Original Text(~250 words)
M. Gillenormand was one of those old men who await death perfectly erect, whom age burdens without making them stoop, and whom even grief does not bend. Still, for some time past, his daughter had been saying that he was failing. He no longer boxed the servants' ears; he no longer thumped the landing so vigorously with his cane when Basque was slow in opening the door. The Revolution of July had scarcely exasperated him for six months. He had seen, almost tranquilly, in the Moniteur, this coupling of words: M. Humblot-Conté, peer of France. The fact is, that the old man was filled with dejection. He did not bend, he did not yield; this was no more a trait of his physical than of his moral nature; but he felt himself giving way internally. Four years had elapsed since Marius had left, and no news of him had reached them. He could not, without a pang, resign himself to the idea that Marius was lost to him forever. The aging M. Gillenormand struggles with the absence of his grandson Marius, who left four years ago after their political disagreements reached a breaking point. Despite his stubborn exterior and conservative beliefs, the old man is internally devastated by the loss of family connection. The chapter reveals how political and social upheavals can tear families apart, as Gillenormand's royalist views clash with Marius's growing republican sympathies. Hugo masterfully portrays the tragedy of two people who love each other but cannot bridge...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
The aging M. Gillenormand struggles with the absence of his grandson Marius, who left four years ago after their political disagreements reached a breaking point. Despite his stubborn exterior and conservative beliefs, the old man is internally devastated by the loss of family connection. The chapter reveals how political and social upheavals can tear families apart, as Gillenormand's royalist views clash with Marius's growing republican sympathies. Hugo masterfully portrays the tragedy of two people who love each other but cannot bridge their ideological differences, showing how pride and inflexibility can destroy the very relationships we treasure most.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Peer of France
A member of the French nobility with hereditary titles and legislative privileges
Modern Usage:
Today we see similar elite circles in politics and business where connections and background determine access to power
Revolution of July
The 1830 revolution that overthrew King Charles X and brought Louis-Philippe to power
Modern Usage:
Any sudden political upheaval that challenges established authority and creates generational divides
Royalist
Someone who supports monarchy and traditional aristocratic values
Modern Usage:
Anyone who clings to outdated systems or refuses to adapt to social change
Characters in This Chapter
M. Gillenormand
Marius's ninety-year-old conservative grandfather
Represents the old aristocratic world struggling against inevitable change
Modern Equivalent:
The stubborn family patriarch who can't understand why younger generations reject traditional values
Marius
Young man estranged from his grandfather over political beliefs
Embodies the generational conflict between old and new France
Modern Equivalent:
The college student who comes home with different political views than their conservative parents
Basque
The family's loyal servant
Shows how even domestic relationships reflect broader social tensions
Modern Equivalent:
The longtime employee caught in the middle of family conflicts
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
The ability to maintain relationships with people whose beliefs you find harmful or wrong
Practice This Today
Practice asking 'What fear or pain might be driving this position?' instead of just 'How can they think this?'
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"He no longer boxed the servants' ears; he no longer thumped the landing so vigorously with his cane"
Context: Describing how M. Gillenormand has changed since Marius left
Physical decline mirrors emotional devastation - his authoritarian nature is breaking down from grief
In Today's Words:
Even the toughest people show their pain through small changes in behavior
"He could not, without a pang, resign himself to the idea that Marius was lost to him forever"
Context: Revealing Gillenormand's inner turmoil about losing his grandson
Pride and love are at war - he won't compromise his beliefs but can't bear losing family
In Today's Words:
Sometimes we'd rather be right than have relationships, but the cost is unbearable
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Generational Conflict
When holding firm to your beliefs becomes more important than maintaining relationships with people you love
Thematic Threads
Social inequality
In This Chapter
Class privilege blinds Gillenormand to changing social realities
Development
His aristocratic worldview prevents understanding of democratic ideals
In Your Life:
When your background makes it hard to empathize with different perspectives
Justice
In This Chapter
Conflict between traditional authority and emerging democratic values
Development
Neither grandfather nor grandson can see the other's version of justice
In Your Life:
Family arguments where everyone thinks they're fighting for what's right
Compassion
In This Chapter
Love exists beneath political disagreement but can't bridge the gap
Development
Emotional connection weakens when ideological differences feel insurmountable
In Your Life:
Loving someone whose values you find morally unacceptable
Modern Adaptation
The Sunday Dinner
Following Jean's story...
Jean visits his former cellmate Tommy's house for dinner, where Tommy's conservative father, a retired police officer, dominates conversation with complaints about criminal justice reform, 'soft' judges, and how 'thugs' get treated too well in prison. The old man genuinely loves Tommy but can't understand why his son defends Jean and other ex-cons. Tommy tries to bridge the gap between his father's law-and-order worldview and his friendship with Jean, but the tension grows unbearable. Jean watches two good people who love each other become enemies over ideology, seeing how the father's pride and fear prevent him from recognizing the humanity in people like Jean.
The Road
Jean's path taught him that people's worst opinions often mask their deepest fears - the father fears losing control in a changing world
The Map
Understanding that behind rigid positions are usually vulnerable hearts helps navigate family conflicts without destroying relationships
Amplification
You can love someone whose beliefs hurt you, but sustainable relationships require some willingness to see the person beyond their positions
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
When is it worth sacrificing relationships to maintain your principles?
analysis • deep - 2
How do you show love to family members whose values you reject?
application • medium - 3
What role does pride play in family conflicts over politics or values?
reflection • surface
Critical Thinking Exercise
The Grandfather's Dilemma
Imagine you're M. Gillenormand's friend. He asks whether he should reach out to Marius despite their political differences. What advice would you give, and what factors would influence your decision?
Consider:
- •The importance of family bonds versus ideological consistency
- •Whether love requires approval of someone's choices
- •How age and generational change affect perspective
- •The role of pride in preventing reconciliation
Journaling Prompt
Describe a time when you had to choose between being right and maintaining a relationship. What did you learn about the costs and benefits of each choice?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 28: The ABC Society - Young Revolutionaries
What lies ahead teaches us idealistic movements begin and attract followers, and shows us the difference between genuine reform and romantic rebellion. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.