Original Text(~250 words)
CHAPTER II. OF THE SOURCES OF THE GENERAL OR PUBLIC REVENUE OF THE SOCIETY. The revenue which must defray, not only the expense of defending the society and of supporting the dignity of the chief magistrate, but all the other necessary expenses of government, for which the constitution of the state has not provided any particular revenue may be drawn, either, first, from some fund which peculiarly belongs to the sovereign or commonwealth, and which is independent of the revenue of the people; or, secondly, from the revenue of the people. PART I. Of the Funds, or Sources, of Revenue, which may peculiarly belong to the Sovereign or Commonwealth. The funds, or sources, of revenue, which may peculiarly belong to the sovereign or commonwealth, must consist, either in stock, or in land. The sovereign, like, any other owner of stock, may derive a revenue from it, either by employing it himself, or by lending it. His revenue is, in the one case, profit, in the other interest. The revenue of a Tartar or Arabian chief consists in profit. It arises principally from the milk and increase of his own herds and flocks, of which he himself superintends the management, and is the principal shepherd or herdsman of his own horde or tribe. It is, however, in this earliest and rudest state of civil government only, that profit has ever made the principal part of the public revenue of a monarchical state. Small republics have sometimes derived a considerable revenue from...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Smith breaks down the fundamental question every government faces: how to pay for itself. He explores two main options - governments owning profitable businesses or taxing citizens - and explains why the first rarely works. When governments try to run businesses, they typically fail because their agents spend carelessly, knowing the money isn't really theirs. Even successful examples like the post office work only because they're simple operations with immediate returns. The bulk of the chapter examines taxation, which Smith organizes around four key principles: taxes should be proportional to people's ability to pay, certain rather than arbitrary, convenient for the taxpayer, and efficient to collect. He analyzes different types of taxes - on land, profits, wages, and consumption - showing how each affects the economy differently. Luxury taxes generally work well because people can choose whether to buy taxed goods, but taxes on necessities often backfire by forcing up wages and hurting the poor most. Smith reveals how tax systems become incredibly complex, using France as an example where different provinces have completely different tax rules, creating massive inefficiency. He argues that simpler, more uniform tax systems like Britain's work better than complicated patchworks. Throughout, Smith emphasizes that good tax policy requires understanding how taxes flow through the economy - a tax on one group often ends up being paid by another entirely. His analysis shows that the design of tax systems shapes not just government revenue, but the entire economic structure of society.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Public Revenue
The money a government needs to operate - paying for defense, courts, infrastructure, and officials' salaries. Smith breaks this into two sources: government-owned businesses or taxes on citizens.
Modern Usage:
Today we call this the government budget, funded mostly through income taxes, sales taxes, and borrowing.
Sovereign Stock
When governments try to make money by owning and running businesses, like a king owning farms or factories. Smith argues this rarely works because government employees don't manage money as carefully as private owners.
Modern Usage:
Modern examples include government-owned utilities or when cities run parking meters - often inefficient compared to private companies.
Tax Incidence
Who actually ends up paying a tax, which isn't always who the law says should pay. A tax on employers might get passed to workers through lower wages, or to customers through higher prices.
Modern Usage:
When cities tax businesses heavily, those businesses often move to suburbs, leaving residents with fewer jobs and services.
Proportional Taxation
Smith's first principle of fair taxation - people should pay based on their ability to pay. The wealthy should contribute more because they benefit more from society's protection of property and order.
Modern Usage:
This is the theory behind progressive income tax brackets where higher earners pay higher percentages.
Tax Certainty
People should know exactly what they owe, when it's due, and how it's calculated. Arbitrary or unpredictable taxes create fear and corruption as officials can demand whatever they want.
Modern Usage:
This is why we have standardized tax forms and published rates rather than letting IRS agents make up what you owe.
Tax Convenience
Taxes should be collected at times and in ways that are easiest for taxpayers. Don't demand payment when people are broke or make them travel far to pay.
Modern Usage:
Modern examples include payroll deduction, online payment systems, and quarterly deadlines that align with business cycles.
Administrative Efficiency
The cost of collecting taxes shouldn't eat up most of the revenue. Complex tax systems require armies of collectors and create opportunities for corruption and evasion.
Modern Usage:
This is why simple flat taxes appeal to some people, even though they may be less fair than complex progressive systems.
Characters in This Chapter
Tartar Chief
example ruler
Smith uses him to show the simplest form of government revenue - a tribal leader who makes money directly from his own herds and flocks. This works only in very basic societies where the ruler can personally oversee everything.
Modern Equivalent:
The small business owner who does everything themselves
Arabian Chief
example ruler
Another example of primitive government finance where the leader's personal wealth IS the government treasury. Smith shows this model breaks down as societies become more complex.
Modern Equivalent:
The family patriarch who controls all the money
Government Agents
cautionary examples
Smith argues these employees of government-run businesses are careless with money because it's not theirs. They lack the motivation of private owners who lose their own money if they fail.
Modern Equivalent:
The government worker who doesn't care about waste because it's taxpayer money, not theirs
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to follow the money trail when someone promises something for 'free' or claims costs will be absorbed elsewhere.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when businesses, landlords, or employers announce changes that supposedly won't cost you anything, then look for where those costs actually show up in your life.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"The agents of a state may, no doubt, with propriety, be considered as the servants of the people, and the people may, no doubt, change them as often as they please."
