Original Text(~250 words)
CHAPTER XIX A Schoolmaster's Difficulties El vulgo es necio y pues lo paga, es justo Hablarle en necio para darle el gusto. [62] LOPE DE VEGA. The mountain-encircled lake slept peacefully with that hypocrisy of the elements which gave no hint of how its waters had the night before responded to the fury of the storm. As the first reflections of light awoke on its surface the phosphorescent spirits, there were outlined in the distance, almost on the horizon, the gray silhouettes of the little bankas of the fishermen who were taking in their nets and of the larger craft spreading their sails. Two men dressed in deep mourning stood gazing at the water from a little elevation: one was Ibarra and the other a youth of humble aspect and melancholy features. "This is the place," the latter was saying. "From here your father's body was thrown into the water. Here's where the grave-digger brought Lieutenant Guevara and me." Ibarra warmly grasped the hand of the young man, who went on: "You have no occasion to thank me. I owed many favors to your father, and the only thing that I could do for him was to accompany his body to the grave. I came here without knowing any one, without recommendation, and having neither name nor fortune, just as at present. My predecessor had abandoned the school to engage in the tobacco trade. Your father protected me, secured me a house, and furnished whatever was necessary for running the...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Standing at the lake where his father's body was thrown, Ibarra meets the local schoolmaster—a young man whose story reveals the brutal reality of trying to create change within a corrupt system. The teacher explains how Ibarra's father once supported education, helping poor children with books and supplies. But when the schoolmaster tries to implement progressive teaching methods—teaching Spanish properly instead of rote memorization, eliminating corporal punishment to create a learning environment based on encouragement rather than fear—he faces crushing opposition from all sides. Padre Damaso publicly humiliates him for speaking Spanish, calling him presumptuous. Parents demand he return to beating their children, believing that's the only way they'll learn. When he briefly succeeds in creating a joyful classroom where children actually want to attend, the system forces him back to the old brutal methods. His story illustrates a devastating truth: individual reformers, no matter how well-intentioned or knowledgeable, cannot overcome entrenched institutional power without support. The schoolmaster's experience foreshadows the challenges Ibarra will face in trying to honor his father's educational legacy. His tale reveals how the colonial system maintains control not just through direct oppression, but by making reform impossible—turning even teachers into instruments of the very ignorance they're supposed to fight. The chapter shows how good people become complicit in bad systems when survival depends on conformity.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Colonial education system
A system designed to keep colonized people barely literate but never truly educated. Students memorized prayers and basic words without understanding, ensuring they stayed dependent on colonial authorities for interpretation and decision-making.
Modern Usage:
We see this in any education system that emphasizes testing and memorization over critical thinking - keeping people trained but not truly educated.
Institutional resistance to reform
When organizations and communities actively fight against positive changes, even when those changes would help them. People resist reform because it threatens existing power structures or challenges familiar ways of doing things.
Modern Usage:
This happens when schools resist new teaching methods, workplaces fight efficiency improvements, or communities oppose beneficial programs because 'that's not how we do things here.'
Systemic complicity
When good people are forced to participate in bad systems to survive. They know what they're doing is wrong, but the system makes it impossible to do right without losing their livelihood or safety.
Modern Usage:
Like healthcare workers who know the system is broken but must follow harmful protocols, or teachers forced to teach to standardized tests instead of actually educating.
Progressive pedagogy
Teaching methods focused on understanding rather than memorization, encouragement rather than punishment, and developing thinking skills rather than blind obedience. Revolutionary in systems designed to maintain ignorance.
Modern Usage:
Modern approaches that emphasize critical thinking, creativity, and student engagement over rote learning and standardized testing.
Social isolation of reformers
How people who try to improve systems often find themselves attacked from all sides - by authorities who see them as threats and by communities who fear change, even positive change.
Modern Usage:
Whistleblowers, activists, and anyone trying to improve corrupt systems often face this - attacked by bosses and sometimes even by the people they're trying to help.
Corporal punishment culture
The belief that learning and discipline can only happen through fear and physical pain. This creates environments where people associate education with suffering rather than growth.
Modern Usage:
Still seen in 'tough love' approaches that prioritize punishment over support, whether in schools, workplaces, or families.
Characters in This Chapter
The schoolmaster
Tragic reformer
A young teacher trying to implement humane, effective education methods who gets crushed by the system. His failure to reform the school despite good intentions and knowledge shows how individual efforts can't overcome institutional corruption without broader support.
Modern Equivalent:
The idealistic new teacher who gets worn down by bureaucracy and hostile parents
Ibarra
Protagonist seeking understanding
Learns about his father's support for education and begins to understand the challenges facing anyone who tries to create positive change. The schoolmaster's story serves as a warning about what Ibarra will face.
Modern Equivalent:
The person returning home to continue a family member's community work
Padre Damaso
Institutional oppressor
Publicly humiliates the schoolmaster for speaking proper Spanish, representing how the colonial system punishes competence that might threaten existing power structures. His actions show how authority figures maintain control through intimidation.
Modern Equivalent:
The boss who punishes employees for showing initiative or knowledge
Ibarra's father
Deceased mentor figure
Though dead, his legacy of supporting education becomes clear. He helped the schoolmaster and provided resources for poor children's education, showing what genuine reform support looks like.
Modern Equivalent:
The community leader who actually put their money where their mouth was
The parents
Unwitting system enforcers
Demand the return of corporal punishment because they believe their children can only learn through beatings. They represent how oppressed people often enforce their own oppression, having internalized harmful beliefs.
