGATE by forcing him to either commit or admit the truth.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What elaborate story does Morris create to avoid breaking up with Catherine directly, and how does she respond to each of his excuses?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Morris choose to create this complicated New Orleans business story instead of simply telling Catherine he wants to end their engagement?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this pattern of creating elaborate excuses instead of having an honest conversation - in workplaces, relationships, or family situations?
application • medium - 4
If you were Catherine's friend, what advice would you give her about how to handle Morris's obvious attempt to make her break up with him?
application • deep - 5
What does Morris's behavior reveal about how people handle situations where they want out of commitments but don't want to be seen as the 'bad guy'?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode the Real Message
Think of a recent situation where someone gave you elaborate reasons for why they couldn't do something - cancel plans, avoid a conversation, delay a decision. Write down their stated reasons, then write what you think they were really trying to communicate. Practice translating excuse-language into honest communication.
Consider:
- •Look for patterns where the excuses keep getting more complicated or unreasonable
- •Notice if the person seems to want you to argue with them or get frustrated
- •Consider whether they're hoping you'll make the decision for them so they don't have to
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you created elaborate excuses instead of having an honest conversation. What were you really afraid would happen if you told the truth?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 30: The Mask Falls Away
In the next chapter, you'll discover to recognize when someone's true character is revealed under pressure, and learn the difference between emotional manipulation and genuine support. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.