Original Text(~250 words)
Il Buon Dí Si Conosce Da Mattina [137] Early the next morning the report spread through the town that many lights had been seen in the cemetery on the previous night. The leader of the Venerable Tertiary Order spoke of lighted candles, of their shape and size, and, although he could not fix the exact number, had counted more than twenty. Sister Sipa, of the Brotherhood of the Holy Rosary, could not bear the thought that a member of a rival order should alone boast of having seen this divine marvel, so she, even though she did not live near the place, had heard cries and groans, and even thought she recognized by their voices certain persons with whom she, in other times,--but out of Christian charity she not only forgave them but prayed for them and would keep their names secret, for all of which she was declared on the spot to be a saint. Sister Rufa was not so keen of hearing, but she could not suffer that Sister Sipa had heard so much and she nothing, so she related a dream in which there had appeared before her many souls--not only of the dead but even of the living--souls in torment who begged for a part of those indulgences of hers which were so carefully recorded and treasured. She could furnish names to the families interested and only asked for a few alms to succor the Pope in his needs. A little fellow, a herder, who dared...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
The morning after the cemetery incident, the townspeople spin wild tales about supernatural lights and ghostly voices, desperately avoiding the simple truth that something real happened there. Religious leaders use the hysteria to collect money for masses, while anyone who speaks plainly—like a young herder who saw only two men with lanterns—gets shouted down as a heretic. Meanwhile, the dying philosopher Tasio has a crucial conversation with Don Filipo about resignation and resistance. Tasio argues that Don Filipo made a mistake stepping down from his position just when the town needed real leadership against corruption. The old man delivers a passionate speech about how the Philippines is finally awakening from centuries of medieval thinking—young people are studying real subjects like science and history instead of useless religious philosophy, new ideas are flowing in from Europe, and even the Catholic orders are being forced to adapt. But Tasio also sees the darker reality: most people still choose comfort over truth, men care more about seducing women than serving their country, and families neglect their own needs to serve the church. As fever takes hold, he swings between hope for the future and despair at the present. He asks Don Filipo to send Crisostomo to see him tomorrow—he has important things to say before he dies. The chapter captures the tension between an old world desperately clinging to power and a new generation slowly awakening to possibilities their parents never imagined.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Venerable Tertiary Order
A Catholic lay organization where regular people (not priests or nuns) join religious groups for status and influence. Members compete to show off their piety and gain social standing in the community.
Modern Usage:
Like people who join exclusive clubs or post constantly about charity work on social media to boost their reputation.
Indulgences
In Catholic teaching, these were supposed to reduce time souls spent in purgatory after death. The Church sold them for money, creating a corrupt system where the wealthy could literally buy their way to heaven.
Modern Usage:
Similar to how wealthy people today can buy their way out of consequences through expensive lawyers or donations to the right causes.
Mass hysteria
When groups of people convince themselves they've witnessed something supernatural or extraordinary, usually when they're anxious about real problems they can't face. The stories get wilder as more people join in.
Modern Usage:
Like how conspiracy theories spread on social media when people feel powerless about real issues they can't control.
Medieval thinking
Tasio's term for outdated ways of understanding the world through superstition and blind obedience to authority, rather than science, reason, and individual thought.
Modern Usage:
When people reject facts and expertise in favor of what feels comfortable or what authority figures tell them to believe.
Resignation vs. resistance
The central debate between Tasio and Don Filipo about whether good people should withdraw from corrupt systems or stay and fight to change them from within.
Modern Usage:
The same dilemma people face today when deciding whether to quit a toxic workplace or stay and try to make it better.
Cultural awakening
Tasio describes how young Filipinos are starting to study real subjects like science and history instead of just religious philosophy, opening their minds to new possibilities.
Modern Usage:
Like when people from traditional backgrounds get exposed to higher education or travel and start questioning how they were raised.
Characters in This Chapter
Sister Sipa
Religious gossip spreader
She can't stand that someone from a rival religious order saw the 'miracle' first, so she invents her own supernatural experience with voices and groans. She uses the hysteria to position herself as more holy than others.
Modern Equivalent:
The coworker who always has to one-up everyone else's stories and turns every situation into drama about herself
Sister Rufa
Competitive religious performer
Not to be outdone by Sister Sipa, she claims she had a prophetic dream about souls in torment and uses it as an opportunity to collect money for 'the Pope's needs' while keeping detailed records of her good deeds.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who posts every charitable act on social media and always has a GoFundMe running for some cause
The little herder
Truth-teller
This young boy simply reports what he actually saw - two men with lanterns in the cemetery. But the adults shout him down as a heretic because his plain truth threatens their profitable supernatural narrative.
Modern Equivalent:
The kid who points out that the emperor has no clothes while all the adults pretend everything is fine
Tasio
Dying philosopher mentor
Though fevering and near death, he delivers passionate speeches about the Philippines awakening from medieval thinking. He sees both hope in the young generation studying real subjects and despair at how most people still choose comfort over truth.
Modern Equivalent:
The wise elder who sees the big picture but is frustrated watching people waste their potential
Don Filipo
Conflicted former leader
He resigned from his leadership position rather than fight the corruption, but Tasio argues he made a mistake - that good people withdrawing from the system only makes things worse.
Modern Equivalent:
The good manager who quits instead of fighting the toxic corporate culture, leaving things worse for everyone else
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to spot when groups create comfortable lies to avoid facing uncomfortable truths.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when explanations feel too convenient or when someone speaking plainly gets attacked rather than heard—that's collective denial protecting itself.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"She could furnish names to the families interested and only asked for a few alms to succor the Pope in his needs."