Context: Discussing why government-run businesses usually fail
Smith points out the fundamental problem with government enterprises - the managers aren't really accountable to anyone specific. Unlike private business owners who lose their own money if they fail, government agents spend other people's money with little personal consequence.
In Today's Words:
Government employees are supposed to work for us, but since we can't really fire them individually, they don't have much reason to care about waste.
"The subjects of every state ought to contribute towards the support of the government, as nearly as possible, in proportion to their respective abilities."
Context: Establishing his first principle of taxation
This is Smith's foundational argument for progressive taxation - those who can afford more should pay more. He bases this not on charity but on fairness, since the wealthy benefit most from society's protection of property and commerce.
In Today's Words:
People should pay taxes based on what they can actually afford, not the same flat amount for everyone.
"Every tax ought to be levied at the time, or in the manner, in which it is most likely to be convenient for the contributor to pay it."
Context: Explaining his principle of tax convenience
Smith understands that timing matters enormously in tax collection. Demanding payment when people are broke leads to hardship and evasion. Good tax policy considers people's cash flow and life circumstances.
In Today's Words:
Don't ask people to pay taxes when they're already struggling to make ends meet.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Road of Invisible Burden - How Costs Always Find Someone to Carry Them
Costs never disappear from a system, they only move to whoever has the least power to refuse them.
Thematic Threads
Hidden Power
In This Chapter
Smith reveals how tax systems mask who really controls economic decisions—the wealthy shape tax policy while appearing to pay their share
Development
Builds on earlier themes of invisible hand by showing how power operates through indirect mechanisms
In Your Life:
You might see this when your 'employee benefits' disappear but executives get bonuses, or when community services get cut while development incentives increase
System Gaming
In This Chapter
Different provinces in France have completely different tax rules, creating opportunities for those who understand the system to avoid costs
Development
Extends Smith's analysis of how complexity benefits insiders at everyone else's expense
In Your Life:
You encounter this when navigating healthcare networks, tax codes, or workplace policies where knowing the right loopholes makes all the difference
Unintended Consequences
In This Chapter
Taxes meant to help the poor often hurt them most, while luxury taxes work because they preserve choice
Development
Reinforces Smith's theme that good intentions don't guarantee good outcomes without understanding mechanisms
In Your Life:
You see this when well-meaning policies at work create more problems, or when trying to help family members backfires
Simplicity vs Complexity
In This Chapter
Britain's simpler tax system works better than France's complicated patchwork of different rules
Development
Continues Smith's preference for systems that work with human nature rather than against it
In Your Life:
You experience this when choosing between simple, transparent deals versus complex ones with hidden terms and conditions
Modern Adaptation
When the Promotion Goes Sideways
Following Adam's story...
Adam watches their retail chain announce 'exciting changes' after a corporate buyout. Management promises better benefits and higher wages, funded by 'efficiency improvements.' But Adam notices the pattern: when the company claims it will absorb costs, those costs always land somewhere else. The new health plan has higher deductibles. The wage increase comes with mandatory overtime that pushes workers into higher tax brackets. Store hours extend but staffing stays the same. The 'free' employee discounts require spending minimums that force workers to shop company stores at inflated prices. Meanwhile, customer prices rise across the board. Adam realizes they're watching a shell game where every announced benefit creates two hidden costs that employees and customers will ultimately pay.
The Road
The road Adam Smith's taxpayers walked in 1776, Adam walks today. The pattern is identical: those with power shift costs to those without, and the person who ultimately pays is rarely the person targeted to pay.
The Map
Smith's framework reveals that costs never disappear, they only move. Adam can trace any 'benefit' to find where its real costs land.
Amplification
Before reading this, Adam might have believed promises about 'company-funded' improvements. Now they can NAME cost-shifting, PREDICT where hidden expenses will surface, and NAVIGATE by asking 'who really pays?' before celebrating any workplace announcement.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
Smith shows that when governments try to run businesses, they usually fail because their agents spend carelessly with other people's money. What examples of this pattern do you see in your workplace or community?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Smith argue that a tax on your landlord's property often becomes a cost you pay through higher rent? What does this reveal about how power works in economic relationships?
analysis • medium - 3
Smith explains that costs never disappear, they just move to someone else. Where do you see this cost-shifting pattern in your daily life - from healthcare to housing to work?
application • medium - 4
If you were designing a fair tax system for your community, how would you apply Smith's four principles: ability to pay, certainty, convenience, and efficiency? What trade-offs would you face?
application • deep - 5
Smith reveals that the person who ultimately pays a cost is rarely the person the policy was designed to target. What does this teach us about the gap between good intentions and real outcomes?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Follow the Money Trail
Choose one recent price increase you've experienced - rent, groceries, gas, or a service. Trace backward through the chain: what costs might have been passed down to you? Who had the power to shift costs, and who was forced to absorb them? Map out the full cost-shifting chain from original source to final payer.
Consider:
- •Look for hidden middlemen who might have passed costs along
- •Consider who in the chain had bargaining power versus who was stuck
- •Think about whether the original reason for the cost increase matches where you ended up paying
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when you were promised something would be 'free' or paid for by 'someone else.' Looking back, can you identify who actually bore the cost and how it eventually affected you?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 32: The Debt Trap Nations Fall Into
The coming pages reveal government spending habits change when borrowing becomes easy, and teach us debt spirals are harder to escape than they appear. These discoveries help us navigate similar situations in our own lives.