Original Text(~250 words)
Maggie Tries to Run away from Her Shadow Maggie’s intentions, as usual, were on a larger scale than Tom imagined. The resolution that gathered in her mind, after Tom and Lucy had walked away, was not so simple as that of going home. No! she would run away and go to the gypsies, and Tom should never see her any more. That was by no means a new idea to Maggie; she had been so often told she was like a gypsy, and “half wild,” that when she was miserable it seemed to her the only way of escaping opprobrium, and being entirely in harmony with circumstances, would be to live in a little brown tent on the commons; the gypsies, she considered, would gladly receive her and pay her much respect on account of her superior knowledge. She had once mentioned her views on this point to Tom and suggested that he should stain his face brown, and they should run away together; but Tom rejected the scheme with contempt, observing that gypsies were thieves, and hardly got anything to eat and had nothing to drive but a donkey. To-day however, Maggie thought her misery had reached a pitch at which gypsydom was her refuge, and she rose from her seat on the roots of the tree with the sense that this was a great crisis in her life; she would run straight away till she came to Dunlow Common, where there would certainly be gypsies; and cruel Tom,...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Nine-year-old Maggie, hurt by Tom's cruelty, decides to run away and join the gypsies—a fantasy she's nurtured whenever adults called her 'wild' or 'half-gypsy.' She imagines they'll welcome her superior knowledge and treat her like royalty. Reality hits hard when she actually finds a gypsy camp. The people are poor, dirty, and suspicious. They don't share her enthusiasm for geography lessons or Columbus stories. When she asks for bread and butter instead of their meager food, they grow irritated. Worse, they steal her thimble, making her realize they might actually be thieves. Her romantic vision of gypsy life—tents on commons, adventure, respect for her intelligence—crumbles into fear that they might harm her. The 'rescue' comes when a gypsy man offers to take her home on a donkey, but the terrifying ride makes her think she's being kidnapped. Just when despair peaks, her father appears on the road. The reunion is tearful and joyful. Mr. Tulliver pays the gypsy generously and takes Maggie home, where—surprisingly—no one scolds her for this escapade. This chapter reveals how Maggie's active imagination both empowers and endangers her. Her fantasy of joining the gypsies reflects a child's desire to escape judgment and find acceptance, but also shows her class privilege—she expects the poor to serve her needs. The experience teaches her that running away doesn't solve emotional problems, and that her romanticized view of 'otherness' was naive. Most importantly, it demonstrates her father's deep love and the security of home, even when that home contains conflict.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Gypsies/Romani people
Traveling communities in 19th century England who lived in caravans and worked as tinkers, horse traders, or entertainers. They faced severe prejudice and were often blamed for theft or seen as exotic 'others.' Eliot uses them to show how Maggie romanticizes what she doesn't understand.
Modern Usage:
We still see this pattern when people romanticize cultures they don't know, like thinking all small towns are wholesome or all city life is glamorous.
Commons
Public lands where poor people could graze animals, gather fuel, or camp temporarily. These spaces represented freedom from property ownership but also poverty and marginality. For Maggie, they symbolize escape from social expectations.
Modern Usage:
Like public parks or campgrounds today - spaces that feel free from normal rules, where people go to 'find themselves' or escape.
Class privilege
Maggie's assumption that poor gypsies will serve her shows how wealth creates blind spots. She expects them to appreciate her 'superior knowledge' and provide comfort food, not understanding their actual struggles.
Modern Usage:
When people assume service workers should be grateful for any job, or expect others to be impressed by their college education.
Romanticizing otherness
Maggie imagines gypsy life as adventurous and respectful of her talents, but reality is harsh poverty. This shows how we idealize what we don't actually know, especially when we're unhappy with our own situation.
Modern Usage:
Like thinking 'simple living' looks like Instagram homesteading, or that other people's jobs are more fulfilling than yours.
Escapist fantasy
Maggie's plan to join the gypsies represents the child's belief that running away will solve emotional problems. She thinks changing location will change how she feels about herself and her relationships.
