Original Text(~250 words)
If that staid old house near the Green at Richmond should ever come to be haunted when I am dead, it will be haunted, surely, by my ghost. O the many, many nights and days through which the unquiet spirit within me haunted that house when Estella lived there! Let my body be where it would, my spirit was always wandering, wandering, wandering, about that house. The lady with whom Estella was placed, Mrs. Brandley by name, was a widow, with one daughter several years older than Estella. The mother looked young, and the daughter looked old; the mother’s complexion was pink, and the daughter’s was yellow; the mother set up for frivolity, and the daughter for theology. They were in what is called a good position, and visited, and were visited by, numbers of people. Little, if any, community of feeling subsisted between them and Estella, but the understanding was established that they were necessary to her, and that she was necessary to them. Mrs. Brandley had been a friend of Miss Havisham’s before the time of her seclusion. In Mrs. Brandley’s house and out of Mrs. Brandley’s house, I suffered every kind and degree of torture that Estella could cause me. The nature of my relations with her, which placed me on terms of familiarity without placing me on terms of favour, conduced to my distraction. She made use of me to tease other admirers, and she turned the very familiarity between herself and me to the account...
Continue reading the full chapter
Purchase the complete book to access all chapters and support classic literature
As an Amazon Associate, we earn a small commission from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.
Available in paperback, hardcover, and e-book formats
Summary
Pip continues his torturous relationship with Estella, spending countless hours in her company while experiencing nothing but misery. During a visit to Satis House, a dramatic confrontation erupts between Estella and Miss Havisham. Estella coldly tells her adoptive mother that she cannot give love because she was never taught to feel it - she is exactly what Miss Havisham made her to be. Miss Havisham, desperate for the affection she trained Estella never to give, realizes the horrific irony of her revenge plot. Pip finally understands that Estella was deliberately shaped as an instrument of vengeance against men, making his love for her part of Miss Havisham's cruel design. Meanwhile, the despicable Bentley Drummle begins pursuing Estella, and despite Pip's protests, she encourages his attention. When Pip confronts her about this, Estella reveals she deceives and entraps all her suitors - except Pip. The chapter ends with an ominous metaphor about a sultan's palace ceiling rigged to fall, suggesting Pip's world is about to collapse. This chapter exposes the devastating consequences of using people as weapons and shows how cycles of hurt create more victims than victors.
That's what happens. To understand what the author is really doing—and to discuss this chapter with confidence—keep reading.
Terms to Know
Good position
In Victorian society, this meant having enough money and social connections to be respectable. The Brandleys weren't wealthy, but they had the right address and knew the right people. It was about maintaining appearances and social standing.
Modern Usage:
Like families today who stretch their budget to live in the 'good school district' or drive a nicer car than they can afford to keep up appearances.
Terms of familiarity without favour
Pip can spend time with Estella and talk casually with her, but she doesn't actually care about him or treat him as special. He has access but no real relationship. It's the worst kind of friendzone - close enough to hope, never close enough to matter.
Modern Usage:
Like being the person someone texts when they're bored but never invites to important events, or the coworker who's friendly at lunch but never gets promoted.
Instrument of revenge
Miss Havisham deliberately raised Estella to break men's hearts as payback for her own broken heart. Estella became a weapon, not a person with her own feelings. She was programmed to hurt others without being able to feel love herself.
Modern Usage:
Like parents who turn their kids against the ex-spouse in a divorce, or people who use others to get back at someone who hurt them.
Seclusion
Miss Havisham's self-imposed isolation from the world after being jilted. She shut herself away in her decaying house, refusing to move on or heal. Her seclusion became a prison of her own making.
Modern Usage:
Like people today who isolate themselves after a bad breakup or trauma, scrolling social media but avoiding real human connection.
Tease other admirers
Estella uses Pip's presence to make her other suitors jealous and work harder for her attention. She plays men against each other, using one to manipulate the others. It's a calculated game of emotional manipulation.
Modern Usage:
Like someone who keeps their ex around on social media to make their current partner jealous, or flirts with multiple people to keep their options open.