Modern Equivalent:
Parents who demand their kids get punitive discipline because 'that's how I learned'
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when an organization will actively resist improvements that threaten existing power structures.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone gets pushback not for being wrong, but for being right in a way that threatens someone else's position or control.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I owed many favors to your father, and the only thing that I could do for him was to accompany his body to the grave."
Context: Explaining to Ibarra why he helped with his father's burial
Shows the schoolmaster's loyalty and gratitude, but also reveals how powerless he was to prevent the injustice done to Ibarra's father. It establishes the father as someone who helped others when he could.
In Today's Words:
Your dad helped me when no one else would, so the least I could do was make sure he got buried with dignity.
"Your father protected me, secured me a house, and furnished whatever was necessary for running the school."
Context: Describing how Ibarra's father supported education
Reveals that real reform requires material support, not just good intentions. Ibarra's father understood that teachers need resources and protection to do their jobs effectively.
In Today's Words:
Your father didn't just talk about supporting education - he actually put up the money and had my back.
"The children were happy and wanted to come to school."
Context: Describing his brief success with progressive teaching methods
Shows that education works best when students are engaged and happy, not terrified. This brief success proves his methods were effective, making the system's forced return to brutality even more tragic.
In Today's Words:
When I stopped beating them and started actually teaching, the kids loved coming to school.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Reformer's Trap - Why Good Intentions Get Crushed
Individual reformers get crushed by systems designed to resist change, regardless of how right they are.
Thematic Threads
Institutional Power
In This Chapter
The education system crushes progressive teaching methods to maintain colonial control
Development
Builds on earlier church corruption themes, showing how institutions protect themselves
In Your Life:
You might see this when trying to improve broken processes at work only to face resistance from management
Individual vs System
In This Chapter
The schoolmaster's lone efforts to reform education are systematically destroyed
Development
Continues Ibarra's struggle, showing how even well-intentioned individuals face systemic opposition
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you try to speak up about problems but find yourself isolated and pressured to conform
Education as Control
In This Chapter
Keeping natives ignorant through brutal teaching methods maintains colonial dominance
Development
Expands on class themes by showing how education is weaponized to preserve hierarchy
In Your Life:
You might see this in how certain groups are kept from accessing quality education or professional development
Complicity Through Survival
In This Chapter
The schoolmaster becomes complicit in the brutality he opposes because he needs to survive
Development
New theme showing how good people become part of bad systems
In Your Life:
You might find yourself staying quiet about workplace problems because you need the job to support your family
Legacy and Memory
In This Chapter
Ibarra learns how his father supported education and faced similar resistance
Development
Continues the theme of honoring deceased parents while understanding their struggles
In Your Life:
You might discover that problems you face at work or in your community are the same ones your parents fought
Modern Adaptation
When Good Ideas Get You Fired
Following Crisostomo's story...
Standing outside the community center where his father once volunteered, Crisostomo meets Marcus, the current youth program coordinator. Marcus tells him how his father had quietly funded supplies and field trips for kids who couldn't afford them. When Marcus first started, he tried implementing trauma-informed approaches—creating safe spaces, teaching conflict resolution instead of punishment, helping kids with homework rather than just warehousing them. The kids responded beautifully; attendance soared, fights dropped. But the board chair accused him of 'coddling criminals.' Parents complained he wasn't being 'tough enough.' When funding got tight, they blamed his 'soft methods.' Now Marcus runs the same punitive programs that drove kids away, knowing they don't work but needing to keep his job. He warns Crisostomo that trying to honor his father's vision of actually helping these kids will face the same crushing opposition from every direction.
The Road
The road the schoolmaster walked in 1887 Philippines, Marcus walks today in modern America. The pattern is identical: reformers with working solutions get crushed by systems that profit from the problems they're trying to solve.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for recognizing when you're fighting the system itself, not just bad individuals. It shows Crisostomo that sustainable change requires building power, not just having good ideas.
Amplification
Before reading this, Crisostomo might have charged ahead with reforms, expecting merit to win. Now they can NAME systemic resistance, PREDICT where opposition will come from, and NAVIGATE by building coalitions first.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What specific changes did the schoolmaster try to implement, and what happened when he did?
analysis • surface - 2
Why did both the priest and the parents oppose the schoolmaster's reforms, even though his methods were clearly working better?
analysis • medium - 3
Where have you seen this same pattern—someone trying to improve a workplace, school, or organization only to face resistance from the very people who should want improvement?
application • medium - 4
If you were the schoolmaster, knowing what you know now about how systems resist change, what would you do differently to protect yourself while still trying to help the children?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about why good people sometimes become part of systems they know are wrong?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map the Power Players
Draw a simple diagram showing the schoolmaster in the center, then map out all the people and forces working against his reforms. For each opponent, write down what they really gain from keeping the old system. Then identify who, if anyone, might have supported him and why they didn't speak up.
Consider:
- •Think about both obvious opponents (like Padre Damaso) and surprising ones (like the parents)
- •Consider what each person fears losing if the system changes
- •Look for potential allies who stayed silent—what might have motivated their silence?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you wanted to improve something at work, school, or in your community but faced unexpected resistance. What were people really protecting, and what would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 20: The Town Hall Trap
In the next chapter, you'll discover strategic thinking can turn political disadvantages into victories, and learn understanding your opponents' motivations matters more than being right. These insights reveal timeless patterns that resonate in our own lives and relationships.