Context: Sister Rufa is turning her 'prophetic dream' into a money-making scheme
This shows how religious leaders exploit people's fears about their dead loved ones to collect money. She's essentially running a spiritual protection racket, claiming she can help souls in purgatory for the right price.
In Today's Words:
She had a convenient dream that just happened to require donations to fix the problem.
"The country is awakening from its medieval lethargy."
Context: He's explaining to Don Filipo why this is a crucial moment in Philippine history
Tasio sees that young Filipinos are finally getting real education and exposure to modern ideas from Europe. He believes they're breaking free from centuries of intellectual oppression by the colonial system.
In Today's Words:
People are finally starting to think for themselves instead of just accepting what they've always been told.
"You have done ill in giving up your place to your opponents."
Context: Tasio is criticizing Don Filipo for resigning from his leadership position
This is the heart of their debate about resignation versus resistance. Tasio argues that when good people withdraw from corrupt systems, they abandon the field to bad actors and make things worse for everyone.
In Today's Words:
You messed up by quitting and letting the bad guys win by default.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Comfortable Lies
Groups collectively choose elaborate fiction over simple truth when reality threatens their comfort or existing power structures.
Thematic Threads
Truth vs. Comfort
In This Chapter
Townspeople create supernatural explanations for cemetery events instead of facing reality; truth-tellers get silenced
Development
Builds on earlier themes of willful blindness, now showing how entire communities participate in denial
In Your Life:
You might find yourself going along with office gossip instead of addressing the real workplace problem everyone's avoiding.
Generational Change
In This Chapter
Tasio sees young people studying science instead of empty philosophy, new ideas flowing from Europe
Development
First major articulation of the awakening theme that's been building throughout the novel
In Your Life:
You might recognize this tension when your kids embrace technology or ideas that challenge your traditional beliefs.
Leadership and Resignation
In This Chapter
Tasio criticizes Don Filipo for stepping down just when the town needed honest leadership most
Development
Continues the theme of good people withdrawing instead of fighting corruption
In Your Life:
You might feel tempted to quit a volunteer position or workplace role when things get difficult, but that's exactly when your integrity is most needed.
Hope vs. Despair
In This Chapter
Dying Tasio swings between excitement about the Philippines' awakening and despair at people's continued passivity
Development
New theme showing the emotional cost of seeing clearly in a world that prefers blindness
In Your Life:
You might feel this same exhausting cycle when you see potential for positive change but watch people choose familiar dysfunction instead.
Exploitation of Fear
In This Chapter
Religious leaders use supernatural hysteria to collect money for masses and maintain control
Development
Continues the theme of institutional manipulation, now showing how fear becomes profit
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when politicians, salespeople, or even family members use your anxieties to get what they want from you.
Modern Adaptation
When Everyone Agrees to Look Away
Following Crisostomo's story...
After Crisostomo's community organizing meeting exposed safety violations at the local factory, wild stories spread through the neighborhood. People claim mysterious 'outside agitators' caused the disruption, that union organizers are secretly funded by foreign enemies, that speaking up will bring government retaliation. The pastor collects donations for 'protection prayers' while the factory owner's allies spread conspiracy theories. When Maria, a single mom who works the line, tries to tell people she simply saw Crisostomo showing photos of blocked fire exits, neighbors shout her down as a troublemaker. Meanwhile, old Mr. Santos, the retired teacher who's been mentoring Crisostomo, lies dying of the lung disease half the factory workers develop. He tells Crisostomo that stepping back from organizing was a mistake—the community needs real leadership now more than ever. Santos sees hope in the young people finally questioning why they accept dangerous conditions their parents endured, but despairs that most still choose comfortable lies over uncomfortable action.
The Road
The road Rizal's townspeople walked in 1887, Crisostomo walks today. The pattern is identical: when reality threatens comfort, communities collectively choose elaborate fiction over simple truth, attacking anyone who speaks plainly.
The Map
This chapter provides a map for recognizing collective denial in action. Crisostomo can identify when groups create comfortable lies to avoid facing difficult truths, and choose whether to join the fiction or stand with reality.
Amplification
Before reading this, Crisostomo might have been confused why his neighbors turned against obvious facts. Now they can NAME collective denial, PREDICT how truth-tellers get attacked, and NAVIGATE by expecting resistance while staying committed to reality.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Why do the townspeople create supernatural explanations for what they witnessed at the cemetery instead of accepting the simple truth?
analysis • surface - 2
How do the religious leaders profit from the townspeople's fear and confusion about the cemetery incident?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern of choosing comfortable lies over uncomfortable truths in your workplace, family, or community?
application • medium - 4
When you encounter a situation where everyone is avoiding an obvious truth, how do you decide whether to speak up or stay silent?
application • deep - 5
What does Tasio's observation about people choosing comfort over truth reveal about why real change is so difficult?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Truth-Teller or Crowd-Follower: Map Your Response
Think of a recent situation where a group you were part of avoided facing an uncomfortable reality. Write down what actually happened versus what people said happened. Then identify who played each role: the truth-tellers who got shut down, the lie-creators who offered easier explanations, and the crowd who went along with the comfortable version.
Consider:
- •Notice how quickly groups can silence uncomfortable truth-tellers
- •Identify what the group gained by avoiding reality and what they lost
- •Consider what would have happened if more people had supported the truth-teller
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you chose to tell an uncomfortable truth despite group pressure. What happened? How did it feel? What would you do differently now?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 54: When Secrets Destroy Everything
Moving forward, we'll examine manipulation exploits religious authority and social divisions, and understand family history can become a weapon against you. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.