Haunted by my ghost
Pip is so obsessed with Estella that he feels like his spirit never leaves her house, even when his body is elsewhere. He's emotionally trapped in a place that brings him nothing but pain.
Modern Usage:
Like constantly checking someone's social media or driving by their house after a breakup - your mind can't leave even when your body does.
Characters in This Chapter
Pip
Tormented protagonist
Pip finally understands he's been played - that his love for Estella was part of Miss Havisham's revenge plot all along. He's horrified but still can't stop loving her, even knowing she's using him to hurt other men.
Modern Equivalent:
The person who knows they're in a toxic relationship but can't walk away
Estella
Cold-hearted victim-turned-weapon
Estella reveals her true nature in a brutal confrontation with Miss Havisham. She admits she can't love because she was never taught how, and coldly tells her adoptive mother she created exactly what she wanted - a heartless woman.
Modern Equivalent:
The person raised by bitter parents who taught them never to trust or love anyone
Miss Havisham
Desperate manipulator facing consequences
Miss Havisham finally realizes the horrible irony of her revenge - she trained Estella so well to be unloving that now Estella can't love her either. She's destroyed herself and others in pursuit of vengeance.
Modern Equivalent:
The parent who realizes too late that their toxic behavior created the very distance they feared
Bentley Drummle
Threatening rival suitor
This brutal, unpleasant man begins pursuing Estella seriously, and she encourages him despite Pip's warnings. His presence represents the worst possible outcome for Estella - marriage to someone who might actually harm her.
Modern Equivalent:
The obviously bad guy your friend starts dating despite everyone's warnings
Mrs. Brandley
Social facilitator
She provides Estella with a respectable home and social connections, but there's no real warmth between them. It's a business arrangement disguised as family care.
Modern Equivalent:
The foster parent or guardian who provides the basics but no real emotional support
Why This Matters
Connect literature to life
This chapter teaches how to recognize when someone's coldness toward you is actually about their own unhealed wounds and someone else's agenda.
Practice This Today
This week, notice when someone's harsh treatment feels disproportionate to your interaction - ask yourself what pain they might be carrying from someone else.
You have the foundation. Now let's look closer.
Key Quotes & Analysis
"I am what you have made me. Take all the praise, take all the blame; take all the success, take all the failure; in short, take me."
Context: Estella coldly tells Miss Havisham that she is exactly the unloving person she was raised to be
This is Estella's devastating truth bomb to Miss Havisham. She's saying 'you wanted a weapon, you got one - but weapons don't have feelings.' It shows how cycles of hurt create more victims, not justice.
In Today's Words:
You made me this way, so don't complain about what you created.
"So hard, so hard! What have I done? What have I done?"
Context: Miss Havisham's anguished realization that her revenge plot has backfired completely
This shows Miss Havisham finally understanding that her need for revenge has destroyed everyone, including herself. She's created a monster she can't control and lost any chance of real love or happiness.
In Today's Words:
Oh God, what have I done to everyone, including myself?
"You will get me out of your thoughts in a week."
Context: Estella dismissively tells Pip he'll get over her quickly
This shows Estella's complete inability to understand real love or emotional attachment. She can't fathom that Pip's feelings are genuine because she's never experienced genuine emotion herself.
In Today's Words:
You'll forget about me and move on in no time.
Intelligence Amplifier™ Analysis
The Weapon Maker's Curse
When you shape someone into an emotional weapon for revenge, you become their primary victim because weapons cannot discriminate between targets.
Thematic Threads
Revenge
In This Chapter
Miss Havisham's revenge plot backfires spectacularly as Estella cannot love her creator any more than her victims
Development
Evolution from mysterious benefactor motives to revealed devastating consequences of using people as instruments of vengeance
In Your Life:
You might see this when holding grudges ends up poisoning your own relationships more than hurting your target.
Identity
In This Chapter
Estella declares she is exactly what Miss Havisham made her to be—incapable of genuine feeling
Development
Builds on Pip's identity crisis by showing how others can be molded into false selves for someone else's agenda
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize you've been performing a role others expected rather than being authentic.
