Original Text(~250 words)
OF THUMBS Tacitus reports, that amongst certain barbarian kings their manner was, when they would make a firm obligation, to join their right hands close to one another, and intertwist their thumbs; and when, by force of straining the blood, it appeared in the ends, they lightly pricked them with some sharp instrument, and mutually sucked them. Physicians say that the thumbs are the master fingers of the hand, and that their Latin etymology is derived from “pollere.” The Greeks called them ‘Avtixeip’, as who should say, another hand. And it seems that the Latins also sometimes take it in this sense for the whole hand: “Sed nec vocibus excitata blandis, Molli pollici nec rogata, surgit.” [“Neither to be excited by soft words or by the thumb.” --Mart., xii. 98, 8.] It was at Rome a signification of favour to depress and turn in the thumbs: “Fautor utroque tuum laudabit pollice ludum:” [“Thy patron will applaud thy sport with both thumbs” --Horace.] and of disfavour to elevate and thrust them outward: “Converso pollice vulgi, Quemlibet occidunt populariter.” [“The populace, with inverted thumbs, kill all that come before them.”--Juvenal, iii. 36] The Romans exempted from war all such as were maimed in the thumbs, as having no more sufficient strength to hold their weapons. Augustus confiscated the estate of a Roman knight who had maliciously cut off the thumbs of two young children he had, to excuse them from going into the armies; and, before him, the Senate, in the time...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Montaigne explores the surprising significance of thumbs across different cultures and times. He describes how barbarian kings sealed sacred oaths by intertwining thumbs until blood appeared, then pricking and sucking them - making the thumb a symbol of unbreakable trust. In ancient Rome, thumbs held life-or-death power in gladiatorial games, with crowds using thumb gestures to decide fighters' fates. The Romans understood thumbs as so essential to strength and skill that they exempted thumb-injured men from military service. This led to deliberate self-mutilation - wealthy Romans would cut off their sons' thumbs to keep them from war, while others maimed themselves to avoid dangerous expeditions. Victorious generals would cut off enemies' thumbs to permanently disable them from fighting or rowing ships. Even in education, Spartan teachers bit students' thumbs as punishment. Through these examples, Montaigne reveals how something as simple as a thumb becomes a repository of cultural meaning - representing everything from sacred bonds to social control. He shows us that power often operates through the smallest details, and that understanding these symbols helps us decode the hidden rules of any society. The essay demonstrates how physical gestures and body parts carry messages that transcend their biological function, becoming tools of communication, punishment, and social organization.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Blood oath
A sacred promise sealed by mixing blood between parties, considered unbreakable because it creates a physical bond. Ancient cultures believed this made the agreement as permanent as family ties.
Modern Usage:
We still say 'blood brothers' or 'sealed in blood' when describing the strongest possible commitments.
Gladiatorial thumbs
The Roman crowd's thumb gestures that decided whether a defeated gladiator lived or died. Contrary to popular belief, thumbs down likely meant 'spare him' while thumbs up or out meant 'kill him.'
Modern Usage:
We use 'thumbs up/down' for approval or disapproval, though we've reversed the original Roman meanings.
Strategic mutilation
Deliberately injuring oneself or one's children to avoid military service or dangerous duties. Shows how desperate people become when facing systems they can't otherwise escape.
Modern Usage:
Today we see people taking extreme measures to avoid unwanted obligations - from fake medical excuses to deliberate academic failure.
Cultural symbolism
How ordinary body parts or objects carry deep meaning within a society. The same gesture can mean completely different things in different cultures or time periods.
Modern Usage:
Hand gestures, clothing choices, or hairstyles still signal group membership, status, or beliefs in ways we often don't consciously recognize.
Social control through body
How societies use physical markers, modifications, or requirements to enforce rules and hierarchies. Bodies become tools of power and resistance.
Modern Usage:
Dress codes, tattoo policies, drug testing, and appearance standards still control behavior through bodily regulation.
Etymology
The origin and historical development of words. Montaigne traces how 'thumb' comes from Latin 'pollere' meaning 'to be strong,' showing how language preserves ancient understanding.
Modern Usage:
Understanding word origins helps us see hidden connections - like how 'salary' comes from Roman salt payments to soldiers.
Characters in This Chapter
Tacitus
Historical authority
Roman historian whose accounts of barbarian customs provide Montaigne with examples of thumb-based rituals. His observations bridge different cultures and show universal human patterns.
Modern Equivalent:
The documentary filmmaker who shows us how other cultures live
Augustus
Enforcer of social order
Roman emperor who punished a wealthy man for cutting off his sons' thumbs to avoid military service. Represents authority that won't tolerate people gaming the system.
Modern Equivalent:
The strict boss who cracks down on fake sick days
Roman knight
Desperate parent
Wealthy father who mutilated his own children to keep them from war, showing how even privilege can't protect against systemic demands. His punishment reveals the state's priorities.
Modern Equivalent:
The helicopter parent who goes too far trying to protect their kids from consequences
Barbarian kings
Ritual practitioners
Foreign rulers who sealed agreements through thumb-blood ceremonies, demonstrating that sacred bonds transcend cultural boundaries. Their practices seem strange but serve universal needs for trust.