Modern Usage:
The 'geographic cure' - thinking a new city, job, or relationship will fix internal problems that follow you everywhere.
Social outcasts
People pushed to society's margins, like the gypsies in this chapter. Maggie identifies with them because she feels rejected by her family, but doesn't understand what real marginalization costs.
Modern Usage:
Anyone society labels as 'different' - from homeless people to teenagers with purple hair - often gets romanticized by those who feel like misfits.
Characters in This Chapter
Maggie Tulliver
Protagonist
A nine-year-old who runs away to join gypsies after Tom hurts her feelings. Her adventure reveals both her vivid imagination and her class privilege - she expects poor people to serve her needs and appreciate her intelligence.
Modern Equivalent:
The kid who threatens to run away when grounded, convinced strangers will appreciate them more than family does
Tom Tulliver
Antagonist (absent but motivating)
Though not physically present, Tom's earlier cruelty drives Maggie's escape attempt. His rejection of her gypsy fantasy as impractical proves correct, showing his more realistic but less imaginative nature.
Modern Equivalent:
The practical sibling who shoots down dreams but is usually right about consequences
The gypsy woman
Reality check
Represents the harsh truth behind Maggie's romantic fantasy. She's poor, suspicious, and unimpressed by Maggie's 'superior knowledge.' Her theft of the thimble confirms Tom's warnings about gypsy dishonesty.
Modern Equivalent:
The person whose real life doesn't match your fantasy about their lifestyle
The gypsy man
Unwitting rescuer
Offers to take Maggie home but terrifies her with his rough manner and the wild donkey ride. His good intentions feel threatening to sheltered Maggie, showing how fear distorts perception.
Modern Equivalent:
The helpful stranger whose different communication style makes you wonder if they're actually dangerous
Mr. Tulliver
Loving father
Appears when Maggie most needs rescue, pays the gypsy generously, and welcomes her home without scolding. His relief and love show Maggie she's valued despite her mistakes.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent who drops everything to come get you when your big adventure goes wrong
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how we project our unmet needs onto unfamiliar situations, assuming they'll provide what our current environment lacks.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when you catch yourself thinking 'if only I worked somewhere else' or 'if only I lived somewhere different'—pause and ask what specific need you're trying to meet.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"She had been so often told she was like a gypsy, and 'half wild,' that when she was miserable it seemed to her the only way of escaping opprobrium would be to live in a little brown tent on the commons."
Context: Explaining why Maggie decides to join the gypsies
This shows how negative labels become self-fulfilling prophecies. Adults calling Maggie 'wild' makes her think she belongs with outcasts. It reveals how children internalize criticism and use it to make sense of their identity.
In Today's Words:
Everyone always said she was weird anyway, so she figured she might as well go be weird with people who wouldn't judge her for it.
"The gypsies, she considered, would gladly receive her and pay her much respect on account of her superior knowledge."
Context: Describing Maggie's expectations about gypsy life
This reveals Maggie's class privilege and naive assumptions. She expects poor, marginalized people to be grateful for her presence and impressed by her education - showing how privilege creates blind spots about others' realities.
In Today's Words:
She was sure they'd be thrilled to have someone as smart as her around and would probably make her their leader.
"It was plain she had made a great mistake about the gypsies - they had not the tenderness for her that she had expected."
Context: When Maggie realizes the gypsies aren't welcoming her as she hoped
This moment marks Maggie's collision with reality. Her romanticized fantasy crumbles when she meets actual poverty and suspicion. It's a painful but necessary lesson about the difference between imagination and truth.
In Today's Words:
Turns out these people had their own problems and weren't interested in taking care of some random kid who showed up.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Romantic Escape
The tendency to romanticize unfamiliar situations as solutions to current emotional needs, projecting our desires onto unknown people or places.