Love
In This Chapter
Estella reveals she deceives all her suitors except Pip, yet cannot love him either due to her emotional programming
Development
Deepens from Pip's unrequited love to expose how love cannot exist where emotional capacity has been systematically destroyed
In Your Life:
You might see this when someone claims they 'don't know how to love' due to their upbringing or past trauma.
Class
In This Chapter
Estella chooses the brutish Drummle over Pip, showing how class trumps character in her calculated choices
Development
Continues theme of how social status influences romantic choices, but now reveals it as deliberate manipulation rather than natural preference
In Your Life:
You might notice this when people choose partners based on status or security rather than genuine connection.
Manipulation
In This Chapter
The full scope of Miss Havisham's manipulation is revealed—she used both Pip and Estella as pawns in her revenge scheme
Development
Escalates from hints of mysterious motives to full exposure of a decades-long manipulation campaign
In Your Life:
You might recognize this when you realize someone has been pulling strings behind the scenes to orchestrate your choices.
Modern Adaptation
When the Mentor Becomes the Enemy
Following Pip's story...
Pip continues his painful relationship with Estella, now working at a prestigious consulting firm after her MBA. He visits their old neighborhood where Ms. Harrison, the wealthy widow who's been funding his education, still lives. A explosive fight erupts between Estella and Ms. Harrison. Estella coldly explains she can't give the gratitude and affection Ms. Harrison craves because she was taught that emotions are weaknesses in business. 'You made me this way,' Estella says. 'You wanted me to be ruthless with men who'd use me, so I became ruthless with everyone.' Ms. Harrison realizes her plan to create a strong, independent woman backfired - Estella treats her with the same calculated coldness she shows everyone else. Meanwhile, Brad, a arrogant investment banker, starts pursuing Estella aggressively. When Pip protests, Estella admits she manipulates all her suitors for networking and career advancement - except Pip, whom she simply ignores. Pip finally understands he was never the point; he was just collateral damage in someone else's revenge story.
The Road
The road Miss Havisham walked in 1861, Pip walks today. The pattern is identical: when you teach someone to weaponize relationships, you become their first casualty.
The Map
This chapter provides a crucial navigation tool for recognizing when you're caught in someone else's revenge cycle. Pip can use it to identify when his struggles aren't really about him.
Amplification
Before reading this, Pip might have kept trying to win Estella's love, thinking he wasn't good enough. Now he can NAME the manipulation, PREDICT that weapons don't discriminate, and NAVIGATE by stepping out of someone else's war.
You now have the context. Time to form your own thoughts.
Discussion Questions
- 1
What does Estella tell Miss Havisham about why she can't love her, and how does Miss Havisham react to this revelation?
analysis • surface - 2
Why does Miss Havisham's plan to use Estella as revenge against men end up hurting Miss Havisham herself the most?
analysis • medium - 3
Where do you see this pattern today - people who create harsh environments to 'toughen others up' but then wonder why no one shows them warmth?
application • medium - 4
If you were Pip's friend watching him pursue someone who openly admits she's incapable of love, what would you tell him and how would you approach that conversation?
application • deep - 5
What does this chapter reveal about how the way we treat others programs them to treat us back?
reflection • deep
Critical Thinking Exercise
Map Your Relationship Patterns
Think about a relationship where you feel like you're not getting the warmth, respect, or attention you want. Write down how you typically interact with that person - your tone, your level of openness, what you withhold or freely give. Then honestly assess: are you modeling the behavior you want to receive back?
Consider:
- •Consider whether you're withholding trust or warmth as protection
- •Notice if you're trying to 'teach lessons' through emotional distance
- •Look for ways you might be programming the very behavior you dislike
Journaling Prompt
Write about a time when someone treated you exactly the way you had been treating them, and you suddenly realized the connection. How did that awareness change your approach?
Coming Up Next...
Chapter 39: The Convict's Return
Moving forward, we'll examine past actions can return to reshape our entire future, and understand the difference between gratitude and obligation in relationships. These insights bridge the gap between classic literature and modern experience.