Modern Equivalent:
Business partners who shake hands and look each other in the eye to seal a deal
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when societies embed control mechanisms in seemingly trivial symbols and gestures.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when small symbols carry disproportionate social weight—who gets deference based on clothing, titles, or objects rather than actual competence.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"Physicians say that the thumbs are the master fingers of the hand"
Context: Montaigne explains why thumbs held such significance across cultures
This reveals how ancient people understood anatomy and power - the thumb's unique opposition to other fingers made it essential for gripping and tool use. Physical capability translated directly into social and military value.
In Today's Words:
Doctors knew that thumbs are what make our hands actually useful
"Augustus confiscated the estate of a Roman knight who had maliciously cut off the thumbs of two young children"
Context: Describing punishment for avoiding military service through mutilation
Shows the collision between parental protection and state demands. The word 'maliciously' reveals how the empire viewed this desperate act - not as love but as treachery against civic duty.
In Today's Words:
The emperor seized everything from a rich guy who maimed his kids to keep them out of the army
"It was at Rome a signification of favour to depress and turn in the thumbs"
Context: Explaining how Roman crowds decided gladiators' fates
Demonstrates how physical gestures become loaded with life-and-death meaning. The crowd's thumb position literally determined whether a human being lived or died, showing democracy's darkest potential.
In Today's Words:
Romans pointed their thumbs down to save a gladiator's life
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Symbolic Power
Societies embed their control systems in small physical symbols that carry disproportionate cultural weight and social meaning.
Thematic Threads
Power
In This Chapter
Physical symbols like thumbs become tools for exercising life-and-death authority over others
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might see this in how uniforms, titles, or possessions instantly change how people treat you.
Class
In This Chapter
Wealthy Romans could buy their sons out of military service by cutting off thumbs
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in how money can purchase exemptions from risks that working people must face.
Social Control
In This Chapter
Cultures use physical rituals and punishments to enforce loyalty and obedience
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might notice this in workplace dress codes, social media behaviors, or family traditions that police conformity.
Identity
In This Chapter
Body parts become markers of belonging, capability, and social status within groups
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might see this in how tattoos, scars, or physical appearance signal group membership or personal history.
Human Relationships
In This Chapter
Sacred bonds are created through shared physical rituals that involve pain or blood
Development
Introduced here
In Your Life:
You might recognize this in how shared difficult experiences create deeper connections than easy ones.
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Arthur's story...
Arthur watches his department head play favorites with stunning precision. The chosen few get invited to 'informal coffee meetings' that determine real policy. They receive the subtle nod during faculty meetings that signals whose ideas matter. Meanwhile, Arthur notices how small symbols carry enormous weight—who gets the good parking spot, whose research gets featured in newsletters, who sits where during ceremonies. When budget cuts loom, Arthur sees colleagues desperately performing loyalty through tiny gestures: staying late visibly, laughing at the dean's jokes, wearing school colors to events. He realizes the department operates through an intricate system of symbolic currency that has nothing to do with teaching ability or student outcomes. The professors who master these unspoken rules advance; those who focus purely on education get marginalized. Arthur faces a choice: learn to play the symbolic game or remain forever on the outside, watching others advance through gestural politics rather than genuine merit.
The Road
The road barbarian kings walked when they sealed oaths through thumb-pricking rituals, Arthur walks today in academic politics. The pattern is identical: power operates through symbolic gestures that create invisible hierarchies everyone understands but rarely names.
The Map
This chapter provides a decoder for symbolic power systems. Arthur can identify which gestures, objects, and rituals carry weight in his environment, then decide strategically which symbolic games serve his goals.
Amplification
Before reading this, Arthur might have dismissed office politics as petty drama, focusing only on his teaching while wondering why others advanced faster. Now he can NAME symbolic power systems, PREDICT how they'll operate, and NAVIGATE them consciously—choosing which symbols to adopt and which hierarchies to ignore.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What made thumbs so powerful in ancient cultures that people would cut them off to avoid military service or disable enemies?
analysis • surface - 2
Why do you think societies choose small physical symbols like thumbs or gestures to carry such enormous meaning about life, death, and power?
analysis • medium - 3
What are the modern equivalents of the Roman thumb gesture - small symbols that carry big social messages in your workplace, school, or community?
application • medium - 4
If you wanted to gain respect or authority in a new environment, how would you identify and strategically use the symbolic language that matters there?
application • deep - 5
What does this pattern of symbolic power reveal about how humans organize themselves and why we're willing to follow unspoken rules?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Decode Your Environment's Power Symbols
Choose a place where you spend significant time - work, school, your neighborhood, or a social group. List 5-7 small symbols, gestures, or objects that carry social weight there. For each one, identify what message it sends and who gets to use it. Then consider which symbols you currently use and which ones you might want to adopt or reject.
Consider:
- •Look for symbols that seem trivial but create real social reactions
- •Notice who has access to certain symbols and who doesn't
- •Consider both the benefits and costs of participating in symbolic hierarchies
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you misread or ignored an important social symbol and what happened. How would you handle that situation differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 83: When Fear Makes Us Cruel
What lies ahead teaches us cowardly people often become the most vicious, and shows us fear-based decisions create cycles of escalating violence. These patterns appear in literature and life alike.