Thematic Threads
Class
In This Chapter
Maggie expects gypsies to serve her needs and admire her education, revealing her unconscious class privilege even while feeling like an outsider in her own family
Development
Building on earlier hints of the Tulliver family's social position and Maggie's education
In Your Life:
You might catch yourself expecting service workers to accommodate your needs without considering their constraints or perspectives
Identity
In This Chapter
Maggie seeks belonging with people she's been compared to ('half-gypsy') when her own family makes her feel different and unwanted
Development
Deepening from her earlier struggles with not fitting feminine expectations
In Your Life:
You might find yourself drawn to groups or communities where you hope your differences will finally be seen as strengths
Fantasy
In This Chapter
Maggie's elaborate imagination creates detailed scenarios of gypsy life that bear no resemblance to reality, leading to dangerous disappointment
Development
Introduced here as a coping mechanism for emotional pain
In Your Life:
You might construct detailed mental scenarios about how different your life would be 'if only' you made a dramatic change
Family
In This Chapter
Despite conflict at home, Maggie's father's rescue and the family's lack of punishment reveal the underlying security and love she almost threw away
Development
Contrasting with earlier tensions, showing family complexity
In Your Life:
You might take for granted the people who would drop everything to find you when you're lost, focusing instead on daily frustrations
Growth
In This Chapter
Maggie learns that running away doesn't solve emotional problems and that her romanticized views of 'otherness' were naive and potentially harmful
Development
First major lesson in the gap between imagination and reality
In Your Life:
You might discover that the problems you're running from often follow you to new situations until you address them directly
Modern Adaptation
When the Dream Job Turns Into a Nightmare
Following Maggie's story...
After another brutal parent-teacher conference where she was criticized for being 'too intense' and 'unconventional,' Maggie impulsively applies for a teaching position at a progressive private school in the city. She fantasizes about colleagues who'll appreciate her creativity, parents who value deep thinking, and students hungry for real learning. When she gets an interview, she's convinced this is her escape from small-town mediocrity. But the reality hits hard during the school visit. The 'progressive' environment is performative—teachers stressed about test scores despite the rhetoric. Parents are more demanding than supportive. The pay is actually lower than her current job, and she'd need expensive housing in the city. Worse, she realizes they see her as a novelty hire—the 'authentic' teacher from a working-class background to add diversity to their marketing. When the principal casually mentions she'd need to tone down her 'intensity' for their parent community, Maggie feels the familiar sting of not belonging anywhere.
The Road
The road nine-year-old Maggie walked toward the gypsy camp in 1860, twenty-five-year-old Maggie walks today toward her fantasy job. The pattern is identical: romanticizing escape to places where we imagine our differences will finally be celebrated.
The Map
This chapter provides a navigation tool for recognizing romantic escape patterns. When feeling undervalued, Maggie can ask: What specific need am I trying to meet, and can any part of it be addressed where I am now?
Amplification
Before reading this, Maggie might have kept chasing fantasy solutions whenever she felt misunderstood. Now she can NAME romantic escape, PREDICT it leads to disappointment, and NAVIGATE it by addressing root needs rather than projecting them onto unknown situations.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What made Maggie think the gypsies would welcome her, and what actually happened when she found them?
analysis • surface - 2
Why did Maggie's fantasy about gypsy life fall apart so quickly? What assumptions was she making?
analysis • medium - 3
When have you seen someone romanticize a job, relationship, or place as the solution to their problems? How did it turn out?
application • medium - 4
If you were Maggie's parent, how would you help her process this experience without crushing her imagination?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how we cope with feeling misunderstood or unappreciated?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Reality-Check Your Escape Fantasy
Think of a time you fantasized about escaping your current situation - maybe quitting your job, moving somewhere new, or ending a relationship. Write down what you imagined would be different 'over there.' Then honestly list what problems would likely follow you and what new challenges might arise.
Consider:
- •What specific needs were you hoping the new situation would meet?
- •How much did you actually know about the reality of that 'escape'?
- •Which of your current problems stem from external circumstances versus internal patterns?
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you discovered that a situation you'd romanticized was very different from your fantasy. What did you learn about the difference between running away from problems versus working through them?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 12: The Gleggs at Home
The coming pages reveal couples can fight about everything except what's really bothering them, and teach us some people need conflict to feel connected in relationships. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.